Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
December 04, 2008
The Manny Market

Buster Olney pens an excellent post on the choices facing Manny Ramirez.

Executives around baseball wonder if that will change in the next few days, because they are having a difficult time envisioning how Ramirez would make more in salary in 2009 than if he accepted arbitration. He made $20 million last season -- although the present-day value was just a little more than $17 million -- and following a historic performance in which Ramirez hit .396 for the Dodgers in two months, driving in 53 runs in 53 games, his arbitration award would be breathtaking. Boras would be in position to set a new and stunning standard through that process, and could ask for A-Rod money.

But accepting arbitration would represent a staggering surrender for Ramirez, who had hoped for a nine-figure contract, and for Boras, who has been talking a deal for as long as six years for the 36-year-old outfielder. One year for $28 million is a long way from 4 years, $100 million, or six years, $150 million. Some friends of Ramirez do not believe that he will allow Boras to take arbitration, as tempting as it may be. "This is not going to be an easy time for Scott," a friend of Ramirez said.

Manny is at an age where taking a big one-year deal carries the risk of a career downturn shutting him out from ever getting a second huge multi-year deal. It's also possible, however, that a series of one-year deals makes Manny much more money that he would get in a long term contract. If he's always playing for the next contract, he might put up very impressive numbers every year, and his price might keep going up.


Posted by David Pinto at 11:38 AM | Free Agents | TrackBack (0)
Comments

I see this as the exact opposite. If you look at most of the free agents out there, Manny might be in the best shape (other than CC). The economy appears to be having a much larger impact than anyone is willing to admit. With the option of arbitration, Manny now has a FLOOR for his services. Yes, its only a one year deal, but he might be one of the few FA's out there that gets a raise this year.

Posted by: Chris at December 4, 2008 12:21 PM

Given the sporadic idiocy of the current Dodger brain trust, arbitration for Manny makes me nervous--if the suits make the decision to bring up some of Manny's warts in an effort to increase their chances of winning the case, they could find themselves having lost the case *and* dealing with a sullen Manny for the 2009 season. Hopefully, their arbitration strategy will be to offer a sufficiently high number to basically guarantee that they will prevail unless Manny counters with an unexpectedly low number. Say, $25 million dollars.

Posted by: M. Scott Eiland at December 4, 2008 12:31 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?