The division continues with the AL Central. I try to get a handle on the wins for the core of the team. That includes the starting position players, the starting rotation, and the closer. I use a combination of the STATS, Inc. depth charts and the CBSSports depth charts, along with news stories to determine those groups. For wins, I use FanGraphs WAR from 2013, making conservative guesses for players not in the majors in 2013. As a rule of thumb, add 50 to the core WAR to get to a season win level. You can see the spreadsheet with the data here.
Detroit Tigers
- Position Player WAR: 19.9
- Starters and Closer: 25.4
- Core Total: 45.3
The Tigers starting pitching in 2013 was very good. Almost… suspiciously good. 🙂 Justin Verlander, Max Scherzer, and Anibal Sanchez harkened back to the glory days of Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, and John Smoltz in Atlanta. Three starters pitching like superb aces strikes me as difficult to repeat. With Verlander coming off surgery, I would expect that core pitching WAR of 25.4 won’t be repeated. Even if they fell off seven WAR, however, they would still be the best in the division by a long shot.
The Tigers rearranged their infield, trading for Ian Kinsler and moving Miguel Cabrera into the hole left by Prince Fielder. We may see Cabrera’s value drop a bit this season, for a number of reasons.
- He’s older, and should start declining.
- At first base, he gets a negative position adjustment compared to third base.
- Possible lingering effects from his late season injury in 2013.
Mitigating #2 would be that he can do less defensive damage at first base than at third. If Cabrera does slow down a bit, he’s likely still good enough to make the offense great.
If the pitching stands up, the Tigers win the division easily. If not, we could see an interesting race in the division.
Cleveland Indians
- Position Player WAR: 19.4
- Starters and Closer: 8.5
- Core Total: 27.9
The Indians look like they are taking a step backward in 2013. After resurrecting the career of Ubaldo Jimenez, the Indians allowed him to leave as a free agent, leaving a bit of a hole in the rotation. They decided that Carlos Santana is no longer their catcher, and installed him at third base, moving Lonnie Chisenhall to designated hitter. I would think they could do better than Lonnie with a little work. Asdrubal Cabrera and John Axford bouncing back from poor years would add a few wins to the team total, but I just don’t see too much upside here.
One advantage for Cleveland (and the Royals, for that matter), is they get to play the Twins and White Sox a lot. Those two teams are very poor, and the wins against them should keep both these squads in the wild card race.
Kansas City Royals
- Position Player WAR: 21.2
- Starters and Closer: 12.7
- Core Total: 33.9
The Royals would be my surprise pick to win the division. Where the 45.3 2013 core WAR for the Tigers I see as a ceiling, the 33.9 core WAR for the Royals looks like a floor. The core of this team are in their primes, and I can imagine Salvador Perez, Eric Hosmer, Alcides Escobar, and Lorenzo Cain improving. Combine that with Billy Butler bouncing back from a poor power season, and I can see this group increasing their core total by seven wins. If the Tigers fall off by that much, there is now a race in the AL Central.
The Royals built this team to get to this point, and I hope they are willing to make the adjustments needed during the season to them over the top.
Minnesota Twins
- Position Player WAR: 6.7
- Starters and Closer: 9.4
- Core Total: 16.1
The Twins probably aren’t this bad, but there’s not a lot of evidence to the contrary. That said, it looks like Aaron Hicks and Oswaldo Arcia will get to play. They received enough playing time in 2013 that I don’t want to adjust their numbers, but their minor league statistics indicate they should be much better than replacement level. I’d love to see Josmil Pinto get most of the starts at catcher, and have the Twins use Kurt Suzuki as a back up and defensive coach to teach Pinto the art of working behind the plate (as Bill Dickey did with Yogi Berra).
The pitching staff looks okay, with Kyle Gibson offering plenty of upside. He’s the kind of low walk pitcher the Twins love, but in the minors he combined that with high strike out rates. He should take some pressure off the defense.
Still, even if everything breaks right for the Twins, they just lack the talent to make a run at the playoffs.
Chicago White Sox
- Position Player WAR: 7.8
- Starters and Closer: 11.0
- Core Total: 18.8
The White Sox core WAR is exactly the same as the Cubs. That means a very long summer of baseball in the Windy City.
The White Sox do have upside, as does any core that adds up that poorly. I rated Jose Abreu as a 2.0 WAR, because the White Sox are paying him like a 2.0 WAR player. They hope they got a bargain here, and if so, he’ll add some offense. Combine that with the possibility of Adam Eaton returning to a high OBP, and you have a nice combination at the top of the order for scoring and driving in runs.
On the pitching side, the upside belongs to a bounce back season from John Danks and continued improvement by Jose Quintana. That would give them a very good three front line starters, but with huge holes in the back of the rotation. My guess is the White Sox will perform better than in 2013, but will still fall short of the playoffs.
Probability of winning the division
- Tigers 45%
- Royals 40%
- Indians 12%
- White Sox 2%
- Twins 1%
Royals fans should be excited.