Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons
Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
You may also specify just home or just road games.
Default dates are first and last games in the database.
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Andy Pettitte
16 15 1 0 6
2 .750 0 0 93 1/3 81 32 23
6 26 76 1 1 2 2.22 7.33 2.51 .58 37.3 1.15
Rich Hill
14 13 2 1 8
3 .727 0 1 90 2/3 58 28 23
11 25 89 1 0 2 2.28 8.83 2.48 1.09 39.2 .92
Jake Peavy
15 15 1 0 8
4 .667 0 0 98 1/3 73 26 25
6 32 91 2 0 2 2.29 8.33 2.93 .55 41.3 1.07
Anibal Sanchez
14 14 2 0 7
2 .778 0 1 90 2/3 77 26 24
7 37 57 1 1 2 2.38 5.66 3.67 .69 34.0 1.26
CC Sabathia
14 14 2 0 8
4 .667 0 0 105 1/3 98 35 28
9 20 96 3 0 2 2.39 8.20 1.71 .77 42.3 1.12
Johan Santana
14 14 0 0 9
2 .818 0 0 97 1/3 66 30 26
8 21 110 1 0 4 2.40 10.17 1.94 .74 42.7 .89
Kenny Rogers
12 11 0 1 6
3 .667 0 0 73 2/3 63 26 20
4 24 23 3 0 4 2.44 2.81 2.93 .49 25.1 1.18
Roger Clemens
11 11 0 0 5
2 .714 0 0 66 51 19 18
5 18 62 4 0 2 2.45 8.45 2.45 .68 26.2 1.05
Robinson Tejeda
12 12 0 0 6
3 .667 0 0 73 1/3 73 26 21
8 23 33 1 1 1 2.58 4.05 2.82 .98 25.0 1.31
Roy Oswalt
15 15 1 0 10
1 .909 0 0 103 2/3 91 30 30
6 22 87 4 1 0 2.60 7.55 1.91 .52 40.5 1.09
Cole Hamels
14 14 0 0 7
3 .700 0 0 88 1/3 74 33 27
9 23 94 2 0 4 2.75 9.58 2.34 .92 33.6 1.10
Matt Cain
15 15 0 0 6
6 .500 0 0 98 72 32 31
7 39 99 4 1 2 2.85 9.09 3.58 .64 33.9 1.13
Derek Lowe
16 15 0 1 10
3 .769 0 0 99 95 35 32
2 25 54 2 1 1 2.91 4.91 2.27 .18 32.9 1.21
Chuck James
15 15 0 0 9
3 .750 0 0 90 2/3 74 33 30
9 37 75 4 0 1 2.98 7.44 3.67 .89 31.8 1.22
Jeff Suppan
15 15 0 0 5
4 .556 0 0 93 2/3 97 38 31
7 27 55 3 0 4 2.98 5.28 2.59 .67 26.3 1.32
Livan Hernandez
15 15 0 0 6
5 .545 0 0 103 1/3 97 39 36
8 39 58 2 1 1 3.14 5.05 3.40 .70 27.5 1.32
Esteban Loaiza
12 12 1 0 7
2 .778 0 1 79 2/3 78 31 28
5 9 57 1 0 2 3.16 6.44 1.02 .56 24.5 1.09
Kelvim Escobar
13 13 1 0 5
6 .455 0 0 81 72 31 29
6 20 66 1 0 1 3.22 7.33 2.22 .67 23.1 1.14
Roy Halladay
13 13 2 0 5
3 .625 0 0 86 1/3 77 32 31
9 18 58 1 0 2 3.23 6.05 1.88 .94 23.0 1.10
Tom Glavine
13 13 0 0 7
4 .636 0 0 80 2/3 71 34 29
7 26 51 5 0 1 3.24 5.69 2.90 .78 23.4 1.20
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
John Smoltz
17 17 1 0 10
5 .667 0 0 111 106 44 41
8 32 98 3 0 4 3.32 7.95 2.59 .65 34.3 1.24
Chien-Ming Wang
11 11 0 0 7
2 .778 0 0 70 81 26 26
4 16 31 1 0 0 3.34 3.99 2.06 .51 19.1 1.39
Nate Robertson
14 14 0 0 5
8 .385 0 0 93 2/3 91 38 35
11 29 60 2 0 4 3.36 5.77 2.79 1.06 22.8 1.28
Greg Maddux
15 15 0 0 7
4 .636 0 0 90 83 38 34
7 16 46 1 0 1 3.40 4.60 1.60 .70 22.6 1.10
Tim Hudson
15 15 0 0 7
3 .700 0 0 97 88 40 37
12 35 70 3 0 1 3.43 6.49 3.25 1.11 25.5 1.27
Bronson Arroyo
16 16 1 0 5
6 .455 0 1 109 2/3 98 51 42
11 37 83 4 0 5 3.45 6.81 3.04 .90 26.1 1.23
David Wells
13 13 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 78 1/3 91 34 30
6 11 43 1 0 0 3.45 4.94 1.26 .69 16.5 1.30
Chris Young
13 13 0 0 3
2 .600 0 0 70 1/3 51 29 27
8 35 63 1 1 2 3.45 8.06 4.48 1.02 17.5 1.22
Jered Weaver
12 12 0 0 4
3 .571 0 0 75 1/3 65 30 29
14 22 65 1 0 2 3.46 7.77 2.63 1.67 19.2 1.15
Dontrelle Willis
16 16 1 0 9
5 .643 0 1 102 103 46 40
10 39 87 5 1 2 3.53 7.68 3.44 .88 28.7 1.39
Javier Vazquez
14 14 1 0 4
6 .400 0 0 89 76 39 35
9 30 98 4 0 6 3.54 9.91 3.03 .91 23.3 1.19
Chris Carpenter
12 12 4 0 5
4 .556 0 2 89 1/3 79 37 36
7 10 71 4 0 2 3.63 7.15 1.01 .71 20.8 1.00
Jon Lieber
13 11 2 1 5
3 .625 0 1 74 1/3 83 35 30
12 6 45 1 0 2 3.63 5.45 .73 1.45 16.7 1.20
John Maine
13 13 0 0 7
2 .778 0 0 75 2/3 54 34 31
13 35 61 2 0 2 3.69 7.26 4.16 1.55 19.9 1.18
Jeremy Sowers
11 11 0 0 4
2 .667 0 0 63 1/3 63 27 26
3 19 25 4 0 1 3.69 3.55 2.70 .43 12.2 1.29
Zach Duke
14 14 1 0 4
7 .364 0 0 93 1/3 109 42 39
7 19 45 3 0 4 3.76 4.34 1.83 .68 16.2 1.37
Cliff Lee
11 11 1 0 5
3 .625 0 0 68 2/3 70 31 29
9 19 41 2 0 2 3.80 5.37 2.49 1.18 14.4 1.30
Felix Hernandez
14 14 2 0 5
6 .455 0 2 85 73 37 36
6 24 81 1 0 7 3.81 8.58 2.54 .64 19.6 1.14
Dave Bush
14 14 1 0 7
4 .636 0 1 90 2/3 84 41 39
9 8 66 9 0 2 3.87 6.55 .79 .89 19.9 1.01
Rodrigo Lopez
17 10 0 2 3
7 .300 0 0 78 2/3 81 35 34
11 21 63 2 1 0 3.89 7.21 2.40 1.26 14.6 1.30
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Jon Garland
15 15 1 0 7
5 .583 0 1 101 1/3 109 50 44
10 20 57 4 0 0 3.91 5.06 1.78 .89 19.4 1.27
Curt Schilling
11 11 0 0 4
4 .500 0 0 70 2/3 84 31 31
7 14 60 0 0 0 3.95 7.64 1.78 .89 14.3 1.39
Daniel Cabrera
13 13 2 0 6
4 .600 0 1 82 74 40 36
4 34 86 4 0 4 3.95 9.44 3.73 .44 19.6 1.32
Ben Sheets
14 14 1 0 5
6 .455 0 0 90 2/3 84 43 40
10 12 81 3 0 1 3.97 8.04 1.19 .99 18.4 1.06
Woody Williams
15 15 0 0 8
5 .615 0 0 90 2/3 98 49 40
16 24 39 3 0 2 3.97 3.87 2.38 1.59 17.2 1.35
Orlando Hernandez
12 12 0 0 5
4 .556 0 0 72 1/3 61 34 32
10 32 68 6 2 1 3.98 8.46 3.98 1.24 16.0 1.29
Brandon Webb
14 14 2 0 5
5 .500 0 1 94 2/3 85 47 42
4 33 81 3 0 3 3.99 7.70 3.14 .38 18.4 1.25
Erik Bedard
15 15 0 0 6
6 .500 0 0 89 1/3 96 46 40
8 33 86 0 0 1 4.03 8.66 3.32 .81 19.3 1.44
Dan Haren
15 15 0 0 7
6 .538 0 0 93 1/3 95 52 42
13 22 72 0 0 2 4.05 6.94 2.12 1.25 18.9 1.25
Clay Hensley
14 13 0 0 5
7 .417 0 0 80 85 40 36
4 31 58 1 0 2 4.05 6.53 3.49 .45 14.8 1.45
Jason Jennings
12 12 0 0 2
5 .286 0 0 73 1/3 70 34 33
5 35 49 0 0 4 4.05 6.01 4.30 .61 10.6 1.43
Kyle Lohse
15 14 0 1 4
5 .444 0 0 84 1/3 90 39 38
10 21 70 0 0 2 4.06 7.47 2.24 1.07 15.2 1.32
Aaron Harang
17 16 2 0 7
4 .636 0 0 107 2/3 115 52 49
16 23 94 4 1 4 4.10 7.86 1.92 1.34 21.2 1.28
Gil Meche
14 14 0 0 3
4 .429 0 0 83 1/3 82 50 38
10 37 65 4 1 3 4.10 7.02 4.00 1.08 13.2 1.43
Freddy Garcia
13 13 0 0 7
4 .636 0 0 87 1/3 86 43 40
10 16 63 3 0 1 4.12 6.49 1.65 1.03 17.0 1.17
A.J. Burnett
15 15 1 0 9
5 .643 0 0 96 90 45 44
7 38 80 7 1 2 4.12 7.50 3.56 .66 21.0 1.33
Jeremy Bonderman
16 16 0 0 3
3 .500 0 0 96 2/3 106 49 45
8 27 83 2 0 5 4.19 7.73 2.51 .74 14.6 1.38
Paul Byrd
11 11 1 0 4
3 .571 0 0 64 1/3 89 45 30
8 15 29 1 0 1 4.20 4.06 2.10 1.12 9.1 1.62
Ian Snell
14 14 0 0 6
6 .500 0 0 87 1/3 81 43 41
15 34 89 1 0 3 4.23 9.17 3.50 1.55 17.6 1.32
Chris Capuano
14 14 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 85 81 48 40
11 20 64 5 0 2 4.24 6.78 2.12 1.16 11.9 1.19
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Boof Bonser
14 14 0 0 5
5 .500 0 0 80 1/3 79 42 38
14 20 72 0 0 2 4.26 8.07 2.24 1.57 14.4 1.23
John Lackey
15 15 0 0 5
7 .417 0 0 93 116 46 44
5 31 84 5 0 7 4.26 8.13 3.00 .48 15.9 1.58
Ted Lilly
14 14 0 0 7
5 .583 0 0 79 2/3 75 44 38
10 24 75 4 2 4 4.29 8.47 2.71 1.13 16.3 1.24
Claudio Vargas
14 13 0 0 5
3 .625 0 0 77 82 41 37
12 21 68 3 0 1 4.32 7.95 2.45 1.40 13.3 1.34
Jamie Moyer
14 14 0 0 6
6 .500 0 0 87 1/3 94 45 42
11 21 46 5 0 0 4.33 4.74 2.16 1.13 12.3 1.32
Jaret Wright
14 12 0 0 5
3 .625 0 0 62 60 33 30
6 33 39 3 0 1 4.35 5.66 4.79 .87 9.9 1.50
Carlos Silva
15 15 0 0 5
7 .417 0 0 86 104 45 42
17 19 31 4 0 1 4.40 3.24 1.99 1.78 9.1 1.43
Adam Loewen
14 14 0 0 6
3 .667 0 0 75 2/3 68 40 37
3 41 65 5 0 1 4.40 7.73 4.88 .36 13.3 1.44
James Shields
12 12 1 0 3
3 .500 0 0 75 73 40 37
16 17 64 2 0 6 4.44 7.68 2.04 1.92 9.9 1.20
Doug Davis
14 14 1 0 6
6 .500 0 1 85 86 47 42
6 42 74 1 1 0 4.45 7.84 4.45 .64 13.9 1.51
Jake Woods
15 8 0 0 4
3 .571 0 0 66 2/3 79 35 33
7 30 36 3 0 1 4.46 4.86 4.05 .94 7.9 1.64
Kevin Millwood
16 16 1 0 8
7 .533 0 0 102 2/3 95 52 51
14 32 83 2 0 0 4.47 7.28 2.81 1.23 16.6 1.24
Barry Zito
14 14 0 0 6
5 .545 0 0 88 1/3 94 47 44
12 40 54 0 0 0 4.48 5.50 4.08 1.22 11.6 1.52
Mark Buehrle
14 14 1 0 4
4 .500 0 1 83 95 44 43
17 18 46 3 1 0 4.66 4.99 1.95 1.84 7.1 1.36
Josh Beckett
14 14 0 0 6
6 .500 0 0 88 1/3 80 47 46
9 33 64 3 0 4 4.69 6.52 3.36 .92 10.6 1.28
Brad Penny
15 15 0 0 9
4 .692 0 0 84 1/3 95 47 44
10 29 62 2 0 3 4.70 6.62 3.09 1.07 13.4 1.47
Joe Blanton
14 13 0 0 6
4 .600 0 0 82 1/3 106 46 43
8 24 54 2 0 1 4.70 5.90 2.62 .87 9.6 1.58
Justin Verlander
13 13 0 0 5
5 .500 0 0 74 2/3 86 41 39
9 32 51 3 1 3 4.70 6.15 3.86 1.08 8.4 1.58
Noah Lowry
12 12 1 0 2
5 .286 0 1 74 1/3 67 42 39
10 26 44 2 0 1 4.72 5.33 3.15 1.21 4.6 1.25
Paul Maholm
12 12 0 0 4
3 .571 0 0 70 1/3 76 38 37
8 30 45 5 1 2 4.73 5.76 3.84 1.02 6.7 1.51
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Joe Saunders
14 14 0 0 7
3 .700 0 0 76 80 44 40
7 32 56 1 1 2 4.74 6.63 3.79 .83 10.6 1.47
Steve Trachsel
13 13 0 0 6
4 .600 0 0 71 2/3 71 39 38
9 31 32 0 1 1 4.77 4.02 3.89 1.13 7.0 1.42
Scott Olsen
15 15 0 0 5
7 .417 0 0 84 1/3 81 51 45
11 41 72 2 0 2 4.80 7.68 4.38 1.17 9.4 1.45
Carlos Zambrano
14 14 0 0 5
6 .455 0 0 84 79 52 45
10 49 74 5 0 3 4.82 7.93 5.25 1.07 9.4 1.52
Jason Schmidt
14 14 0 0 5
4 .556 0 0 80 86 49 43
12 33 74 4 1 2 4.84 8.32 3.71 1.35 9.4 1.49
Randy Johnson
10 10 1 0 6
2 .750 0 0 66 2/3 60 36 36
7 18 51 4 1 0 4.86 6.88 2.43 .94 8.4 1.17
Aaron Cook
13 13 0 0 2
6 .250 0 0 86 1/3 98 51 47
8 23 40 5 0 2 4.90 4.17 2.40 .83 2.2 1.40
Shaun Marcum
16 11 0 3 3
4 .429 1 0 62 66 34 34
13 26 53 4 0 1 4.94 7.69 3.77 1.89 5.3 1.48
Miguel Batista
14 13 0 0 3
4 .429 0 0 80 84 46 44
6 40 43 2 2 2 4.95 4.84 4.50 .68 3.3 1.55
Matt Morris
14 14 1 0 4
7 .364 0 0 89 94 54 49
10 29 49 5 2 1 4.96 4.96 2.93 1.01 4.4 1.38
Jarrod Washburn
12 12 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 69 74 40 38
11 23 36 4 0 1 4.96 4.70 3.00 1.43 3.1 1.41
Ervin Santana
14 14 0 0 6
5 .545 0 0 80 75 49 45
11 31 54 3 0 2 5.06 6.08 3.49 1.24 6.4 1.32
Jake Westbrook
14 14 2 0 8
5 .615 0 1 90 1/3 124 53 51
8 28 49 3 0 3 5.08 4.88 2.79 .80 7.1 1.68
Randy Wolf
14 14 0 0 6
1 .857 0 0 70 1/3 76 42 40
15 33 55 4 0 1 5.12 7.04 4.22 1.92 6.7 1.55
Jorge de la Rosa
12 12 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 61 1/3 61 38 35
11 34 43 1 1 2 5.14 6.31 4.99 1.61 3.0 1.55
Jae Seo
13 13 0 0 0
4 .000 0 0 70 104 50 40
13 19 37 4 0 4 5.14 4.76 2.44 1.67 -1.3 1.76
Vicente Padilla
14 14 0 0 5
6 .455 0 0 85 2/3 98 52 49
13 30 57 7 2 0 5.15 5.99 3.15 1.37 4.5 1.49
Brett Myers
16 15 1 0 6
4 .600 0 0 93 1/3 94 55 54
18 32 105 2 0 1 5.21 10.12 3.09 1.74 9.2 1.35
Jason Hirsh
12 12 0 0 4
5 .444 0 0 63 1/3 66 39 37
12 27 45 3 1 4 5.26 6.39 3.84 1.71 3.2 1.47
Jeff Francis
14 14 0 0 6
3 .667 0 0 85 1/3 100 54 50
9 27 41 4 0 1 5.27 4.32 2.85 .95 2.8 1.49
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Luke Hudson
11 11 0 0 4
3 .571 0 0 64 2/3 69 40 38
7 25 38 3 0 3 5.29 5.29 3.48 .97 2.1 1.45
Adam Eaton
15 15 0 0 8
4 .667 0 0 79 92 49 47
13 28 51 4 0 1 5.35 5.81 3.19 1.48 5.6 1.52
Runelvys Hernandez
11 11 1 0 4
4 .500 0 1 61 2/3 75 45 37
8 30 29 5 0 0 5.40 4.23 4.38 1.17 0.7 1.70
Ramon Ortiz
15 15 0 0 7
7 .500 0 0 84 1/3 97 58 54
13 27 46 9 0 2 5.76 4.91 2.88 1.39 -0.2 1.47
Tony Armas Jr.
13 13 0 0 2
7 .222 0 0 64 81 50 42
11 34 33 5 0 2 5.91 4.64 4.78 1.55 -4.7 1.80
Jason Marquis
14 14 0 0 3
9 .250 0 0 70 80 47 46
10 38 40 7 1 0 5.91 5.14 4.89 1.29 -4.0 1.69
Jose Contreras
13 13 1 0 4
8 .333 0 1 70 2/3 80 56 47
8 25 53 4 0 4 5.99 6.75 3.18 1.02 -2.4 1.49
Jeff Weaver
14 14 0 0 4
5 .444 0 0 76 92 52 51
14 25 45 6 0 1 6.04 5.33 2.96 1.66 -4.5 1.54
Odalis Perez
15 15 0 0 2
6 .250 0 0 78 2/3 101 56 54
9 23 54 1 1 2 6.18 6.18 2.63 1.03 -7.3 1.58
Josh Fogg
14 13 0 0 4
4 .500 0 0 69 94 53 51
10 25 41 5 0 0 6.65 5.35 3.26 1.30 -8.4 1.72
Byung-Hyun Kim
14 12 0 2 3
8 .273 0 0 68 2/3 79 53 53
11 27 52 6 1 2 6.95 6.82 3.54 1.44 -10.5 1.54
Tomo Ohka
12 12 0 0 1
6 .143 0 0 61 2/3 69 50 48
13 21 22 3 0 3 7.01 3.21 3.06 1.90 -14.0 1.46
Mark Redman
13 13 1 0 4
6 .400 0 1 70 1/3 97 58 55
4 28 35 4 1 2 7.04 4.48 3.58 .51 -12.3 1.78
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions .
Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database