Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
A.J. Burnett 1011003141 34.54700615 608326302 69261571383444.428.363.821.01103.61.41
Johnny Cueto 92921032 32.50001531 531270252 72185428373154.277.253.141.2288.31.35
Jeremy Guthrie 95952031 43.41900600 593295278 8416834932254.175.242.521.2687.91.27
Ervin Santana 89888041 25.62104581 1/3578276260 74167490302204.037.592.591.15120.71.28
Vicente Padilla 71702032 19.62702413 1/3420222206 56143308306174.496.713.111.2263.51.36
Ubaldo Jimenez 1001006046 32.59002638 1/3529257243 34280584294403.438.233.95.48180.61.27
Dave Bush 85810022 32.40700473 2/3492284255 7615030529254.855.802.851.4434.31.36
John Lackey 84844037 24.60701554 2/3571269248 61159425280144.026.902.58.99108.81.32
Tim Wakefield 837031025 26.49000450 2/3444248232 56146273281274.635.452.921.1245.61.31
Randy Wolf 1011012036 31.53702620 1/3582288268 7421646427093.896.733.131.07124.61.29
Jamie Moyer 82772137 26.58701470 479240230 6712528027144.405.362.391.2870.01.29
Justin Masterson 1125421016 28.36401397 2/3393211190 36173327270184.307.403.92.8157.51.42
Justin Verlander 1011018048 35.57801665 1/3604307284 52221651269253.848.812.99.70161.81.24
Mike Pelfrey 97962138 32.54310589 635286269 4219833026744.115.043.03.6496.51.41
Fausto Carmona 79795026 33.44102456 1/3480275249 40212261262164.915.154.18.7931.31.52
Carlos Marmol 238001216 11.353600239 1238276 13158345264142.8612.995.95.4984.01.18
Chad Billingsley 99952140 32.55602588 2/3537252234 39235551250283.588.423.59.60155.41.31
Felix Hernandez 999910041 28.59402689 592246206 49221624243392.698.152.89.64241.91.18
Matt Garza 95946134 31.52313592 1/3540270254 72201467244183.867.103.051.09122.91.25
Paul Maholm 94942026 33.44101586 1/3650310286 50185360242154.395.532.84.7769.21.42
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Josh Beckett 80805035 22.61402514 1/3522268251 63134487241114.398.522.341.1089.91.28
Scott Feldman 91780430 27.52600482 1/3520288261 58166262244204.874.893.101.0836.41.42
Roy Halladay 999827058 31.652010735 2/3685244218 64104633231112.677.741.27.78271.11.07
CC Sabathia 10310314057 25.69506720 2/3629273246 57200645233153.078.062.50.71235.81.15
Ryan Dempster 98983043 27.61401622 568279241 61227567230223.498.203.28.88169.71.28
Jon Lester 97976050 23.68502621 2/3555239227 48213602231153.298.723.08.69194.01.24
Roy Oswalt 95948038 29.56704601 2/3544242230 6114449623173.447.422.15.91158.41.14
Kevin Millwood 91917026 36.41900558 638308284 74185380232174.586.132.981.1959.01.47
Jonathan Sanchez 95911230 33.47601514 2/3431246231 54259539221334.049.434.53.94110.21.34
Scott Kazmir 81810031 32.49200449 2/3430249238 64209376220244.767.534.181.2855.41.42
Max Scherzer 77680221 26.44700422 388202173 45154424221163.699.043.28.96101.41.28
Edinson Volquez 54530125 11.69400308 1/3260137124 26160320222173.629.344.67.7687.21.36
Daniel Cabrera 4539248 16.33300231 258156139 28132118222265.424.605.141.09-3.71.69
Bronson Arroyo 1001006047 34.58002636 621312293 8919241121184.155.822.721.26113.11.28
Carlos Zambrano 94782234 19.64202487 2/3446218201 35219399211183.717.364.04.65116.71.36
Jorge de la Rosa 81750034 24.58600436 2/3405234218 48200434213354.498.954.12.9977.71.39
Micah Owings 703701516 23.41010257 2/3258168160 3513019021165.596.644.541.22 3.81.51
Jon Garland 98982039 33.54200600 2/3638308275 66207335200164.125.023.10.9997.81.41
Chris Carpenter 67664033 14.70201443 386153135 2810533020042.746.702.13.57152.51.11
Jason Marquis 75742028 31.47501441 2/3466238224 39174237203154.564.833.55.7948.51.45
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Barry Zito 99982129 44.39700571 1/3549301281 57267424192124.436.684.21.9076.11.43
Wandy Rodriguez 90901034 31.52301538 511237201 51175502194123.368.402.93.85152.21.28
Tommy Hanson 55551021 15.58300330 1/3287128116 2410228919053.167.872.78.6599.11.18
Oliver Perez 65550413 16.44800306 1/3290188176 45205279191155.178.206.021.3218.11.62
Chad Gaudin 1233104116 19.45700302 2/3311180161 41128263193124.797.823.811.2232.61.45
Sean Green 16200325 9.35720158 1519080 980128192134.567.294.56.5116.81.46
James Shields 100993038 35.52102638 693335303 87143514183224.277.252.021.23105.41.31
Ricky Romero 61613027 18.60001388 381186172 33161315182243.997.313.73.7780.51.40
Rich Harden 71690024 16.60000381 309173155 52190427180143.6610.094.491.23102.21.31
Kyle Kendrick 73631425 20.55600362 2/3420217200 5011516718454.964.142.851.2423.01.48
C.J. Wilson 1573337122 16.579380324 276147130 21152295181133.618.194.22.5883.51.32
Jamey Wright 186004812 15.44400221 2/3221141113 16104148181164.596.014.22.6524.61.47
Tim Lincecum 99987049 22.69004664 2/3544225209 39228757172372.8310.253.09.53248.01.16
Joe Saunders 95955042 31.57502587 1/3621304271 75181318171144.154.872.771.1596.51.37
Gavin Floyd 94943038 32.54300586 2/3567292260 65187459171263.997.042.871.00117.21.29
Javier Vazquez 96914437 36.50700585 550284271 77170559170164.178.602.621.18114.41.23
John Lannan 89892026 36.41901531 2/3557271242 59189277172104.104.693.201.0077.51.40
Jeff Suppan 917601020 30.40000440 2/3537277250 68178221171195.114.513.641.3912.41.62
Jason Hammel 1046512124 21.53320432 2/3487236220 46124318172244.586.612.58.9652.11.41
Francisco Liriano 74690225 27.48100404 1/3405210198 37155390172184.418.683.45.8268.21.38
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Daisuke Matsuzaka 66660031 15.67400380 2/3346180172 35198341170174.078.064.68.8383.41.43
Luke Hochevar 65643019 31.38001375 420254238 44130254171185.716.103.121.06-6.11.47
Jeff Niemann 66613327 16.62803371 362182173 45128270170104.206.553.111.0966.51.32
Armando Galarraga 84772123 26.46901466 2/3453251236 73179295163114.555.693.451.4149.81.35
Carl Pavano 72728035 25.58303454 2/3503237227 558627916194.495.521.701.0963.21.30
Chris Volstad 74733027 26.50902418 1/3432224208 49155261161164.475.623.331.0554.31.40
Braden Looper 67671026 21.55301393 2/3442224205 6410920816184.694.762.491.4638.61.40
Dana Eveland 54481314 18.43800266 1/3314165157 18135164161125.315.544.56.61 6.61.69
Chad Durbin 194003611 7.61130226 20010091 2010918816053.627.494.34.8051.81.37
Dan Haren 1011016042 30.58302680 1/3641279262 77132645152363.478.531.751.02184.71.14
Zack Greinke 989810039 32.54903651 2/3616265235 50162606151173.258.372.24.69190.41.19
Joe Blanton 93920030 26.53600568 2/3615303285 79168408150114.516.462.661.2570.11.38
Joba Chamberlain 1474302316 13.55230329 1/3325163147 32137328155144.028.963.74.8766.51.40
Aaron Heilman 218006012 20.375100220 1/3216119113 28106200150144.628.174.331.1429.21.46
Matt Cain 1001009035 33.51503658 2/3571252239 63225534142243.277.303.07.86178.71.21
Cole Hamels 98985036 32.52904629 2/3584258242 7815757514043.468.222.241.11166.31.18
Ted Lilly 91911039 30.56501575 1/3503245232 8614450114993.637.842.251.35144.81.12
Nick Blackburn 94924232 34.48500560 658306276 7312026214174.444.211.931.1762.21.39
Zach Duke 92924024 45.34802557 673327296 6714728914684.784.672.381.0835.41.47
Andy Pettitte 86860039 25.60900527 2/3549265240 52172407141114.096.942.93.89103.51.37
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Brian Bannister 82811123 40.36500464 1/3534313288 67158288143295.585.583.061.30-4.01.49
Andy Sonnanstine 955412522 19.53711374 426230209 5198234140125.035.632.361.2323.41.40
Ross Ohlendorf 80550313 25.34200347 2/3357183171 47128237142174.436.143.311.2239.51.40
Shaun Marcum 56561022 15.59500346 2/3307144136 459328814063.537.482.411.1788.11.15
Anibal Sanchez 58581019 25.43201332 2/3330163146 2714327814183.957.523.87.7367.11.42
Carlos Silva 57551115 24.38500296 2/3374198192 366715914175.824.822.031.09-12.81.49
Jeremy Bonderman 50420111 15.42300252 2/3278162149 3810416114095.315.733.701.35 4.41.51
Charlie Morton 51501011 29.27501251 1/3294184167 31107169141115.986.053.831.11-13.41.60
Darren O'Day 17000468 4.66720164 1335348 104413014022.637.132.41.5555.01.08
John Danks 97972040 31.56301608 1/3555256244 61200470131103.616.952.96.90147.21.24
Edwin Jackson 97962037 32.53601606 2/3613295280 71225450131334.156.683.341.05105.31.38
Scott Baker 90901038 22.63301542 2/3537252248 71133451130174.117.482.211.18106.41.23
Hiroki Kuroda 83822028 30.48302497 471231199 40114362130223.606.562.06.72113.71.18
Brett Myers 81734128 24.53801484 1/3483229212 6715439313053.947.302.861.2597.51.32
Kevin Correia 86781225 29.46301453 487261247 52175323131134.916.423.481.0336.81.46
Kevin Slowey 73713035 20.63602406 2/3446204197 586831413074.366.951.501.2872.71.26
Todd Wellemeyer 73640423 24.48900372 2/3395209196 56154253131124.736.113.721.3538.61.47
Ryan Rowland-Smith 894701111 17.39320324 342186167 47119178132114.644.943.311.3123.81.42
Jose Contreras 1154312119 23.45240309 1/3324172154 30104233130144.486.783.03.8743.01.38
Aaron Laffey 70400414 19.42410271 305151132 2011613013274.384.323.85.6630.51.55
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Miguel Batista 1582104512 20.37540269 285162146 35157180130134.886.025.251.1718.51.64
Brandon Webb 35353022 7.75901230 2/321210189 156718513183.477.222.61.5966.81.21
Nelson Figueroa 632711013 15.46411208 2/32129789 218416813073.847.253.62.9145.11.42
Kerry Wood 1700012511 11.500620167 1/31376766 1475196131113.5510.544.03.7548.31.27
Josh Johnson 75754033 12.73300480 430164157 28133454120182.948.512.49.53161.41.17
Randy Wells 63590220 24.45500365 374164148 3311224912153.656.142.76.8179.41.33
Jarrod Washburn 56542114 23.37811329 2/3334164154 429918712034.205.112.701.1543.51.31
Brad Bergesen 49473115 17.46900293 1/3319156141 378314612324.334.482.551.1435.31.37
Garrett Olson 923701612 18.40010250 2/3289172167 42111161120126.005.783.991.51-13.61.60
Chan Ho Park 1521204311 10.52420242 1/3246125110 2688204121114.097.583.27.9742.61.38
Ian Kennedy 4341019 14.39100234 2/3213124118 3198196120194.537.523.761.1927.91.33
Brian Burres 53370211 17.39300215 1/3264150141 268911212165.894.683.721.09-11.11.64
D.J. Carrasco 14310259 3.75000210 1/32019888 127715712093.776.723.29.5141.91.32
Brandon League 168005613 15.46470186 2/31678776 1763155120183.667.473.04.8245.81.23
Chris Perez 16500766 7.462320161 2/31156155 1777171120143.069.524.29.9548.91.19
J.C. Romero 16200335 4.55640112 1/3844138 10809212223.047.376.41.8032.41.46
Cliff Lee 939317048 25.65805667 1/3654240221 4595536111142.987.231.28.61214.31.12
Mark Buehrle 1001005041 35.53901642 1/3708308283 6614634411693.974.822.05.92113.61.33
Joel Pineiro 81806132 26.55213515 553249233 489627811094.074.861.68.8484.31.26
Tim Hudson 64632030 17.63801413 363144139 3512725411183.035.542.77.76122.91.19
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Doug Davis 68680016 26.38100387 2/3418213195 44188292111224.536.784.361.0244.01.56
Jake Peavy 60603026 23.53101382 1/3324153149 38127369113103.518.692.99.89105.11.18
Brad Penny 58561120 22.47600323 2/3366195180 3910219511185.015.422.841.0821.31.45
Brian Tallet 1223002310 17.37000294 1/3305178168 4413222011035.146.734.041.3511.21.48
Jesse Litsch 40392014 15.48302231 2/3245118109 315512311054.234.782.141.2033.11.29
Darren Oliver 181102513 4.76510206 2/31816662 1453178110102.707.752.31.6172.11.13
Sean Gallagher 832301810 10.50000192 2/3206129116 2111116011235.427.475.19.98 6.31.65
Brian Bass 10140279 7.56210183 213118105 2385104110135.165.114.181.13 5.91.63
Brad Thompson 74140308 13.38100164 1/31829994 17467611195.154.162.52.93 3.81.39
Jeff Bennett 11640265 11.31230144 1527166 9799511064.125.944.94.5620.51.60
Jered Weaver 97974040 30.57102612 556262248 69174559101133.658.222.561.01153.91.19
Adam Wainwright 87877050 22.69402595 1/3524194177 44156516100122.687.802.36.67222.31.14
Ricky Nolasco 91894042 26.61801555 549281266 7511952810384.318.561.931.22106.31.20
Aaron Cook 82825033 23.58902497 558255238 43147236101114.314.272.66.7867.11.42
Aaron Harang 78753118 38.32102458 1/3530257240 75131377100174.717.402.571.4744.91.44
Trevor Cahill 62621028 21.57101375 1/3340172157 4613520810273.764.993.241.1079.51.27
David Price 60552029 13.69001351 298147129 3313730210373.317.743.51.85105.71.24
R.A. Dickey 944122217 18.48601351 363161153 36123204101263.925.233.15.9259.91.38
Rick Porcello 58580024 21.53300333 1/3364177164 4190173104174.434.672.431.1144.01.36
Nate Robertson 81520615 22.40500319 2/3392233216 4213220610196.085.803.721.18-20.61.64
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Mark Hendrickson 1413102214 19.42410314 361193176 4210119710185.045.652.891.2014.71.47
Brett Anderson 49491018 17.51401287 2/3292135114 266722510343.577.042.10.8170.31.25
John Maine 49490018 17.51400261 236141132 32130216100184.557.454.481.1038.11.40
Dustin Nippert 781801612 13.48000198 217111108 2410015610164.917.094.551.0918.61.60
Shawn Camp 16900469 10.47430191 1/31848073 175813510023.436.352.73.8045.21.26
Joakim Soria 176001546 7.4621150186 1364038 145120610271.849.972.47.6881.61.01
Fernando Rodney 183001206 14.300640184 1749391 15106163100124.457.975.18.7323.31.52
Scott Downs 18100526 11.353140178 2/31475248 105414810052.427.462.72.5062.11.12
Mitchell Boggs 85150257 8.46700159 1/31738682 1382111101114.636.274.63.7315.81.60
Jose Veras 155004512 9.57100156 1267672 208615710164.159.064.961.1533.71.36
Santiago Casilla 149003710 5.66740154 1617266 1371134100213.867.834.15.7634.41.51
Pedro Martinez 29290010 7.58800153 2/31758886 265212410125.047.263.051.5213.21.48
Renyel Pinto 16000286 6.50000142 2/31216359 1493130100143.728.205.87.8831.31.50
Justin Speier 10300276 10.37500108 1136461 224295100105.087.923.501.83 8.51.44
Josh Rupe 6100134 2.66700103 2/31196665 11586310045.645.475.04.95-2.91.71
Mitch Stetter 11000207 2.7781074 583433 7497810034.019.495.96.8518.81.45

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database