November 29, 2025

Ryan or Witt?

A friend mentioned to me that he thought Dylan Cease was more Bobby Witt than Nolan Ryan. I disagreed off the top of my head, but here are the comparisons through their age 29 seasons:

CategoryBobby WittNolan RyanDylan Cease
Innings139319351015 1/3
Strikeouts per 9 IP7.89.710.9
Walks per 9 IP5.75.53.8
HR per 9 IP0.670.511.07
ERA4.523.113.88
Through Seasonal Age 29

Ryan and Witt are much more like each other than either is like Cease. Cease owns a very high walk rate for the era, but nothing close to Ryan or Witt at the same career age. Note that the two older pitchers could get away with more walks due to the lack of power in the league compared to today. Cease’s ERA is almost halfway between Ryan and Witt (3.82).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *