Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date: End Date:	All Games: Home Games: Road Games:	Playing For: Playing Versus: At Park:
Sort by: Descending Ascending Minimum Innings Pitched: Minimum Decisions: Minimum Games Played: Minimum Games Started: Minimum Complete Games: Minimum Games Finished: Minimum Wins: Minimum Losses:	Minimum Saves: Minimum Shutouts: Minimum Hits: Minimum Runs: Minimum ER: Minimum Home Runs: Minimum Walks: Minimum Strikeouts: Minimum Hit by Pitch: Minimum Balks: Minimum Wild Pitches:

Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Jake Peavy	20	20	1	0	11	5	.688	0	0	131 2/3	95	35	32	7	43	145	4	0	3	2.19	9.91	2.94	.48	59.3	1.05
Tom Gorzelanny	14	14	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	90 1/3	70	26	24	4	27	57	5	1	3	2.39	5.68	2.69	.40	32.9	1.07
Andy Pettitte	22	20	1	0	7	4	.636	0	0	125 2/3	116	44	35	8	40	95	2	1	3	2.51	6.80	2.86	.57	44.3	1.24
Rich Hill	19	18	2	1	10	5	.667	0	1	123 1/3	84	40	35	15	36	118	5	0	2	2.55	8.61	2.63	1.09	48.5	.97
Johan Santana	19	19	0	0	11	4	.733	0	0	128 1/3	97	42	37	13	30	141	3	0	6	2.59	9.89	2.10	.91	52.3	.99
Anibal Sanchez	17	17	2	0	8	3	.727	0	1	104	98	35	32	8	47	66	3	1	5	2.77	5.71	4.07	.69	34.6	1.39
Roy Oswalt	20	20	1	0	13	3	.812	0	0	138 2/3	122	43	43	10	32	108	5	1	1	2.79	7.01	2.08	.65	50.1	1.11
Jeff Suppan	20	20	1	0	9	5	.643	0	0	128 1/3	133	48	41	10	33	72	4	0	4	2.88	5.05	2.31	.70	39.4	1.29
Cole Hamels	19	19	1	0	11	4	.733	0	0	124	111	49	41	15	35	135	2	0	6	2.98	9.80	2.54	1.09	45.5	1.18
Tim Hudson	21	21	0	0	10	4	.714	0	0	142	125	51	48	13	39	97	4	0	1	3.04	6.15	2.47	.82	42.7	1.15
Derek Lowe	21	20	1	1	12	5	.706	0	0	133	128	51	45	4	37	77	2	2	1	3.05	5.21	2.50	.27	41.2	1.24
CC Sabathia	19	19	2	0	10	5	.667	0	0	138	134	55	47	16	24	135	4	0	2	3.07	8.80	1.57	1.04	45.5	1.14
Matt Cain	20	20	1	0	8	8	.500	0	0	129	99	46	45	7	55	117	4	1	6	3.14	8.16	3.84	.49	39.2	1.19
Chris Young	18	18	0	0	6	4	.600	0	0	102	72	43	36	10	47	90	3	2	4	3.18	7.94	4.15	.88	30.0	1.17
Jon Lieber	18	16	2	1	6	5	.545	0	1	107	112	45	38	14	16	63	1	0	2	3.20	5.30	1.35	1.18	27.8	1.20
Bronson Arroyo	21	21	1	0	7	7	.500	0	1	142 1/3	122	60	51	12	49	103	4	0	6	3.22	6.51	3.10	.76	37.5	1.20
Greg Maddux	20	20	1	0	9	5	.643	0	0	124 1/3	111	49	45	7	21	67	1	0	3	3.26	4.85	1.52	.51	32.9	1.06
John Maine	18	18	0	0	10	3	.769	0	0	107 1/3	82	42	39	14	50	89	2	0	3	3.27	7.46	4.19	1.17	33.6	1.23
Kelvim Escobar	18	18	2	0	8	7	.533	0	1	112 2/3	102	46	41	7	26	89	1	0	4	3.28	7.11	2.08	.56	32.2	1.14
John Smoltz	22	22	1	0	13	6	.684	0	0	144 1/3	141	56	53	12	39	127	3	0	4	3.30	7.92	2.43	.75	44.9	1.25
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Tom Glavine	18	18	0	0	8	4	.667	0	0	111 2/3	99	47	42	11	32	69	5	0	2	3.39	5.56	2.58	.89	28.7	1.17
Gil Meche	19	19	0	0	5	4	.556	0	0	116 1/3	112	60	44	13	46	91	4	1	3	3.40	7.04	3.56	1.01	28.3	1.36
Robinson Tejeda	16	16	0	0	7	5	.583	0	0	95	99	41	36	12	28	53	4	1	4	3.41	5.02	2.65	1.14	23.8	1.34
Dan Haren	20	20	0	0	9	6	.600	0	0	128 2/3	121	60	49	16	28	108	1	0	4	3.43	7.55	1.96	1.12	35.1	1.16
Orlando Hernandez	14	14	0	0	6	4	.600	0	0	86 1/3	68	36	33	10	36	83	6	2	1	3.44	8.65	3.75	1.04	24.5	1.20
Jered Weaver	17	17	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	101 2/3	97	43	39	16	32	91	1	0	2	3.45	8.06	2.83	1.42	26.9	1.27
Chuck James	20	20	0	0	11	5	.688	0	0	117	102	48	45	15	48	94	4	0	1	3.46	7.23	3.69	1.15	33.9	1.28
James Shields	17	17	1	0	5	3	.625	0	0	115 1/3	97	49	46	19	22	102	3	0	7	3.59	7.96	1.72	1.48	26.9	1.03
Jon Garland	19	19	1	0	9	6	.600	0	1	131 2/3	131	60	53	11	24	64	4	0	0	3.62	4.37	1.64	.75	28.2	1.18
Chris Carpenter	12	12	4	0	5	4	.556	0	2	89 1/3	79	37	36	7	10	71	4	0	2	3.63	7.15	1.01	.71	20.8	1.00
Brandon Webb	18	18	3	0	7	6	.538	0	1	124 2/3	107	57	51	6	42	102	5	0	4	3.68	7.36	3.03	.43	28.5	1.20
Ben Sheets	19	19	1	0	7	6	.538	0	0	119	111	52	49	13	20	99	3	0	2	3.71	7.49	1.51	.98	27.4	1.10
Nate Robertson	19	19	0	0	6	10	.375	0	0	123 1/3	129	56	51	13	36	72	2	0	4	3.72	5.25	2.63	.95	23.9	1.34
Ted Lilly	19	19	0	0	9	6	.600	0	0	114	104	56	48	12	29	99	4	2	4	3.79	7.82	2.29	.95	27.9	1.17
Livan Hernandez	20	20	0	0	8	7	.533	0	0	132 1/3	132	59	56	11	57	73	2	1	1	3.81	4.96	3.88	.75	25.5	1.43
Ian Snell	19	19	0	0	8	7	.533	0	0	120 1/3	113	54	51	16	45	112	3	0	6	3.81	8.38	3.37	1.20	28.4	1.31
Javier Vazquez	19	19	1	0	4	8	.333	0	0	121 1/3	104	56	52	13	37	122	5	0	8	3.86	9.05	2.74	.96	24.9	1.16
Brad Penny	20	20	0	0	11	4	.733	0	0	115 2/3	120	54	50	10	39	89	2	0	5	3.89	6.93	3.03	.78	27.7	1.37
Claudio Vargas	19	18	0	0	7	3	.700	0	0	104	107	49	45	15	33	85	3	0	3	3.89	7.36	2.86	1.30	22.5	1.35
Doug Davis	19	19	1	0	7	9	.438	0	1	115 1/3	116	59	50	7	56	95	4	1	1	3.90	7.41	4.37	.55	24.2	1.49
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Boof Bonser	19	19	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	108 1/3	109	56	47	18	36	102	1	1	2	3.90	8.47	2.99	1.50	23.4	1.34
Chien-Ming Wang	15	15	0	0	8	5	.615	0	0	96 2/3	109	42	42	7	20	41	2	0	1	3.91	3.82	1.86	.65	18.4	1.33
Clay Hensley	17	16	0	0	6	7	.462	0	0	94 1/3	103	45	41	4	39	65	1	0	2	3.91	6.20	3.72	.38	18.7	1.51
John Lackey	19	19	0	0	8	8	.500	0	0	121 2/3	144	55	53	6	37	113	5	0	8	3.92	8.36	2.74	.44	27.1	1.49
Chris Capuano	19	19	0	0	6	6	.500	0	0	112	106	57	49	13	31	82	6	0	4	3.94	6.59	2.49	1.04	21.2	1.22
Roy Halladay	18	18	3	0	7	5	.583	0	0	121	116	55	53	11	23	83	1	0	2	3.94	6.17	1.71	.82	22.8	1.15
Cliff Lee	14	14	2	0	6	3	.667	0	0	88 2/3	89	41	39	11	25	51	3	0	2	3.96	5.18	2.54	1.12	16.4	1.29
Felix Hernandez	15	15	2	0	5	6	.455	0	2	88 2/3	80	40	39	6	27	86	1	0	7	3.96	8.73	2.74	.61	18.9	1.21
Dontrelle Willis	21	21	1	0	11	7	.611	0	1	134	136	66	59	14	56	107	6	1	3	3.96	7.19	3.76	.94	29.7	1.43
A.J. Burnett	20	20	1	0	11	7	.611	0	0	129 1/3	117	58	57	14	57	113	10	1	3	3.97	7.86	3.97	.97	30.0	1.35
Curt Schilling	16	16	0	0	6	4	.600	0	0	103 2/3	122	46	46	11	21	86	0	0	0	3.99	7.47	1.82	.95	20.4	1.38
Zach Duke	19	19	1	0	4	10	.286	0	0	121 2/3	149	59	54	10	25	55	3	0	4	3.99	4.07	1.85	.74	16.3	1.43
David Wells	18	18	0	0	4	6	.400	0	0	107 1/3	130	52	48	10	20	58	2	0	0	4.02	4.86	1.68	.84	15.5	1.40
Jarrod Washburn	17	17	1	0	6	7	.462	0	1	104 2/3	102	49	47	13	31	56	7	1	1	4.04	4.82	2.67	1.12	16.9	1.27
Jamie Moyer	20	20	0	0	9	7	.562	0	0	129	126	61	58	15	34	69	5	0	0	4.05	4.81	2.37	1.05	22.4	1.24
Erik Bedard	20	20	0	0	6	7	.462	0	0	120	120	60	54	11	44	124	1	0	2	4.05	9.30	3.30	.82	24.4	1.37
Daniel Cabrera	19	19	3	0	8	7	.533	0	1	121 1/3	105	61	56	10	56	117	7	1	9	4.15	8.68	4.15	.74	24.4	1.33
Paul Byrd	16	16	1	0	6	4	.600	0	0	97	129	62	45	14	16	47	2	0	1	4.18	4.36	1.48	1.30	14.2	1.49
Aaron Harang	22	21	2	0	10	5	.667	0	0	144	149	70	67	18	31	125	4	2	7	4.19	7.81	1.94	1.12	27.5	1.25
Adam Loewen	17	17	0	0	7	3	.700	0	0	92 1/3	82	46	43	4	55	78	5	1	2	4.19	7.60	5.36	.39	18.0	1.48
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Dave Bush	19	19	1	0	9	6	.600	0	1	123	116	61	58	13	14	89	12	0	2	4.24	6.51	1.02	.95	21.4	1.06
Woody Williams	21	21	0	0	9	8	.529	0	0	129 1/3	139	70	61	23	34	52	5	1	2	4.24	3.62	2.37	1.60	17.9	1.34
Joe Blanton	19	18	1	0	9	5	.643	0	0	118 2/3	141	60	56	12	31	82	2	0	1	4.25	6.22	2.35	.91	20.5	1.45
Carlos Silva	19	19	0	0	6	9	.400	0	0	110	132	55	52	19	25	42	5	0	2	4.25	3.44	2.05	1.55	13.2	1.43
Jason Bergmann	20	14	0	4	1	5	.167	0	0	92 2/3	72	46	44	12	37	75	3	0	3	4.27	7.28	3.59	1.17	10.8	1.18
Barry Zito	19	19	0	0	8	7	.533	0	0	121 2/3	121	61	58	15	53	72	0	0	1	4.29	5.33	3.92	1.11	18.0	1.43
Noah Lowry	17	17	1	0	6	6	.500	0	1	106 2/3	95	58	51	11	41	66	3	0	2	4.30	5.57	3.46	.93	14.9	1.27
Josh Beckett	19	19	0	0	10	6	.625	0	0	121	110	60	58	10	40	93	3	0	4	4.31	6.92	2.98	.74	21.8	1.24
Kyle Lohse	20	19	0	1	4	9	.308	0	0	114 2/3	130	57	55	11	31	87	1	0	2	4.32	6.83	2.43	.86	15.0	1.40
Steve Trachsel	18	18	0	0	7	6	.538	0	0	100	99	50	48	12	46	42	0	2	3	4.32	3.78	4.14	1.08	13.2	1.45
Freddy Garcia	18	18	0	0	8	5	.615	0	0	114	117	58	55	12	22	83	7	0	5	4.34	6.55	1.74	.95	18.3	1.22
Justin Verlander	18	18	0	0	8	6	.571	0	0	104 2/3	120	55	51	12	40	72	6	1	6	4.39	6.19	3.44	1.03	16.5	1.53
Joe Saunders	15	15	0	0	8	3	.727	0	0	82	87	44	40	7	34	57	1	1	2	4.39	6.26	3.73	.77	14.7	1.48
Carlos Zambrano	19	19	0	0	8	7	.533	0	0	116 1/3	110	66	57	15	60	96	7	0	5	4.41	7.43	4.64	1.16	18.8	1.46
Jorge de la Rosa	17	17	0	0	6	7	.462	0	0	94	92	52	47	13	42	57	1	1	3	4.50	5.46	4.02	1.24	11.7	1.43
Scott Olsen	20	20	0	0	6	9	.400	0	0	115 2/3	123	69	59	16	51	96	3	0	4	4.59	7.47	3.97	1.24	14.4	1.50
Jason Marquis	19	19	1	0	7	9	.438	0	1	105 2/3	104	55	54	13	44	56	9	1	0	4.60	4.77	3.75	1.11	11.4	1.40
Brett Myers	29	15	1	7	7	4	.636	4	0	109	107	57	56	19	37	128	2	0	2	4.62	10.57	3.06	1.57	18.3	1.32
Jeremy Sowers	15	15	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	83 1/3	92	45	43	6	26	30	5	0	2	4.64	3.24	2.81	.65	5.7	1.42
Mark Buehrle	18	18	1	0	5	5	.500	0	1	108	123	57	56	22	26	68	3	1	1	4.67	5.67	2.17	1.83	9.8	1.38
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Matt Morris	19	19	1	0	6	8	.429	0	0	123 1/3	133	69	64	14	40	59	6	2	1	4.67	4.31	2.92	1.02	9.6	1.40
Jeremy Bonderman	19	19	0	0	5	3	.625	0	0	113 2/3	133	65	59	10	31	102	2	0	6	4.67	8.08	2.45	.79	13.0	1.44
Randy Wolf	19	19	0	0	8	3	.727	0	0	100 1/3	108	55	53	18	41	95	6	0	2	4.75	8.52	3.68	1.61	14.7	1.49
Vicente Padilla	19	19	0	0	6	8	.429	0	0	117	126	71	62	17	47	71	8	2	0	4.77	5.46	3.62	1.31	9.6	1.48
Jason Schmidt	14	14	0	0	5	4	.556	0	0	80	86	49	43	12	33	74	4	1	2	4.84	8.32	3.71	1.35	9.4	1.49
Randy Johnson	15	15	1	0	7	4	.636	0	0	96 2/3	87	53	52	12	25	88	7	1	1	4.84	8.19	2.33	1.12	12.1	1.16
Aaron Cook	18	18	0	0	4	7	.364	0	0	116 2/3	135	69	63	10	36	52	5	0	2	4.86	4.01	2.78	.77	4.5	1.47
Ervin Santana	19	19	0	0	7	8	.467	0	0	112	112	66	61	19	42	79	5	0	4	4.90	6.35	3.38	1.53	9.9	1.38
Paul Maholm	17	17	1	0	6	6	.500	0	1	100 1/3	107	56	55	15	37	63	5	1	2	4.93	5.65	3.32	1.35	7.5	1.44
Jason Hirsh	17	17	0	0	5	8	.385	0	0	94 1/3	92	56	52	18	44	68	3	1	5	4.96	6.49	4.20	1.72	7.0	1.44
Jake Westbrook	17	17	2	0	9	5	.643	0	1	105	136	61	58	9	33	57	3	0	4	4.97	4.89	2.83	.77	9.2	1.61
Kevin Millwood	19	19	1	0	8	9	.471	0	0	116	116	66	65	16	39	96	3	0	0	5.04	7.45	3.03	1.24	10.6	1.34
Jose Contreras	17	17	2	0	6	9	.400	0	2	99	103	68	56	11	32	66	5	0	4	5.09	6.00	2.91	1.00	6.1	1.36
Jeff Francis	19	19	0	0	7	6	.538	0	0	119	139	72	68	13	38	59	6	1	1	5.14	4.46	2.87	.98	4.4	1.49
Miguel Batista	19	18	0	0	5	6	.455	0	0	107 1/3	123	65	63	10	47	55	2	2	5	5.28	4.61	3.94	.84	1.2	1.58
Jae Seo	18	18	0	0	2	6	.250	0	0	93 1/3	134	68	58	17	27	51	6	0	4	5.59	4.92	2.60	1.64	-4.2	1.73
Adam Eaton	20	20	0	0	10	6	.625	0	0	109	128	71	68	19	40	76	6	0	1	5.61	6.28	3.30	1.57	4.1	1.54
Odalis Perez	20	20	0	0	4	8	.333	0	0	108 2/3	135	72	70	12	30	64	2	1	2	5.80	5.30	2.48	.99	-5.3	1.52
Ramon Ortiz	20	20	0	0	7	11	.389	0	0	108 1/3	129	79	74	16	35	56	11	0	3	6.15	4.65	2.91	1.33	-7.2	1.51
Tomo Ohka	17	17	0	0	3	8	.273	0	0	90 2/3	101	67	63	17	35	32	3	0	4	6.25	3.18	3.47	1.69	-11.5	1.50
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Tony Armas Jr.	18	18	0	0	2	9	.182	0	0	84 2/3	113	70	60	16	44	49	6	0	4	6.38	5.21	4.68	1.70	-10.8	1.85
Josh Fogg	19	18	0	0	5	8	.385	0	0	96 1/3	129	78	71	14	38	63	6	0	0	6.63	5.89	3.55	1.31	-11.5	1.73
Jeff Weaver	18	18	0	0	4	9	.308	0	0	90	125	73	72	16	29	53	7	0	2	7.20	5.30	2.90	1.60	-17.7	1.71
Mark Redman	16	16	1	0	4	8	.333	0	1	82 1/3	116	71	67	7	34	43	5	1	2	7.32	4.70	3.72	.77	-17.5	1.82

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database