Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings

Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

Rank	Pitcher	Rating
1	Pedro Martinez	589.33
2	Greg Maddux	571.22
3	Roger Clemens	569.93
4	Curt Schilling	561.05
5	Mike Mussina	551.21
6	John Smoltz	546.99
7	Randy Johnson	536.58
8	Kevin Brown	529.57
9	Tom Glavine	525.38
10	Andy Pettitte	508.43
11	Brad Radke	507.5
12	Denny Neagle	506.96
13	Jeff Fassero	500.24
14	Chuck Finley	495.8
15	David Cone	487.53
16	Wilson Alvarez	484.66
17	Andy Benes	483.29
18	Ismael Valdes	481.84
19	Alex Fernandez	478.33
20	Kevin Appier	477.21
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
21	Pat Hentgen	476.36
22	Darryl Kile	476.34
23	Hideo Nomo	475.46
24	David Wells	467.52
25	Ken Hill	464.91
26	Andy Ashby	461.41
27	Al Leiter	460.53
28	Todd Stottlemyre	458.84
29	Charles Nagy	458.56
30	Jamie Moyer	458.27
31	Scott Erickson	455.82
32	Jimmy Key	455.18
33	Tim Wakefield	453.89
34	Justin Thompson	453.7
35	Orel Hershiser	451.16
36	Ramon Martinez	449.34
37	Mike Hampton	448.3
38	Shane Reynolds	443.63
39	Steve Trachsel	443.49
40	Bobby Jones	439.06
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
41	Joey Hamilton	437.99
42	Bob Tewksbury	437.17
43	Kirk Rueter	436.45
44	Mark Clark	435.6
45	Rick Reed	433.77
46	Aaron Sele	430.55
47	John Burkett	429.37
48	Scott Karl	429.34
49	Dave Burba	427.74
50	Shawn Estes	422.3
51	Francisco Cordova	422.12
52	Cal Eldred	421.92
53	Pedro Astacio	418.45
54	Tim Belcher	416.59
55	Jon Lieber	414.88
56	Chan Ho Park	409.54
57	Darren Oliver	409.07
58	Carlos Perez	408.51
59	Dustin Hermanson	408.05
60	Allen Watson	406.59
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
61	Brett Tomko	404.91
62	Woody Williams	404.53
63	Matt Morris	404.2
64	Mike Morgan	404.08
65	Bobby Witt	403.93
66	Kenny Rogers	402.4
67	Danny Darwin	397.23
68	Tom Gordon	397.01
69	Doug Drabek	396.38
70	Jaime Navarro	396.1
71	Mark Gardner	395.94
72	James Baldwin	395.92
73	Jason Schmidt	395.57
74	Jeff Juden	393.71
75	Dave Mlicki	393.7
76	Terry Mulholland	392.43
77	Frank Castillo	390.84
78	Scott Kamieniecki	389.79
79	Esteban Loaiza	389.05
80	Jose Mercedes	388.5
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
81	John Thomson	386.86
82	Chad Ogea	386.17
83	Willie Blair	385.39
84	Brian Moehler	383.21
85	Jaret Wright	382.65
86	Dennis Springer	381.99
87	Kevin Tapani	380.52
88	Tom Candiotti	379.79
89	Jeremi Gonzalez	378.81
90	Pat Rapp	376.64
91	John Smiley	376.46
92	Livan Hernandez	373.65
93	Ben McDonald	370.94
94	Mark Leiter	368.0
95	Omar Olivares	367.85
96	Sterling Hitchcock	366.6
97	Jose Rosado	366.32
98	Pete Harnisch	365.25
99	Kent Mercker	365.19
100	Steve Cooke	364.95
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
101	Mike Oquist	364.81
102	Alan Benes	364.38
103	Jason Dickson	363.74
104	Chris Holt	363.0
105	Donovan Osborne	361.26
106	Rick Helling	359.89
107	Glendon Rusch	358.95
108	Garrett Stephenson	358.67
109	Mike Remlinger	358.53
110	Roger Bailey	358.53
111	Juan Guzman	358.05
112	Roger Pavlik	356.47
113	Dwight Gooden	353.01
114	Matt Beech	352.53
115	Jeff D'Amico	348.6
116	Tony Saunders	347.77
117	Jamey Wright	344.32
118	Ken Cloude	344.02
119	Jose Lima	343.84
120	Tyler Green	342.59
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
121	Bartolo Colon	342.44
122	Ramon Garcia	342.39
123	Jeff Suppan	342.36
124	Jimmy Haynes	342.03
125	Bret Saberhagen	340.02
126	LaTroy Hawkins	339.95
127	Felipe Lira	339.45
128	Brian Meadows	339.35
129	Pete Smith	337.81
130	Kevin Millwood	335.99
131	Scott Sanders	335.14
132	Mike Sirotka	335.08
133	Masato Yoshii	332.9
134	Jack McDowell	331.96
135	Steve Avery	331.39
136	Kevin Foster	330.72
137	Brian Anderson	329.01
138	Cliff Politte	327.18
139	Hipolito Pichardo	327.18
140	Bill Swift	327.12
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
141	Jose Silva	326.26
142	Scott Eyre	325.83
143	Brian Bohanon	325.55
144	Brian Rose	325.38
145	John Halama	325.15
146	Greg Keagle	323.94
147	Paul Wagner	323.11
148	Eric Milton	322.5
149	Manny Aybar	321.2
150	Rolando Arrojo	321.0
151	David Weathers	320.91
152	Rich Robertson	319.97
153	Hideki Irabu	319.91
154	Chris Haney	318.33
155	Tim Worrell	317.8
156	Frank Rodriguez	317.75
157	Andy Larkin	317.46
158	Ramiro Mendoza	316.67
159	Mike Grace	316.39
160	Rick Gorecki	316.23
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
161	Mark Thompson	316.01
162	Eric Ludwick	315.34
163	Jason Bere	315.26
164	Jesus Sanchez	314.88
165	Sean Bergman	314.64
166	Butch Henry	312.99
167	Joel Adamson	312.46
168	Erik Hanson	311.35
169	Javier Vazquez	310.92
170	Mark Langston	310.2
171	Kerry Wood	310.14
172	Gabe White	308.82
173	Ariel Prieto	308.57
174	Trey Moore	308.03
175	Jason Johnson	307.45
176	Chris Carpenter	307.27
177	Darren Dreifort	306.75
178	Marc Valdes	306.23
179	Derek Lowe	305.42
180	Jim Pittsley	304.92
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
181	Dave Telgheder	304.12
182	Rick Krivda	303.11
183	Miguel Batista	302.8
184	Mark Portugal	302.53
185	Steve Woodard	302.13
186	Doug Johns	301.96
187	Nerio Rodriguez	301.75
188	Scott Winchester	301.14
189	Robert Person	300.43

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database

None