The AL Central turned out to be quite a surprising division. The best team in the league resides here, and it’s the Royals, not the Tigers. Kansas City leads the division by 4 1/2 games, and at this point there is little competition for the division title.
Royals
The Royals have all the makings of a great team. They rank fourth in the AL in runs scored per game at 4.52 R/G, and first in the AL in runs allowed per game, 3.69 RA/G. They are good against teams with records of at least .500 (24-19) and kill the others (28-15).
My impression of the team coming into the season was one that overachieved in 2014, and that would cause them to slide in 2015. Instead, they built on that success, especially the hitters.
Drilling down a bit, the Royals have an advantage at the start and end of innings. With no one on or out, Royals pitchers allow a .216/.278/.374 slash line. They have allowed 22 home runs, but those were all solo shots. With two out and men in scoring position, they allow a .179/.271/262 slash line. The Royals defensively are good at not starting trouble, and getting out of the trouble when it occurs.
The batters do well in those situations. With none on or out, they hit .270/.319/.391 with 13 homers. With two out and RISP, they hit .295/.365/.459. They get an offensive sequence started earlier than their opponents, and they keep it rolling.
On top of all that, they are the best defensive team in the the AL in terms of UZR per 150. That allows the pitchers to post one of the lowest strike out rates in the league without getting hurt. At this point in the season, it will be tough to keep them out of the playoffs.
Twins
The Twins are pretty much an average team. They score 4.30 runs per game, just a bit above the 4.23 runs per game league average. They allow 4.04 runs per game, just below the 4.13 league average. Their UZR per 150 sits at 3.3, seventh out of 15 teams. They’re a little above average in these areas, which leads to a winning record.
The team, however, really shouldn’t be outscoring their opponents. The Twins are hitting .254/.307/.400 while the Twins pitchers allow a .269/.319/.417 line. On top of that, opponents are much better at stealing that the Twins. Minnesota base runners were successful 44 times in 75 attempts, 58.7%. Opponents stole 52 bases in 67 attempts, 77.6%. There’s nothing in the overall stat lines that indicate the Twins should be winning.
The Twins are doing well due to situational hitting. Batters post a .283/.350/.442 slash line with runners in scoring position, pitchers allow a .258/.336/.388 slash line in the same situation. It’s enough to make the difference between winning and losing.
One sign that the Twins might not regress to runs more in line with their overall numbers is that Joe Mauer is starting to pick up. Over his last 25 games Mauer posted numbers much more in line with his career standards. A second half like that would give the offense a very nice boost.
Tigers
I’ve long considered Dave Dombrowski one of the smartest general managers in baseball, but he made a huge mistake in extending the contracts of two players with no need. Both Justin Verlander and Miguel Cabrera signed contract extensions with two year left on good deals, and with injuries suffered by both players, those contracts seem excessive. If the team let Verlander play out his contract, the Tigers could have used that money to keep Max Scherzer. If they had let the Cabrera contract play out, they might have realized that he was not going into his 30s a healthy player, and signed him to a shorter term deal to keep him in uniform.
The money in those two contracts, with the players missing large swaths of the season, makes it difficult for the Tigers to correct mid-course. The offense was good in first half, third in the American League with 4.52 runs per game. It’s tough to believe they and maintain that without Cabrera.
The pitching, without a good Verlander, ranks poorly. They allowed 4.69 runs per game, second highest in the AL. A staff that was known for blowing away batters is striking out just 7.0 per nine innings, fourth lowest in the AL. Things seem to be getting worse, with a 6.16 team ERA in July.
The plan was to get Michael Ilitch a World Series trophy. Dombrowski will need to rebuild the team quickly for that to happen. I expect the Tigers to be sellers at the trade deadline, and they probably won’t make the playoffs this season.
Indians
The Indians offense appears to be trying to prove that a team can walk too much. The Indians lead the AL with 309 walks, helping them to a good .320 OBP. The problem is they don’t hit. Their 728 hits is the fourth lowest total in the AL. They also don’t hit many home runs, which would move some of those walkers home. Their 71 HR represents the third lowest total in the AL. (Despite all the walks, only 49 of their 71 homers came with men on base.) Put that all together and they score just 3.94 runs per game, fourth lowest in the AL.
With that kind of offense, the team needs good pitching and defense. They allow 4.16 runs per game just a bit above league average. That’s odd, too. They strikeout batters at the highest rate in the league, and their FIP is the lowest in the league. If they were posting the lowest ERA in the league, they might be on the winning side of .500 and in the race.
It’s a conundrum. The team shows good selectivity at the plate, but they don’t score. The pitchers blow away batters, but they don’t prevent runs. Maybe the team needs the equivalent of Joe Carter and Tommy John on the roster. I would not be surprised to see a break out in the second half, but it could also be that abilities of the players don’t mesh well with each other.
White Sox
The White Sox played seven games better than their Pythagorean projection and are still 11 games out. This is a poor team that, hard to believe, benefited from a great deal of luck so far in 2015.
The offense is dreadful, scoring just 3.40 runs per game, worst in the AL. With a .241/.294/.355 slash line, they hit the trifecta of not hitting for average, not getting on base, and not hitting for power. The same group of players owns the worst UZR/150 in the league as well. They can neither hit nor field. Nor can they run stealing just 28 bases in 51 attempts. Ugh.
The pitching isn’t that bad, but with all the balls finding holes in the defense, the White Sox ERA is well above their ERA, just like in Cleveland. The team is a hot mess that is not easily going to be fixed at the trade deadline. A winter of work that appeared to improve the team goes down the drain.
Outlook
The Tigers look like toast, the White Sox probably get worse, and the Twins are playing above their heads. Even if Cleveland can turn their strengths into runs and run prevention, 11 games is a long way to go to catch a good Royals team. I won’t be surprised if the order of finish is KC, Cleveland, Minnesota, Detroit, and Chicago, with all those teams well behind the Royals.