Grantland posts an ESPN 30 for 30 short on the Honus Wagner card that might be a doctored.
Category Archives: Collectibles
Lettermen
I need to get one of these. I bought a Rays pullover windbreaker in 2008. I remember wearing it to Costco in Connecticut, and all the Yankees fans were appreciative as the Rays knocked the Red Sox out of the playoffs. đ
Gehrig Treasure
A failed Lou Gehrig romance led to a trove of memorabilia 80 years later. It’s a great story of a shy ball player, an over bearing mother, and the girl that got away.
Steinbrenner Letters for Sale
Michael Schriner sends along this message:
Last summer the NY Times featured a story about a 60 year old letter collection written by the future NY Yankees owner George Steinbrenner. The story highlighted excerpts of his letters that were sent to Mary Jane Elster (maiden name).
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/16/sports/baseball/16ohio.htmlThese fascinating letters revealed much about George’s formative years. After the story was published Mary Jane was asked to co-author a book and was asked to donate her letters to the Baseball Hall of Fame. Unfortunately, the Yankees intervened to block both.
According to Lonn Trost of the Yankees, the letters âWill cause untold embarrassment and damages to the Steinbrenner family and the Steinbrennersâ business interests.â
Richard Sandomir of the NY Times and Ron Blum of AP covered the Yankees response last October,
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/15/sports/baseball/15steinbrenner.html
http://abcnews.go.com/Sports/wireStory?id=11972951Over the last year Mary Jane has shared her first hand accounts about George on her blog,
http://mjschriner.wordpress.com . Over 10,000 visitors have already enjoyed her stories.Now at the age of 79, Mary Jane can no longer read her letters due to failing eyesight. Through her blog, she feels that she has shared her stories to enlighten people about George.
Since she cannot donate the letters to the Hall of Fame for all to see, she would like to make them available to a collector that will be able to share them with other fans. Anyone interested in her letter collection can contact her directly at elster.michael@yahoo.com.
Michael is Mary Jane’s son. I can see where a collector would find this a very valuable item.
Pin Money
Before players received rings for winning the World Series, a pin served to commemorate the championship. One from the 1919 Cincinnati Reds is about to go on sale:
The pin is also generating new respect for its original recipient, first baseman Jake Daubert.
The player some call âThe Best First Baseman Not in the Hall of Fameâ was the glue that held the â19 Reds togetherâpopular in the clubhouse and a terror on the field.
The Reds of that year get overlooked a bit, as the White Sox threw the series. Heinie Groh and Edd Roush were the hitting stars that year, and the top five starters posted ERAs under 2.40. The team finished second in runs per game at 4.1 and tied for fewest allowed with 2.9 per game. They were easily the best team in the NL, winning the pennant by nine games.
Juiced Bat
A rare game used bat, autographed by Ty Cobb, will go up for auction:
No autographed Cobb bats have ever been offered within the hobby, according to MEARSâ Troy Kinunen. Cobb also added the date and âLake Oscawanaâ inscription. His handwriting has been authenticated by JSA.
MEARS indicates the bat includes tobacco juice stains and is consistent with bats ordered by Cobb during the mid-1920s.
Cool, a bat spit on by Cobb.
Golden Bat
The bat Kirk Gibson swung to homer off Dennis Eckersley in the World Series sold for over half a million dollars. The proceeds benefit Kirk’s charity.
So why was this bat so valuable? Bill Mazeroski’s home run was a much higher leverage home run in terms of the series, as the Pirates went from losing to winning a World Series. While a 1-0 lead in a seven game series is important, it by no means guarantees a win.
The bat is valuable due to a convergence of low probability events resulting in a home run. First, Gibson came to the play injured. He won the MVP in 1988, but did not start the game due to injury. Second, Eckersley allowed just five home runs that season and a slugging percentage of .270. He was extremely good against lefties with a .198/.229/.286 slash line. So an injured Gibson should be no match for Eck. Add to that the homer won the game, and he hit it for a team with a gigantic fan base. Finally, people just like Kirk Gibson. He always played the game full throttle, and the played it well. It was the perfect combination to make a piece of equipment worth more than it’s weight in gold.
New Habits for Everyone!
The nuns of the School Sisters of Notre Dame did well selling their Honus Wagner card.
The nuns will receive $220,000 from the sale. The total sale price includes a 19.5 percent buyer’s premium. Sister Virginia Muller, who was entrusted with the card, says the proceeds will go to the order’s ministries in more than 30 countries around the world.
Collector and card shop owner Doug Walton bought the card.
Doug gets the double pleasure of securing a rare collectible and helping people all over the world at the same time.
Here’s my second nun story. My aunt was a nun, and when my grandmother passed away, Sister was retired in New Haven, just up the road from the family in Bridgeport, CT. She came down to stay at the convent at the family’s church, and there were a number of young nuns in the parish. That evening, she’s walking around and hears guitar playing. She walks into a room and sees the young nuns gathered around a man in a Hawaiian shirt, a good looking guy with thick red hair and a beard playing the instrument. The nuns are looking at him like he’s a rock star, and my aunt, shocked, pipes up with, “What’s going on here?” Turns out, the guitar player was the parish priest, who calmly explained that to Sister.
The next day we held the wake. For four hours we sat there, and nuns kept coming in, two or three at a time. We didn’t know until later, but my aunt’s order bussed in everyone from New Haven and New York City (where my aunt taught for many years) to go to attend. Rather than inundate us all at once, they waited in the bus in the parking lot, and came to pay their respects in dribs and drabs. We reached the end of the wake, and the nine grand children, including me, are sitting in one row when three more sisters walk in. We all thought the same thing, “There’s more of them?” when my uncle Tony, sitting behind us, says, “I didn’t think there was that much black cloth in the whole world!” We all lost it that point and started laughing, and I almost fell off my chair. đ
Nun Cents
A man left an order of nuns in Baltimore a Honus Wagner card.
When they opened the box, they found the card, with a typewritten note: “Although damaged, the value of this baseball card should increase exponentially throughout the 21st century!”
The card was unknown to the sports-memorabilia marketplace because the nuns’ benefactor had owned it since 1936.
It has a big crease in the upper right-hand corner, and three of the white borders have been cut off. It has also been laminated. But even in poor condition, a T206 Wagner card is prized by collectors, said Chris Ivy, director of sports auctions at Heritage Auction Galleries in Dallas, which is auctioning the card.
The sisters will use the money to support their international ministries.
Here’s my nun story. My father’s oldest sister became a nun. She spent most of her time teaching kindergarten in New York City, and not in the best of neighborhoods. Many years later, she was visiting her sister, and some news came on about the John Gotti trial. My cousin said something negative about Gotti, and Sister took exception. “Don’t you say anything bad about Mr. Gotti, he’s a great man.” My cousin’s family was a bit shocked. Sister then went on to tell how her convent in New York had hired a painter. They paid him up front, he worked for a day, left the place unfinished, and didn’t return. So the next Sunday, Gotti, who was a parishioner, walks in. He asks the nuns what happened. They tell him the story and ask him to pray for them. Gotti agrees to pray for them. The next day, the painter shows up, gives back all the money and finishes the job. Al because Gotti prayed for them. đ
Lost Card Collection
A reader (Ryan Duffin, via James Crabtree) sends along this story about the Washington, D.C. police working their tails off to return a baseball card collection. From the E-Mail:
This is hilarious. It seems like an Onion parody story, but CNN ran it.
The line that cracked me up was:
Breul won’t hazard a guess on their value, but he indicated some might be worth about $1.
I hope the D.C. police work this diligently on all the break-ins and other theft that occur in the city.
Thomson’s Autograph
The death of Bobby Thomson reminds Mark Simon how writing for autographs helped him learn about baseball history.
Baseball Furniture
Kristen Hudak found a coffee table for your coffee table baseball books.
Card Response
Upper Deck responds to the loss of their ability to print licensed baseball cards. They believe innovation will be lost in the industry. No doubt there is less pressure on Topps to produce a superior product.
Upper Deck Lowered
Upper Deck settles with MLB, and as Craig Calcaterra explains, this wasn’t your typical settlement:
Last rule of a settlement: if you can’t get the other guy to agree to some sort of neutral joint statement that doesn’t have someone declaring victory, it is less a settlement than it is a total reaming.
Upper Deck is paying MLB a ton of money, and for all intents and purposes, can’t produce a baseball card that even suggests a player belongs to a certain team. Someone at the company made a very bad decision.
Upper Deck Hardball
MLB is suing Upper Deck over the card company’s continued use of MLB trademarks.
Fit to a Tee
Flood of Memorabilia
Curt Flood’s estate is auctioning off memorabilia from the career of the man who first fought for free agency.
Topps on Top
Topps becomes the official trading card maker for Major League Baseball:
By dropping Upper Deck, M.L.B. hopes that Topps, under Michael D. Eisner, the former chief executive of the Walt Disney Company, can invigorate card collecting, especially with young fans. The league also believes that one cardmaker can end the confusion of competitors selling multiple card series in hobby shops and big-box stores.
âThis is redirecting the entire category toward kids,â said Eisner, who acquired the company in 2007. âTopps has been making cards for 60 years, the last 30 in a nonexclusive world that has caused confusion to the kid who walks into a Wal-Mart or a hobby store. Itâs also been difficult to promote cards as unique and original.â
Baloney. Kids are more than capable of keeping track of the various card companies. I suspect this is more about limiting supply so the company of a former major league team owner can make more money. Competition kept Topps on their toes:
Since Eisnerâs privately held Tornante Company and Madison Dearborn, a private equity company, acquired Topps, it has introduced 3-D cards, the ToppsTown trading and collecting Web site, and the Topps Attax game to appeal to young card enthusiasts and to develop new ones.
I doubt that will continue without other companies pushing new products as well. I hope Upper Deck comes up with a way to keep competing, since they still have an agreement with the MLBPA.
Collectibles for Crime
Looking for an autographed Babe Ruth baseball? Utah is the place to go:
For sale at the Utah Attorney General’s Office: A baseball autographed by Babe Ruth.
There are also bats, balls and jerseys autographed by Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, Cal Ripken Jr., Michael Jordan and John Stockton, among others.
No, the Attorney General’s Office hasn’t started its own home shopping channel. The memorabilia belonged to a former minor-league baseball team owner convicted of an investment scam who must now repay $4.6 million. Money from the memorabilia sale will go toward that restitution.
Charlene Barlow, an assistant attorney general, said her office is hoping to raise $500,000 from Thursday’s silent auction and the separate sale of a house in St. George that also belonged to the convicted scammer.
Sounds like the chance to get a piece of history at a good price.
Baseball Cards
Remember that George Scott card I received in the mail? A number of other bloggers received cards as well, and we decided it was some kind of viral marketing scheme. We were right. There’s a contest called Cardboard Fetish:
In July 2009, in conjunction with its 11th Annual Shrine of the Eternals Induction Day, the Baseball Reliquary will present Cardboard Fetish, a major exhibition celebrating baseball trading cards, past and present. The exhibition will be held at the Pasadena Central Library, Pasadena, California.
A major component of the exhibition will be a display of original and one-of-a-kind baseball trading cards designed by artists. The Baseball Reliquary is now accepting submissions for this unique exhibition in any format: original drawings, altered or manipulated cards, collages, computer-generated, etc.
Sounds like fun.
Great Scott
Someone sent me a George Scott baseball card in the mail today. There was no return address and no note. Whoever sent it, thanks!
Brush with Greatness
Kevin Rozell of Zell’s Pinstripe Blog ran into Phil Hughes on a baseball card message board and ended up scoring some autographed items. The world keeps getting smaller all the time.
No Bills for Ball
No one was willing to come up with $100,000 for the ball Jose Molina hit for the last home run at Yankee Stadium. If Jeter had hit the ball, the bidding would have been huge.
The Rabbi’s of the Ballpark
Did you know there are law enforcement professionals assigned to each ballpark to authenticate items used in a game before they are sold?
The 49-year-old Chicago police officer is not there as a fan — although he does love baseball — but as part of Major League Baseball’s program to guarantee the authenticity of game-used jerseys, balls, bats and other memorabilia it sells to fans.
At the end of the White Sox game, Cunningham will assign each item an identification number, attach a tamper-proof hologram and record its details.
Fans who pay hundreds or sometimes thousands of dollars to buy these items — usually via the Major League Baseball website — can be sure that they are getting what they pay for.
“It’s put integrity back in collectibles,” said Cunningham, one of baseball’s 130 authenticators, who also witness and authenticate the signatures of players who sign items for sale.
The program was set up after a Federal Bureau of Investigation probe into sports memorabilia in 2000 that concluded that as much as 75 percent of sports and entertainment memorabilia was fake.
I still think it’s not that difficult to fake one of these things. How many people look at the hologram and do the research to determine it’s the hologram as opposed to a forgery?
Political Cards
Upper Deck writes:
On behalf of Upper Deck, we are thrilled to announce the “Presidential Predictor” card set in the 2008 Series One Baseball release. The illustrated parodies show several of the top candidates in rare form by tying each one of them to a pivotal moment or personality from baseball’s rich history.
The candidates’ cards, inserted at a rate of 1:8 packs in Upper Deck’s 2008 Series One Baseball release, are hitting store shelves now!
Notable names in the “Presidential Predictor” set include, from the Democratic side, Barack Obama and John Edwards; and from the Republicans: John McCain, Mitt Romney, Rudy Giuliani and Fred Thompson. A few other surprise candidates and political personalities are also showcased in the collection including Al Gore being tagged out by reigning U.S. President George W. Bush in a funny portrayal of Yankee second baseman Chuck Knoblauch’s phantom tag of Boston’s Jose Offerman during the ’99 American League Championship Series.
Collectors who pull any of the Presidential Predictor cards from packs will have the opportunity to win a trip for two to throw out the “presidential” first pitch at an official Major League Baseball game during the 2009 season. They simply need to type in the static code(s) found on the backs of the cards at www.presidentialpredictor.com to gain entry into an Upper Deck Baseball sweepstakes. The top prize will be open to all collectors who register the winning candidate’s trading card. Each of the cards can be viewed at the www.presidentialpredictor.com website.
I like the Fred Thompson card.
Art Lovers
MLB commissioned Malcolm Farley to capture the Rockies run to the pennant in a series of paintings:
Farley has been commissioned by Major League Baseball to do a series of five pieces: Helton’s home run; shortstop Troy Tulowitzki turning a double play; two of Matt Holliday, including his shot over the center- field wall in the pennant-clinching victory; and a stadium piece with fireworks erupting over Denver’s night sky.
His work last week took him to Los Angeles to paint Stevie Wonder during an awards ceremony, to New York to paint Cleveland Cavaliers star LeBron James and to San Antonio, where he crossed paths with Eva Longoria, wife of Spurs guard Tony Parker.
“They’re all Rockies fans,” he said of Wonder, James and Longoria. “They’re all talking about the Rockies. It’s what’s good about baseball.”
You can see some of his other baseball work here.
Wagner, Max
The Honus Wagner card sets another record.
No Cards
This recent post about baseball cards got me in the mood to buy a pack, so when I was out this afternoon on errands, I stopped by the local CVS to buy a pack of Topps. I looked through the candy rack at the front of the store, but didn’t see any. I asked the cashier, and she told me CVS didn’t carry them anymore! I guess they’ve really lost popularity.
Baseball Musings is holding a pledge drive in March.
Nice Return
The Honus Wagner baseball card sold again, nearly doubling in price since the last transaction, going for $2.35 million:
The seller Brian Seigel in 2000 paid a then-record $1,265,000 for the prize card, which is in better condition than the rest.
“This particular one was preserved in spectacular condition,” said Joe Orlando, president of Professional Sports Authenticator of Newport Beach – the company that certified the authenticity of the card. “It’s the Holy Grail of baseball cards.”
Still, the Wagner cards are so rare that even those in much worse condition will sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars, Seigel said.
I remember the market for baseball cards was hot in the early 1990s. I didn’t trade, but I know at some point the market collapsed. Did that happen because collecting was a fad or did card companies produce too many cards trying to make a buck off the craze?
Back of the Card
Dan Wechsler sends this article on what it’s like to create the back of a baseball card.

