Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
March 20, 2005
Better Living Through Medicine

Kate Zernike looks at the way drugs are used to enhance performance outside of sports and asks if these people are cheating also?

But if baseball players are cheating, is everyone else, too?

After all, Americans are relying more and more on a growing array of performance enhancing drugs. Lawyers take the anti-sleep drug Provigil to finish that all-night brief, in hopes of concentrating better. Classical musicians take beta blockers, which banish jitters, before a big recital.Is the student who swallows a Ritalin before taking the SAT unethical if the pill gives her an unfair advantage over other students? If a golfer pops a beta blocker before a tournament, is he eliminating a crucial part of competition - battling nerves and a chance of choking?

And as time goes on, the drugs are only going to get better. What's the right answer? On one hand, you have people with a vested interest in keeping PEDs out of sports; the natural athletes and people who want to protect the records of their heros (Maris didn't really break Ruth's record because he had 162 games and expansion; McGwire didn't really break Maris' record because of a juiced ball/expansion/smaller parks/diluted pitching/steroids). On the other hand if nature makes life easy for some people, why not use drugs to balance the playing field. If some excels due to naturally high levels of testosterone, why not raise other people to that level?

These are not easy questions. As always, I welcome your comments on the subject.

Baseball Musings is holding a pledge drive during March. Click here for details.


Posted by David Pinto at 02:34 PM | Cheating | TrackBack (1)
Comments

Along those lines, look at this:



Sunday, March 20, 2005
Ball Four -- Steroids and Hemmorhoids
It had been a long trial. The presentations had been complex and tedious, the witnesses long-winded and even more tedious. The courtroom was still hot, and as is more true of public buildings than any other, there was an utter lack of humidity. The static electricity that this caused as one rubbed against anything at all, was the only electricity in the room.

The judge intoned: "Okay, Counsel, so you rest. Is there anything further? ... No? Very well, then. Members of the jury, counsel have rested. There is nothing further. Well, nothing further by way of evidence. Now, we will proceed to closing arguments. This is an opportunity for counsel to sum up the evidence and present their view of how they suggest you should see the case. However, while you should pay attention to the arguments of counsel, they are not evidence, but simply the attorneys' summation of the evidence from their point of view. Alright then, Counselor Bwana, you go first, you're at bat, so to speak."

I stood and walked to the front of the jury box trying to finish off the menthol-eucalyptus lozenge I had unwrapped in a desperate attempt to compensate for the dryness of the room and the dryness of the judge.

"May it please the court. Members of the jury ...."

"Er... Excuse me counsel, will you approach the bench?"

What is going on? I haven't done ANYTHING ... yet. I look at my shoes ... no, the laces are tied. I do a surreptitious check of my fly ... the zipper is fine.

I get to the side of the bench and opposing counsel sidles up, pouring out of his amply filled garment that once looked like a suit.

"Counselor Bwana, what were you eating just before you started?"

"Oh, your Honor, that was a throat lozenge, one of those menthol-eucalyptus ones."

"Counselor, there will be no performance enhancing products used in this courtroom. I don't want you having an unfair advantage over your opponent. I don't care if it is dry in here. What we want is a clean trial here, lawyers using their natural abilities uncluttered with artificial medications and over-the-counter products to make it easier to speak to juries and fool them into believing that your eloquence is not fostered by cough drops. Lozenges ... hmmm ... there'll be none of that in this court. We'll take a break for 15 minutes and let the effects wear off before we resume."

Oh Mercy! But hadn't the judge said I was up at bat, so to speak? Gee, I don't think menthol-eucalyptus lozenges enhance reasoning power or speaking ability. But, I suppose it's a bad influence on first and second year law students to let them think that cough drops will make them incipient Clarence Darrows.

So, here's a little something about those who really get up to bat:

Congressmen ask "Did you take steroids?"
Players squirm, inflaming hemmorhoids.

Each one disclaims - he's not like Jose:
"I'm sorry, Sir. My lips are sealed
I won't say who was juiced on the field
But I promise it didn't affect their play."

These guys shouldn't be counted heroes
As role models, they are proved zeroes
So much money makes them go whacko
Or maybe it's just the chewing tobacco?

For every question McGwire avoids
Bet he wishe he'd instead sucked Altoids.


You be the judge. So to speak.

Cheerz....Bwana

More at www.breakfastwithbwana.blogspot.com

Posted by: bwana at March 20, 2005 05:13 PM

Spot on article. Roids weren't banned by baseball when these guys took them. They aren't illegal drugs, merely controlled substances (and if some quack doctor perscribed them, then they are perfectly legal). And our society is so intertwined in drugs to improve performance, why bother banning them?

Posted by: Chuck at March 21, 2005 09:48 AM

Why ban them? Because its an unfair advantage. Please don't even try to compare beta blockers and steroids. If you really must compare them, then just go ahead and take roids for the rest of your life and have a friend take beta blockers for the rest of his...we'll see if their effects are generally comparable, but we better do it fast since you'll probably be dead by 55.

You can claim that those of us crying foul over steroids just want to save our old heroes, but the fact is all of you who want to ignore it simply don't want to admit when your favorite sport is wrong.

Posted by: ksmith at March 21, 2005 12:58 PM

That's terrible one.

Posted by: Morris at December 3, 2005 11:41 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?