Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date: End Date:	All Games: Home Games: Road Games:	Playing For: Playing Versus: At Park:
Sort by: Descending Ascending Minimum Innings Pitched: Minimum Decisions: Minimum Games Played: Minimum Games Started: Minimum Complete Games: Minimum Games Finished: Minimum Wins: Minimum Losses:	Minimum Saves: Minimum Shutouts: Minimum Hits: Minimum Runs: Minimum ER: Minimum Home Runs: Minimum Walks: Minimum Strikeouts: Minimum Hit by Pitch: Minimum Balks: Minimum Wild Pitches:

Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Mark Buehrle	16	16	0	0	3	9	.250	0	0	92 1/3	135	76	73	24	20	51	3	1	0	7.12	4.97	1.95	2.34	-18.7	1.68
Josh Fogg	14	14	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	72 2/3	102	58	56	15	26	46	4	0	0	6.94	5.70	3.22	1.86	-11.1	1.76
Mark Redman	16	16	2	0	5	6	.455	0	1	90	118	66	62	11	33	47	6	1	1	6.20	4.70	3.30	1.10	-7.3	1.68
Pedro Astacio	16	16	1	0	5	5	.500	0	1	85 1/3	106	61	58	13	30	39	1	1	0	6.12	4.11	3.16	1.37	-6.4	1.59
Byung-Hyun Kim	15	15	0	0	3	8	.273	0	0	88 1/3	102	61	59	12	33	72	6	1	3	6.01	7.34	3.36	1.22	-4.6	1.53
Matt Morris	16	16	1	0	4	8	.333	0	0	97 2/3	109	68	65	12	30	53	8	3	0	5.99	4.88	2.76	1.11	-6.9	1.42
Runelvys Hernandez	12	12	1	0	5	5	.500	0	1	70	81	47	46	10	34	35	4	2	1	5.91	4.50	4.37	1.29	-2.5	1.64
Paul Byrd	14	14	1	0	3	4	.429	0	0	73 1/3	122	68	48	14	12	28	3	0	1	5.89	3.44	1.47	1.72	-5.5	1.83
Jason Marquis	16	16	0	0	5	9	.357	0	0	90 1/3	111	61	58	15	33	49	8	1	0	5.78	4.88	3.29	1.49	-2.9	1.59
Tim Hudson	17	17	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	100 2/3	124	70	64	16	34	65	4	0	4	5.72	5.81	3.04	1.43	-1.2	1.57
Brad Penny	16	15	0	0	7	7	.500	0	0	87	107	58	55	12	26	69	2	0	4	5.69	7.14	2.69	1.24	2.4	1.53
Ramon Ortiz	16	16	0	0	5	9	.357	0	0	93	106	63	58	19	36	48	10	2	2	5.61	4.65	3.48	1.84	-1.7	1.53
Noah Lowry	15	15	1	0	4	5	.444	0	1	89 1/3	95	58	55	11	35	53	4	0	1	5.54	5.34	3.53	1.11	-1.0	1.46
Carlos Silva	16	16	0	0	6	6	.500	0	0	87	118	59	53	18	19	35	3	0	1	5.48	3.62	1.97	1.86	0.0	1.57
Jamie Moyer	14	14	0	0	4	7	.364	0	0	86 1/3	100	55	52	17	19	42	3	0	0	5.42	4.38	1.98	1.77	-0.6	1.38
Rodrigo Lopez	18	12	0	2	4	8	.333	0	0	82	105	51	49	11	27	68	3	1	1	5.38	7.46	2.96	1.21	2.8	1.61
Gil Meche	15	15	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	82 1/3	85	59	49	13	38	70	3	1	3	5.36	7.65	4.15	1.42	3.2	1.49
Ervin Santana	15	15	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	90 1/3	89	56	53	13	33	67	2	0	5	5.28	6.68	3.29	1.30	4.9	1.35
Jeff Weaver	13	13	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	71 2/3	85	43	42	15	23	38	5	0	1	5.27	4.77	2.89	1.88	1.6	1.51
Eric Milton	15	15	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	84 1/3	90	53	49	16	27	49	4	0	2	5.23	5.23	2.88	1.71	2.1	1.39
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Doug Davis	16	16	1	0	6	6	.500	0	1	100 1/3	105	61	58	8	42	79	1	0	2	5.20	7.09	3.77	.72	6.1	1.47
Randy Johnson	16	16	1	0	8	5	.615	0	0	104 2/3	99	65	60	13	27	87	7	1	1	5.16	7.48	2.32	1.12	9.0	1.20
Steve Trachsel	14	14	0	0	9	3	.750	0	0	75 2/3	83	44	43	11	39	39	1	0	3	5.11	4.64	4.64	1.31	7.7	1.61
Luke Hudson	15	14	0	1	7	3	.700	0	0	83 1/3	90	49	47	7	31	57	3	0	4	5.08	6.16	3.35	.76	7.4	1.45
James Shields	15	15	1	0	2	7	.222	0	0	89 2/3	99	52	50	18	26	70	2	0	9	5.02	7.03	2.61	1.81	3.8	1.39
Josh Beckett	16	16	0	0	6	7	.462	0	0	101	100	57	56	14	42	68	4	0	6	4.99	6.06	3.74	1.25	7.3	1.41
Jose Contreras	16	16	1	0	5	9	.357	0	1	99 1/3	107	62	55	11	28	66	8	0	8	4.98	5.98	2.54	1.00	6.3	1.36
Ted Lilly	15	15	0	0	6	6	.500	0	0	85	86	51	47	12	34	67	4	2	4	4.98	7.09	3.60	1.27	8.2	1.41
Claudio Vargas	14	14	0	0	4	6	.400	0	0	77	89	48	42	14	23	58	5	0	4	4.91	6.78	2.69	1.64	6.3	1.45
Kris Benson	12	12	2	0	2	6	.250	0	0	75 2/3	91	44	41	17	20	38	1	0	1	4.88	4.52	2.38	2.02	2.6	1.47
Mark Hendrickson	16	12	0	0	1	7	.125	0	0	72	89	44	39	7	25	46	2	1	2	4.88	5.75	3.12	.88	2.6	1.58
Joe Blanton	15	15	0	0	9	5	.643	0	0	93	123	53	50	9	25	49	3	0	1	4.84	4.74	2.42	.87	10.4	1.59
Aaron Cook	15	15	0	0	3	7	.300	0	0	97 2/3	112	56	52	8	29	40	4	0	2	4.79	3.69	2.67	.74	3.8	1.44
Curt Schilling	13	13	0	0	4	5	.444	0	0	82 2/3	104	44	44	13	10	72	2	0	0	4.79	7.84	1.09	1.42	8.5	1.38
Chris Capuano	16	16	2	0	2	7	.222	0	1	100 1/3	112	57	53	17	19	67	6	0	5	4.75	6.01	1.70	1.52	5.9	1.31
Tom Glavine	13	13	0	0	3	4	.429	0	0	78 1/3	90	48	41	7	26	47	2	0	1	4.71	5.40	2.99	.80	5.9	1.48
Dave Bush	16	14	1	0	7	5	.583	0	1	90 2/3	94	51	47	12	12	68	12	0	1	4.67	6.75	1.19	1.19	12.1	1.17
Jeremy Bonderman	16	16	0	0	6	4	.600	0	0	97 2/3	110	56	50	12	31	94	1	1	2	4.61	8.66	2.86	1.11	14.2	1.44
Freddy Garcia	15	15	0	0	5	5	.500	0	0	99 2/3	103	57	51	12	21	69	3	0	1	4.61	6.23	1.90	1.08	10.7	1.24
Adam Loewen	13	12	0	0	6	3	.667	0	0	70 2/3	65	37	36	2	35	60	4	1	0	4.58	7.64	4.46	.25	11.3	1.42
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Dan Haren	15	15	1	0	8	6	.571	0	0	96 1/3	104	53	49	13	18	80	1	0	4	4.58	7.47	1.68	1.21	15.2	1.27
Jason Schmidt	14	14	0	0	5	5	.500	0	0	85	88	51	43	9	38	70	4	1	3	4.55	7.41	4.02	.95	11.5	1.48
Cliff Lee	15	15	0	0	5	6	.455	0	0	87	105	56	44	12	26	50	2	0	2	4.55	5.17	2.69	1.24	9.5	1.51
Livan Hernandez	15	15	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	97	110	51	49	13	27	61	2	0	1	4.55	5.66	2.51	1.21	11.6	1.41
Cory Lidle	13	13	0	0	7	4	.636	0	0	71 1/3	73	37	36	16	26	51	4	0	2	4.54	6.43	3.28	2.02	11.8	1.39
Paul Maholm	14	14	0	0	6	3	.667	0	0	83 2/3	88	45	42	9	34	56	5	1	2	4.52	6.02	3.66	.97	11.4	1.46
Kyle Lohse	20	10	0	4	2	5	.286	0	0	74	80	38	37	9	18	60	0	1	3	4.50	7.30	2.19	1.09	8.0	1.32
Ian Snell	15	15	0	0	7	5	.583	0	0	92 1/3	87	46	46	19	38	96	1	0	4	4.48	9.36	3.70	1.85	16.8	1.35
Aaron Harang	17	16	1	0	5	6	.455	0	0	104	115	53	51	15	28	89	5	0	4	4.41	7.70	2.42	1.30	14.9	1.38
Vicente Padilla	15	15	0	0	7	5	.583	0	0	94	101	50	46	11	26	70	6	1	0	4.40	6.70	2.49	1.05	15.0	1.35
Jarrod Washburn	15	15	0	0	4	6	.400	0	0	88	99	48	43	10	30	48	4	0	1	4.40	4.91	3.07	1.02	9.8	1.47
Jon Lieber	15	15	2	0	6	5	.545	0	1	97 1/3	114	54	47	15	15	56	2	0	3	4.35	5.18	1.39	1.39	13.3	1.33
Felix Hernandez	14	14	1	0	3	7	.300	0	1	87	84	44	42	8	31	79	1	0	7	4.34	8.17	3.21	.83	12.4	1.32
Barry Zito	16	16	0	0	8	5	.615	0	0	105 2/3	111	55	51	17	47	61	5	0	1	4.34	5.20	4.00	1.45	15.9	1.50
Javier Vazquez	16	15	1	0	3	6	.333	0	0	95 2/3	91	52	46	12	30	90	6	0	4	4.33	8.47	2.82	1.13	13.8	1.26
Justin Verlander	13	13	0	0	6	5	.545	0	0	77 1/3	87	38	37	10	27	56	1	1	2	4.31	6.52	3.14	1.16	13.3	1.47
Chris Young	14	14	0	0	4	2	.667	0	0	75 1/3	62	37	36	14	30	70	2	1	2	4.30	8.36	3.58	1.67	12.7	1.22
Bronson Arroyo	16	16	1	0	5	6	.455	0	1	108	104	53	51	19	33	87	4	0	4	4.25	7.25	2.75	1.58	16.7	1.27
Kevin Millwood	15	15	1	0	8	6	.571	0	0	97 2/3	90	50	46	10	26	71	1	0	1	4.24	6.54	2.40	.92	17.9	1.19
Mike Mussina	12	12	0	0	5	3	.625	0	0	70 1/3	76	35	33	7	12	62	3	0	1	4.22	7.93	1.54	.90	13.4	1.25
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Jae Seo	14	14	0	0	1	6	.143	0	0	81 1/3	105	43	38	13	27	35	1	0	4	4.20	3.87	2.99	1.44	7.2	1.62
Nate Robertson	15	15	1	0	5	9	.357	0	0	103 2/3	102	51	48	14	30	65	2	0	3	4.17	5.64	2.60	1.22	15.3	1.27
John Lackey	16	16	2	0	7	6	.538	0	2	103 2/3	118	51	47	4	35	102	4	0	7	4.08	8.86	3.04	.35	22.0	1.48
Chuck James	14	14	0	0	8	4	.667	0	0	81 2/3	75	40	37	13	32	61	2	0	1	4.08	6.72	3.53	1.43	17.9	1.31
A.J. Burnett	16	16	1	0	8	7	.533	0	0	104 1/3	111	53	47	10	34	86	5	1	4	4.05	7.42	2.93	.86	21.8	1.39
Brett Myers	13	13	1	0	7	3	.700	0	0	87	81	40	39	15	23	95	2	0	1	4.03	9.83	2.38	1.55	21.0	1.20
Carlos Zambrano	15	15	0	0	10	3	.769	0	0	94	81	47	42	8	49	89	2	0	7	4.02	8.52	4.69	.77	23.9	1.38
Greg Maddux	16	16	0	0	6	6	.500	0	0	98 2/3	102	49	44	7	18	54	0	0	0	4.01	4.93	1.64	.64	16.7	1.22
Esteban Loaiza	16	16	1	0	8	4	.667	0	1	101 2/3	109	50	45	9	22	73	4	0	1	3.98	6.46	1.95	.80	21.1	1.29
Orlando Hernandez	12	12	0	0	6	3	.667	0	0	73	61	36	32	8	24	73	5	2	0	3.95	9.00	2.96	.99	17.8	1.16
Zach Duke	16	16	1	0	5	7	.417	0	0	102 2/3	120	52	45	6	27	52	4	1	4	3.94	4.56	2.37	.53	16.5	1.43
Jake Westbrook	14	14	2	0	7	6	.538	0	1	96 1/3	128	46	42	7	25	46	1	0	3	3.92	4.30	2.34	.65	17.8	1.59
Josh Johnson	14	14	0	0	5	3	.625	0	0	83 1/3	75	39	36	11	35	69	3	0	0	3.89	7.45	3.78	1.19	17.6	1.32
Jeff Francis	15	15	1	0	8	4	.667	0	1	95 1/3	96	47	40	8	26	50	5	0	0	3.78	4.72	2.45	.76	20.7	1.28
Jake Peavy	15	15	1	0	6	6	.500	0	0	96 1/3	86	41	40	9	35	99	2	0	1	3.74	9.25	3.27	.84	24.1	1.26
John Smoltz	16	16	1	0	10	4	.714	0	0	107	103	45	44	11	23	107	2	0	3	3.70	9.00	1.93	.93	30.2	1.18
Derek Lowe	17	16	0	1	9	4	.692	0	0	101	109	45	41	7	20	62	1	1	1	3.65	5.52	1.78	.62	24.7	1.28
Woody Williams	15	15	0	0	7	4	.636	0	0	91 1/3	102	44	37	12	19	44	3	0	3	3.65	4.34	1.87	1.18	20.1	1.32
Miguel Batista	16	16	2	0	4	2	.667	0	1	105 2/3	97	44	42	5	42	48	4	1	5	3.58	4.09	3.58	.43	19.6	1.32
Dontrelle Willis	15	15	1	0	7	4	.636	0	1	101	100	45	40	9	43	89	5	0	3	3.56	7.93	3.83	.80	26.4	1.42
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Scott Olsen	15	15	0	0	6	4	.600	0	0	91 2/3	81	40	36	9	37	88	0	0	4	3.53	8.64	3.63	.88	24.6	1.29
Kenny Rogers	15	15	0	0	7	3	.700	0	0	89 1/3	82	40	35	10	33	36	3	0	4	3.53	3.63	3.32	1.01	20.3	1.29
Ben Sheets	11	11	0	0	4	4	.500	0	0	71 2/3	66	30	28	8	9	75	2	0	0	3.52	9.42	1.13	1.00	19.3	1.05
Cole Hamels	15	15	0	0	8	4	.667	0	0	88 2/3	73	38	34	13	27	103	1	0	3	3.45	10.45	2.74	1.32	28.6	1.13
Clay Hensley	15	13	0	1	5	5	.500	0	0	83 2/3	83	37	32	6	37	65	2	0	2	3.44	6.99	3.98	.65	21.3	1.43
John Maine	14	13	1	1	6	4	.600	0	1	78 2/3	60	33	30	13	28	62	2	0	2	3.43	7.09	3.20	1.49	21.5	1.12
Jason Jennings	15	15	1	0	3	6	.333	0	0	99 1/3	88	38	37	6	39	65	3	0	3	3.35	5.89	3.53	.54	22.2	1.28
Jeremy Sowers	13	13	2	0	7	3	.700	0	2	83 1/3	80	32	31	8	19	32	2	0	1	3.35	3.46	2.05	.86	20.9	1.19
Roy Halladay	16	16	1	0	6	3	.667	0	0	105 1/3	101	39	37	8	21	70	1	0	2	3.16	5.98	1.79	.68	28.7	1.16
Jon Garland	15	14	1	0	10	3	.769	0	1	96 1/3	108	34	33	6	13	49	4	0	0	3.08	4.58	1.21	.56	30.1	1.26
Brandon Webb	14	14	3	0	8	4	.667	0	1	99 2/3	79	39	34	7	29	77	2	0	2	3.07	6.95	2.62	.63	31.5	1.08
Chien-Ming Wang	15	15	1	0	10	3	.769	0	1	99 2/3	107	34	34	6	24	34	0	0	2	3.07	3.07	2.17	.54	29.2	1.31
CC Sabathia	15	15	4	0	5	7	.417	0	1	110	109	49	37	10	24	93	6	0	3	3.03	7.61	1.96	.82	32.3	1.21
Johan Santana	16	16	0	0	9	2	.818	0	0	107 1/3	85	41	36	12	27	116	2	0	3	3.02	9.73	2.26	1.01	38.3	1.04
Chris Carpenter	16	16	5	0	9	3	.750	0	3	116 2/3	89	40	39	11	15	90	5	0	2	3.01	6.94	1.16	.85	37.3	.89
Matt Cain	15	15	0	0	7	4	.636	0	0	96 2/3	72	33	32	7	40	101	4	1	4	2.98	9.40	3.72	.65	33.4	1.16
Rich Hill	12	11	2	1	6	3	.667	0	1	73	54	29	24	10	22	72	2	0	2	2.96	8.88	2.71	1.23	25.7	1.04
Anibal Sanchez	16	15	2	0	8	3	.727	0	1	103 2/3	77	37	34	9	42	68	4	1	3	2.95	5.90	3.65	.78	32.6	1.15
Jeff Suppan	14	14	0	0	6	3	.667	0	0	87	89	34	28	7	26	52	4	0	3	2.90	5.38	2.69	.72	26.7	1.32
Roy Oswalt	16	15	1	1	8	4	.667	0	0	103 2/3	101	33	33	9	14	86	2	0	0	2.86	7.47	1.22	.78	35.4	1.11
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Andy Pettitte	16	15	1	1	7	4	.636	0	0	92 2/3	88	36	29	7	30	88	1	1	1	2.82	8.55	2.91	.68	33.1	1.27
Chad Billingsley	13	13	0	0	6	3	.667	0	0	70 1/3	65	27	22	6	42	52	2	0	3	2.82	6.65	5.37	.77	24.4	1.52
Kelvim Escobar	14	14	1	0	6	4	.600	0	0	94	83	31	28	6	22	77	1	0	2	2.68	7.37	2.11	.57	32.7	1.12
Erik Bedard	15	15	0	0	7	4	.636	0	0	96	86	35	28	6	29	93	0	0	4	2.62	8.72	2.72	.56	36.3	1.20
Jered Weaver	14	14	0	0	7	2	.778	0	0	90	68	26	26	11	27	78	2	0	2	2.60	7.80	2.70	1.10	33.8	1.06
Roger Clemens	15	15	0	0	7	3	.700	0	0	91	70	27	24	7	24	82	4	0	3	2.37	8.11	2.37	.69	36.7	1.03

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database