Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Andy Pettitte 1615106 2.7500093 1/3813223 626761122.227.332.51.5837.31.15
Rich Hill 1413218 3.7270190 2/3582823 1125891022.288.832.481.0939.2.92
Jake Peavy 1515108 4.6670098 1/3732625 632912022.298.332.93.5541.31.07
Anibal Sanchez 1414207 2.7780190 2/3772624 737571122.385.663.67.6934.01.26
CC Sabathia 1414208 4.66700105 1/3983528 920963022.398.201.71.7742.31.12
Johan Santana 1414009 2.8180097 1/3663026 8211101042.4010.171.94.7442.7.89
Kenny Rogers 1211016 3.6670073 2/3632620 424233042.442.812.93.4925.11.18
Roger Clemens 1111005 2.7140066 511918 518624022.458.452.45.6826.21.05
Robinson Tejeda 1212006 3.6670073 1/3732621 823331112.584.052.82.9825.01.31
Roy Oswalt 15151010 1.90900103 2/3913030 622874102.607.551.91.5240.51.09
Cole Hamels 1414007 3.7000088 1/3743327 923942042.759.582.34.9233.61.10
Matt Cain 1515006 6.5000098 723231 739994122.859.093.58.6433.91.13
Derek Lowe 16150110 3.7690099 953532 225542112.914.912.27.1832.91.21
Chuck James 1515009 3.7500090 2/3743330 937754012.987.443.67.8931.81.22
Jeff Suppan 1515005 4.5560093 2/3973831 727553042.985.282.59.6726.31.32
Livan Hernandez 1515006 5.54500103 1/3973936 839582113.145.053.40.7027.51.32
Esteban Loaiza 1212107 2.7780179 2/3783128 59571023.166.441.02.5624.51.09
Kelvim Escobar 1313105 6.4550081 723129 620661013.227.332.22.6723.11.14
Roy Halladay 1313205 3.6250086 1/3773231 918581023.236.051.88.9423.01.10
Tom Glavine 1313007 4.6360080 2/3713429 726515013.245.692.90.7823.41.20
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
John Smoltz 17171010 5.66700111 1064441 832983043.327.952.59.6534.31.24
Chien-Ming Wang 1111007 2.7780070 812626 416311003.343.992.06.5119.11.39
Nate Robertson 1414005 8.3850093 2/3913835 1129602043.365.772.791.0622.81.28
Greg Maddux 1515007 4.6360090 833834 716461013.404.601.60.7022.61.10
Tim Hudson 1515007 3.7000097 884037 1235703013.436.493.251.1125.51.27
Bronson Arroyo 1616105 6.45501109 2/3985142 1137834053.456.813.04.9026.11.23
David Wells 1313003 5.3750078 1/3913430 611431003.454.941.26.6916.51.30
Chris Young 1313003 2.6000070 1/3512927 835631123.458.064.481.0217.51.22
Jered Weaver 1212004 3.5710075 1/3653029 1422651023.467.772.631.6719.21.15
Dontrelle Willis 1616109 5.64301102 1034640 1039875123.537.683.44.8828.71.39
Javier Vazquez 1414104 6.4000089 763935 930984063.549.913.03.9123.31.19
Chris Carpenter 1212405 4.5560289 1/3793736 710714023.637.151.01.7120.81.00
Jon Lieber 1311215 3.6250174 1/3833530 126451023.635.45.731.4516.71.20
John Maine 1313007 2.7780075 2/3543431 1335612023.697.264.161.5519.91.18
Jeremy Sowers 1111004 2.6670063 1/3632726 319254013.693.552.70.4312.21.29
Zach Duke 1414104 7.3640093 1/31094239 719453043.764.341.83.6816.21.37
Cliff Lee 1111105 3.6250068 2/3703129 919412023.805.372.491.1814.41.30
Felix Hernandez 1414205 6.4550285 733736 624811073.818.582.54.6419.61.14
Dave Bush 1414107 4.6360190 2/3844139 98669023.876.55.79.8919.91.01
Rodrigo Lopez 1710023 7.3000078 2/3813534 1121632103.897.212.401.2614.61.30
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Jon Garland 1515107 5.58301101 1/31095044 1020574003.915.061.78.8919.41.27
Curt Schilling 1111004 4.5000070 2/3843131 714600003.957.641.78.8914.31.39
Daniel Cabrera 1313206 4.6000182 744036 434864043.959.443.73.4419.61.32
Ben Sheets 1414105 6.4550090 2/3844340 1012813013.978.041.19.9918.41.06
Woody Williams 1515008 5.6150090 2/3984940 1624393023.973.872.381.5917.21.35
Orlando Hernandez 1212005 4.5560072 1/3613432 1032686213.988.463.981.2416.01.29
Brandon Webb 1414205 5.5000194 2/3854742 433813033.997.703.14.3818.41.25
Erik Bedard 1515006 6.5000089 1/3964640 833860014.038.663.32.8119.31.44
Dan Haren 1515007 6.5380093 1/3955242 1322720024.056.942.121.2518.91.25
Clay Hensley 1413005 7.4170080 854036 431581024.056.533.49.4514.81.45
Jason Jennings 1212002 5.2860073 1/3703433 535490044.056.014.30.6110.61.43
Kyle Lohse 1514014 5.4440084 1/3903938 1021700024.067.472.241.0715.21.32
Aaron Harang 1716207 4.63600107 2/31155249 1623944144.107.861.921.3421.21.28
Gil Meche 1414003 4.4290083 1/3825038 1037654134.107.024.001.0813.21.43
Freddy Garcia 1313007 4.6360087 1/3864340 1016633014.126.491.651.0317.01.17
A.J. Burnett 1515109 5.6430096 904544 738807124.127.503.56.6621.01.33
Jeremy Bonderman 1616003 3.5000096 2/31064945 827832054.197.732.51.7414.61.38
Paul Byrd 1111104 3.5710064 1/3894530 815291014.204.062.101.12 9.11.62
Ian Snell 1414006 6.5000087 1/3814341 1534891034.239.173.501.5517.61.32
Chris Capuano 1414003 5.3750085 814840 1120645024.246.782.121.1611.91.19
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Boof Bonser 1414005 5.5000080 1/3794238 1420720024.268.072.241.5714.41.23
John Lackey 1515005 7.4170093 1164644 531845074.268.133.00.4815.91.58
Ted Lilly 1414007 5.5830079 2/3754438 1024754244.298.472.711.1316.31.24
Claudio Vargas 1413005 3.6250077 824137 1221683014.327.952.451.4013.31.34
Jamie Moyer 1414006 6.5000087 1/3944542 1121465004.334.742.161.1312.31.32
Jaret Wright 1412005 3.6250062 603330 633393014.355.664.79.87 9.91.50
Carlos Silva 1515005 7.4170086 1044542 1719314014.403.241.991.78 9.11.43
Adam Loewen 1414006 3.6670075 2/3684037 341655014.407.734.88.3613.31.44
James Shields 1212103 3.5000075 734037 1617642064.447.682.041.92 9.91.20
Doug Davis 1414106 6.5000185 864742 642741104.457.844.45.6413.91.51
Jake Woods 158004 3.5710066 2/3793533 730363014.464.864.05.94 7.91.64
Kevin Millwood 1616108 7.53300102 2/3955251 1432832004.477.282.811.2316.61.24
Barry Zito 1414006 5.5450088 1/3944744 1240540004.485.504.081.2211.61.52
Mark Buehrle 1414104 4.5000183 954443 1718463104.664.991.951.84 7.11.36
Josh Beckett 1414006 6.5000088 1/3804746 933643044.696.523.36.9210.61.28
Brad Penny 1515009 4.6920084 1/3954744 1029622034.706.623.091.0713.41.47
Joe Blanton 1413006 4.6000082 1/31064643 824542014.705.902.62.87 9.61.58
Justin Verlander 1313005 5.5000074 2/3864139 932513134.706.153.861.08 8.41.58
Noah Lowry 1212102 5.2860174 1/3674239 1026442014.725.333.151.21 4.61.25
Paul Maholm 1212004 3.5710070 1/3763837 830455124.735.763.841.02 6.71.51
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Joe Saunders 1414007 3.7000076 804440 732561124.746.633.79.8310.61.47
Steve Trachsel 1313006 4.6000071 2/3713938 931320114.774.023.891.13 7.01.42
Scott Olsen 1515005 7.4170084 1/3815145 1141722024.807.684.381.17 9.41.45
Carlos Zambrano 1414005 6.4550084 795245 1049745034.827.935.251.07 9.41.52
Jason Schmidt 1414005 4.5560080 864943 1233744124.848.323.711.35 9.41.49
Randy Johnson 1010106 2.7500066 2/3603636 718514104.866.882.43.94 8.41.17
Aaron Cook 1313002 6.2500086 1/3985147 823405024.904.172.40.83 2.21.40
Shaun Marcum 1611033 4.4291062 663434 1326534014.947.693.771.89 5.31.48
Miguel Batista 1413003 4.4290080 844644 640432224.954.844.50.68 3.31.55
Matt Morris 1414104 7.3640089 945449 1029495214.964.962.931.01 4.41.38
Jarrod Washburn 1212003 5.3750069 744038 1123364014.964.703.001.43 3.11.41
Ervin Santana 1414006 5.5450080 754945 1131543025.066.083.491.24 6.41.32
Jake Westbrook 1414208 5.6150190 1/31245351 828493035.084.882.79.80 7.11.68
Randy Wolf 1414006 1.8570070 1/3764240 1533554015.127.044.221.92 6.71.55
Jorge de la Rosa 1212003 5.3750061 1/3613835 1134431125.146.314.991.61 3.01.55
Jae Seo 1313000 4.0000070 1045040 1319374045.144.762.441.67-1.31.76
Vicente Padilla 1414005 6.4550085 2/3985249 1330577205.155.993.151.37 4.51.49
Brett Myers 1615106 4.6000093 1/3945554 18321052015.2110.123.091.74 9.21.35
Jason Hirsh 1212004 5.4440063 1/3663937 1227453145.266.393.841.71 3.21.47
Jeff Francis 1414006 3.6670085 1/31005450 927414015.274.322.85.95 2.81.49
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Luke Hudson 1111004 3.5710064 2/3694038 725383035.295.293.48.97 2.11.45
Adam Eaton 1515008 4.6670079 924947 1328514015.355.813.191.48 5.61.52
Runelvys Hernandez 1111104 4.5000161 2/3754537 830295005.404.234.381.17 0.71.70
Ramon Ortiz 1515007 7.5000084 1/3975854 1327469025.764.912.881.39-0.21.47
Tony Armas Jr. 1313002 7.2220064 815042 1134335025.914.644.781.55-4.71.80
Jason Marquis 1414003 9.2500070 804746 1038407105.915.144.891.29-4.01.69
Jose Contreras 1313104 8.3330170 2/3805647 825534045.996.753.181.02-2.41.49
Jeff Weaver 1414004 5.4440076 925251 1425456016.045.332.961.66-4.51.54
Odalis Perez 1515002 6.2500078 2/31015654 923541126.186.182.631.03-7.31.58
Josh Fogg 1413004 4.5000069 945351 1025415006.655.353.261.30-8.41.72
Byung-Hyun Kim 1412023 8.2730068 2/3795353 1127526126.956.823.541.44-10.51.54
Tomo Ohka 1212001 6.1430061 2/3695048 1321223037.013.213.061.90-14.01.46
Mark Redman 1313104 6.4000170 1/3975855 428354127.044.483.58.51-12.31.78

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database