The division preview series continues with the AL Central. The starting point for my analysis is the 2012 WAR of the position players, the starting rotation and the closer. All WAR numbers come from FanGraphs. The Royals play the White Sox and the Tigers play the Twins to start division play at 4 PM EDT Monday.

Miguel Cabrera and Justin Verlander combined for nearly 14 WAR in 2012. Photo: Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports
Detroit Tigers
- Position Player WAR: 31.6
- Pitcher WAR: 21.9
- Total: 53.5
I added this three times to make sure it was right. Fifty three and a half WAR would give the Tigers 100 wins without contributions from anyone else. This includes a 0.0 for Victor Martinez, who didn’t play in 2012. Is the number reasonable? Omar Infante is coming off a 3.0 WAR, the best of his career. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him drop to a one. Jhonny Peralta turned in a 2.5. He’s getting older, but that’s not an unreasonable number. Torii Hunter‘s 5.1 seems very high for someone in his late 30s. I’d say a two is more likely this season.
The pitchers are all good. Maybe Anibal Sanchez breaks down again, and his 3.6 disappears. Maybe Rick Porcello pitches more like a fifth starter and drops two WAR. So maybe there is an excess of ten wins from career years.
Fine, but you also have to add two or three back for Victor Martinez and Al Alburquerque playing full seasons. The Tigers are probably a mid-40s teams in WAR, and they should end up with the best record in the AL. This is a magnificent squad.
Chicago White Sox
- Position Player WAR: 17.1
- Pitcher WAR: 14.0
- Total: 31.1
Adam Dunn recovered from his poor 2011, while Paul Konerko fells from his good season that year. Both came in under 2.0 WAR at positions that should generate a ton of offense. Age appears to be catching up both these sluggers. Looking at the rest of the order, I don’t see much upside.
The strength of the team is the starting rotation. Sale and Peavy give them an excellent 1-2 punch at the top of the rotation. The upside here belongs to Dylan Axelrod, who projects to excellent walk and home run numbers as the fifth starter.
Maybe Gordon Beckham finally figures out how to play. Tyler Flowers gets to catch for a full season, and that might add some wins. If Alexrod, Beckham, and Flowers play well, the team has a chance at a wild card slot.
Kansas City Royals
- Position Player WAR: 15.6
- Pitcher WAR: 8.6
- Total: 24.2
I’m not sure what to make of the Royals. The remain a young team with good players in Alex Gordon, Billy Butler, Mike Moustakas, Lorenzo Cain, and Salvador Perez. Eric Hosmer posted a -1.6 WAR in 2012, and it’s tough to believe he’s that bad long term. There’s plenty of room for upside. Unfortunately, they still trot out Jeff Francoeur and Jonathan Sanchez, who just are not very good. There’s upside, but I’d be happier with the team if those two names were gone and two 0.0 WAR players were given jobs. Even if things break right, I don’t think this is the year for the Royals.
Cleveland Indians
- Position Player WAR: 22.4
- Pitcher WAR: 4.2
- Total: 26.6
I like that Cleveland finally gave up on Grady Sizemore and Travis Hafner. I appreciate the loyalty, but waiting for those two players to overcome injuries kept Cleveland from making moves that could have improved the team. Now they’ve picked up Nick Swisher and Michael Bourn, which gives them a good core of position players. Lonnie Chisenhall has a chance to give them an improvement at third as well.
The rotation, however, has the most upside potential. Ubaldo Jimenez showed signs of regaining his control this spring. Brett Myers returns to a starting role. Scott Kazmir worked his way back to the majors. If those three can post a 2.0 WAR each, the Indians are competing with Chicago for second place and a possible wild card spot. I like what the front office is trying here. We’ll see if it works.
Minnesota Twins
- Position Player WAR: 9.5
- Pitcher WAR: 4.3
- Total: 13.8
The Twins have upside potential simply due to a number of their players having not played much in 2012. That said, a number of them posted negative WARs in their short time on the field, and a lot more of a negative isn’t a good thing. The Twins should do better in 2013, but at the moment they don’t look like they have the talent to compete.
Keep your eye on Justin Morneau. If he has finally recovered from his concussion, they should score a bit from the combination of Justin and Joe Mauer.
Predictions:
Here’s how I see the probability of each team winning the division:
- Tigers 60%
- White Sox 20%
- Indians 9%
- Royals 8%
- Twins 3%
I’m probably underestimating the Tigers here, but teams can be devastated by injuries quickly. That may be the only thing that can stop them.