Tag Archives: George Brett

June 18, 2024

Best Living

With the passing of Willie Mays, it’s a tough decision on who takes the mantle of greatest living ballplayer. When Joe DiMaggio died, Mays was pretty much a lock to take over. It may very well be Barry Bonds, which would be fitting since Mays was a second father to him. I don’t think people would go for that due to the steroid issue, however. It might also be Pete Rose, who has his own scandals weighing on him.

A friend and I are spit-balling names, and our list includes, in no particular order:

Griffey would fit the mold of the great centerfielder. Ryan pitched extremely well into his 40s. Ripken transformed the position of shortstop. Brett and Schmidt were great hitters and great defenders at the hot corner. Henderson was known for his speed, but hit for plenty of power. Pujols and Trout simply put runs on the board. Maddux may be the best pitcher I’ve ever seen. Cabrera led the Marlins to a World Series title his rookie year and went on to win a triple crown.

I’m sure you can think of others, please leave names in the comments. I think this is a much tougher choice than we faced in the late 1990s.

Update: Should have included Reggie Jackson and Derek Jeter.

July 24, 2023

The Pine Tar Game

Today is the 40th anniversary of the Pine Tar Game, in which George Brett temporarily lost a home run because the pine tar on his bat was too high toward the barrel. The announcers discussed this during the Sunday Night Baseball broadcast, but they left out a reason the Yankees thought they could get Brett. Years before, Lou Piniella lost a hit (I believe it was in Minnesota) because the Twins complained he had too much pine tar on the bat. So there was precedent for taking away a hit, and the Yankees had suffered it. (I watched both games, so when they took away Brett’s homer, I was not surprised.)

The announcers did make a point that I hadn’t heard before. Eduardo Perez noted that pine tar was used to hide alterations to the bat that would help with putting spin the batter ball. Not:

The rulebook provision was meant to avoid dirtying too many baseballs, not to affect the outcome of a play or game.

ESPN.com

I suspect MLB did not want to promote the idea that batters were cheating, just like they underplayed steroid use for years. Dirty baseball strike me as a convenient cover story.

November 27, 2022

The Power of In Play

Cyril Morong notes that Joe DiMaggio is the only player with at least fifty home run in road games to collect more home runs than strikeouts away from home. This represents a great lesson for power hitters on the value of limiting strikeouts. DiMaggio hit .334/.405/.611 in road games. His BABIP came in at .310, but his BABNIP (HR/(HR+K)) came in at .505. So he hit 24 points above his BABIP. It’s tough to find that kind of batting average enhancement today from home runs and strikeouts.

The closest thing we may have to this kind of BA/BABIP ratio comes off the bat of Nolan Arenado. Arenado, who strikes out at about 14% for his career, owns a number of seasons in which he posted a higher BA than BABIP. Still, for his career, his BABIP stands at .292 and his BA at .289.

One thing that would be extremely exciting for the game would be a run at a .400 BA. That’s possible if a player can combine a high BABIP with a good number of home runs and few strikeouts.

In the last 45 years MLB saw three runs at .400. Rod Carew in 1977 may have been the last real run at that average when he hit .388. Carew reached that mark in a full season, coming to the plate 694 times. George Brett in 1980 hit .390, but with forty-five games missed barely qualified for the batting title with 515 PA. Tony Gwynn hit .394 in the strike-shortened 1994 season when he came to the plate 475 times.

Carew hit his .388 with a BABIP of .408, hitting 14 home runs. Gwynn’s .394 came on BABIP of .389, hitting 12 home runs. Only Brett was DiMaggio like, hitting .390 on a .368 BABIP. He smacked 24 home runs while striking out just 22 times.

Ichiro Suzuki at his best hit .372 on a BABIP of .399. He did not strikeout much, just 63 times, low by modern standards. With just eight home runs, however, his BABNIP was a drag on his batting average.

So how do we engineer a George Brett, someone who combines the BABIP and power of Mike Trout with the in play skills of Luiz Arraez? Would it be possible to get Fernando Tatis Jr.or Bo Bichette to cut their strikeouts in half? Or is it just impossible with modern pitchers and bullpen usage not to strike out a ton?

MLB keeps experimenting with rules at the minor league level, mostly to improve the pace of the game. The limited shifts rule for the 2023 season serves the purpose of producing more base hits on balls in play. That will help in the quest for a .400 hitter. Maybe MLB should think of rule changes in terms of producing a .400 hitter. How does the game either devalue strikeouts or increase the incentives for balls in play? That to me is the next big problem to solve after pace of play.

May 15, 2015

Gordon and Brett

A reader asked for other .400 probability charts from the past to compare to Dee Gordon. Here’s George Brett from 1980. George was helped by an injury that gave him the chance to hit .400 in a small sample size. After going 2 for 4 on 9/19/1980, Brett was at .400, but went 14 for 46 the rest of the way to finish at .390. With four games to go, it became nearly impossible for Brett to reach .400.

Gordon is 2 for 2 so far on Friday.

July 25, 2013

Brett Steps Aside

George Brett decided not to continue as the Royals hitting coach. Players are disappointed. Here’s Eric Hosmer:

“At the end of the day it stinks he’s leaving,” Hosmer said, “but the good thing is he’ll still around for home games. I’m disappointed. We’re going to miss him in the dugout. He’s expressed to us about he’s a phone call away.”

Pedro Grifol takes over as the full time hitting coach:

While Brett was fixing the mental part of the Royals, Grifol was doing the behind-the-scenes work on players’ mechanics, poring over video and tinkering with their swings.

The 43-year-old began his first season with the Royals as the hitting coach of the Surprise Royals. Before that, he was a manager for Class A High Desert in the Seattle organization, and had worked as an area scout, manager and minor league director over the past 13 seasons.

Now, Grifol has the chance to make a name for himself as the hitting coach.

Hosmer seems to be back on track. The rest of the team doesn’t seem to be much better.

July 9, 2013

Pine Tar Story

BBTF links to a Wall Street Journal article on the bat boy involved in the George Brett pine tar incident.

On Tuesday at Yankee Stadium, George Brett will hold a news conference to talk about the most famous moment in his Hall-of-Fame career: the Pine-Tar Game.

Yet absent from that news conference will be a 47-year-old New York cop named Merritt Riley, who feels personally responsible for the pine-tar debacle.

“I really believe the Pine-Tar Game would never have happened if I hadn’t done what I did,” said Riley.

It’s a great story with insight into George Brett’s personality. Well worth the read.

Sometimes lost in the story is that the Yankees had every reason to believe that they could take a hit away from Brett this way. A few years earlier, Thurman Munson lost a hit in Minnesota when his bat was challenged for pine tar. It was a single early in the game, so the Yankees didn’t make a big deal out of the ruling.

Umpires in another game had not disallowed a home run on a pine tar violation, and Lee McPhail agreed, noting that the rule was intended to keep balls clean, not prevent an unfair advantage to hitters. I tend to disagree. If the league wanted to keep balls clean, it should have been up to the umpires to notice too much pine tar and tell the hitters the bats were illegal. If the league wanted the other side to call hitters on this, then an out is an appropriate penalty.

These type of things irk me. The batting out of order rule is extremely convoluted, to force an opposing manager to form a strategy when the opposing team is doing something illegal.

Rule 6.07 Comment: The umpire shall not direct the attention of any person to the presence in the batter?s box of an improper batter. This rule is designed to require constant vigilance by the players and managers of both teams. There are two fundamentals to keep in mind: When a player bats out of turn, the proper batter is the player called out. If an improper batter bats and reaches base or is out and no appeal is made before a pitch to the next batter, or before any play or attempted play, that improper batter is considered to have batted in proper turn and establishes the order that is to follow.

A much simpler rule would be “if an improper batter sees a pitch, the improper batter is out.” That rule would be enforced by the umpires, which after all is their freaking job! Same with the appeal play when a runner advances on a fly ball. If he leaves the base early, the umpires should not rule him safe at the base he attains. Stop wasting time making the other team do the job of the umpires.

June 14, 2013

Short Term Brett

Sam Mellinger write on how the current Kansas City road trip might decide George Brett‘s willingness to continue as the Royals hitting coach:

“When I retired, it wasn’t because I couldn’t play anymore,” Brett says. “I was still a good hitter. Not what I was, but I led the team in RBIs my last year. I retired because I got tired of the travel and being away from my family.”

One moment from back then particularly sticks in Brett’s memory. A road trip to Seattle, late in his career. He’d always told his wife how beautiful it was there, so she flew ahead to meet him. The Royals played the night before in another city – Brett can’t remember exactly where, which is sort of the point – and didn’t get to the hotel until 4 in the morning. He thought then this was no way to spend the rest of his life.

He thinks about that now, too.

If Brett’s coaching is working, I suspect he doesn’t need to be there all the time. He can do a lot of instruction in KC, and skip some of the trips. With all games broadcast, he’ll see what players are doing right and wrong during games. KC has an assistant coach, and he could make the long road trips. I don’t think it needs to be stay or go. There is a compromise position.

May 30, 2013

Someone Who Could Hit

The Royals hired George Brett as their interim hitting coach:

Hall of Famer George Brett was appointed the club’s interim hitting coach Thursday and will join the team in time for their game against the St. Louis Cardinals. Brett takes over for Jack Maloof and Andre David, who have been reassigned to the minor league organization.

This will be Brett’s first in-season coaching role, though he’s been the franchise’s vice president of baseball operations since retiring as a player following the 1993 season. He’s also worked as a volunteer coach at spring training for years.

“I’m thankful that this organization has one of the greatest hitters and more importantly one of the greatest competitors our game has ever seen in George Brett, and he has accepted our offer to join the coaching staff on an interim basis,” Royals general manager Dayton Moore said.

I can’t argue with the choice. Brett was one of the great hitters of his generation. He started out as a high average/OBP player, but by his prime developed excellent power, taking advantage of the extra-base hit opportunities at Kaufman Stadium. He hit 665 doubles and 137 triples, leading the league in the latter category three times. We’ll see what he can do as a coach.

March 4, 2013

Tarring Brett

George Brett has some fun with Jeff Francoeur and Alex Gordon as the latter two show fans how to pine tar a bat.

Brett gets off a great zinger, which might have hit a little too close to home for Fancoeur. At about the 1:08 mark, George says to Jeff:

Jesus, you’ve have two good years!

George looks like he can still hit .300.

March 17, 2011

Shouldering the Burden

Via Rob Neyer, Joe Posnanski lists the players who did the most offensively to carry their teams to a World Series victory since 1946. The gist of the post is to pay homage to George Brett and his amazing 1985 season. However, I come away impressed even more with Derek Jeter, who manages to make the top ten on despite playing for extremely good offensive teams.