Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date: End Date:	All Games: Home Games: Road Games:	Playing For: Playing Versus: At Park:
Sort by: Descending Ascending Minimum Innings Pitched: Minimum Decisions: Minimum Games Played: Minimum Games Started: Minimum Complete Games: Minimum Games Finished: Minimum Wins: Minimum Losses:	Minimum Saves: Minimum Shutouts: Minimum Hits: Minimum Runs: Minimum ER: Minimum Home Runs: Minimum Walks: Minimum Strikeouts: Minimum Hit by Pitch: Minimum Balks: Minimum Wild Pitches:

Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Johan Santana	34	34	1	0	19	8	.704	0	1	230 1/3	180	81	72	27	57	244	5	1	8	2.81	9.53	2.23	1.05	86.6	1.03
Chris Young	31	31	0	0	12	5	.706	0	0	179	129	65	58	17	71	163	6	3	5	2.92	8.20	3.57	.85	59.8	1.12
Jake Peavy	33	33	1	0	16	8	.667	0	0	213 1/3	180	73	70	10	71	227	7	0	3	2.95	9.58	3.00	.42	75.4	1.18
CC Sabathia	33	33	5	0	17	9	.654	0	2	239 1/3	231	96	80	22	41	208	9	0	3	3.01	7.82	1.54	.83	77.5	1.14
Andy Pettitte	36	33	1	1	12	10	.545	0	0	211 1/3	212	86	71	15	63	154	2	1	3	3.02	6.56	2.68	.64	62.1	1.30
Rich Hill	28	27	2	1	11	8	.579	0	1	175	132	66	59	26	53	164	6	1	2	3.03	8.43	2.73	1.34	55.9	1.06
Erik Bedard	33	33	0	0	13	9	.591	0	0	208	190	81	72	17	66	224	4	0	5	3.12	9.69	2.86	.74	67.4	1.23
Roy Oswalt	36	35	3	1	16	10	.615	0	0	239 2/3	235	84	83	20	60	183	6	1	1	3.12	6.87	2.25	.75	71.1	1.23
John Maine	30	29	1	1	14	8	.636	0	1	178 2/3	138	66	62	24	69	143	2	0	4	3.12	7.20	3.48	1.21	55.6	1.16
John Smoltz	34	34	1	0	20	8	.714	0	0	222 2/3	217	81	78	19	50	206	5	0	7	3.15	8.33	2.02	.77	73.9	1.20
Ben Sheets	28	28	2	0	13	7	.650	0	0	181 2/3	170	68	64	19	30	153	3	0	3	3.17	7.58	1.49	.94	55.1	1.10
Dan Haren	34	34	1	0	17	9	.654	0	0	225 1/3	196	93	81	27	49	184	3	0	9	3.24	7.35	1.96	1.08	67.1	1.09
Kelvim Escobar	30	30	3	0	15	9	.625	0	1	196 1/3	179	78	71	12	54	159	3	0	8	3.25	7.29	2.48	.55	58.1	1.19
Chien-Ming Wang	29	29	2	0	18	7	.720	0	1	198 1/3	204	73	73	11	44	81	6	0	6	3.31	3.68	2.00	.50	52.3	1.25
Justin Verlander	30	30	1	0	17	7	.708	0	1	187 1/3	172	73	69	18	63	151	11	2	10	3.31	7.25	3.03	.86	56.8	1.25
Tom Gorzelanny	27	27	0	0	9	9	.500	0	0	166 1/3	154	66	62	10	61	104	8	1	7	3.35	5.63	3.30	.54	40.6	1.29
John Lackey	33	33	2	0	19	10	.655	0	2	217	217	91	82	15	65	192	11	0	11	3.40	7.96	2.70	.62	64.7	1.30
Brandon Webb	33	33	4	0	15	10	.600	0	1	229 2/3	200	105	89	16	70	190	5	0	6	3.49	7.45	2.74	.63	59.8	1.18
Jon Garland	32	31	1	0	16	9	.640	0	1	213 1/3	220	92	83	13	44	105	4	0	1	3.50	4.43	1.86	.55	50.2	1.24
Matt Cain	33	33	1	0	9	15	.375	0	0	210	169	85	84	14	101	186	6	1	12	3.60	7.97	4.33	.60	48.6	1.29
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Roy Halladay	30	30	3	0	15	5	.750	0	0	202	201	87	82	18	36	133	2	0	2	3.65	5.93	1.60	.80	47.3	1.17
Jeff Francis	32	32	1	0	15	9	.625	0	1	207 2/3	213	93	86	17	56	125	10	1	1	3.73	5.42	2.43	.74	45.3	1.30
Derek Lowe	35	34	3	1	18	11	.621	0	0	221 1/3	223	101	92	13	55	146	3	3	2	3.74	5.94	2.24	.53	51.3	1.26
Aaron Harang	36	35	4	0	16	8	.667	0	0	236 2/3	233	105	99	26	54	208	9	2	13	3.76	7.91	2.05	.99	56.1	1.21
Ian Snell	32	32	1	0	13	12	.520	0	0	204	194	90	86	26	74	183	5	0	10	3.79	8.07	3.26	1.15	47.3	1.31
Cole Hamels	33	33	2	0	17	8	.680	0	0	206 1/3	191	97	89	33	55	225	5	0	7	3.88	9.81	2.40	1.44	53.7	1.19
Brad Penny	34	33	0	0	18	8	.692	0	0	197 2/3	211	90	86	16	56	149	6	0	9	3.92	6.78	2.55	.73	45.7	1.35
A.J. Burnett	32	32	4	0	15	13	.536	0	1	209 2/3	195	100	92	23	76	201	15	1	8	3.95	8.63	3.26	.99	47.9	1.29
Felix Hernandez	27	27	2	0	9	11	.450	0	2	164	168	75	73	15	51	156	3	0	12	4.01	8.56	2.80	.82	33.6	1.34
Joe Blanton	33	32	2	0	16	10	.615	0	1	213	234	102	95	20	49	136	3	1	4	4.01	5.75	2.07	.85	41.1	1.33
Greg Maddux	34	34	1	0	14	11	.560	0	0	210	219	100	94	17	33	116	2	0	3	4.03	4.97	1.41	.73	36.6	1.20
Gil Meche	33	33	0	0	8	10	.444	0	0	199	203	109	90	24	72	158	5	2	3	4.07	7.15	3.26	1.09	33.3	1.38
Chuck James	34	34	0	0	17	11	.607	0	0	193 2/3	190	93	88	32	79	149	7	0	1	4.09	6.92	3.67	1.49	40.7	1.39
Jeff Suppan	33	33	1	0	14	10	.583	0	0	204 1/3	225	104	93	19	68	107	9	0	6	4.10	4.71	3.00	.84	33.9	1.43
Carlos Zambrano	33	33	1	0	18	10	.643	0	0	214 1/3	186	109	98	25	99	192	10	0	10	4.12	8.06	4.16	1.05	46.4	1.33
Scott Olsen	34	34	0	0	11	13	.458	0	0	197	199	106	91	22	86	169	4	0	9	4.16	7.72	3.93	1.01	35.4	1.45
Dontrelle Willis	35	35	2	0	15	12	.556	0	1	219 2/3	232	112	102	25	97	173	12	2	6	4.18	7.09	3.97	1.02	40.1	1.50
Jeremy Bonderman	32	32	0	0	15	4	.789	0	0	198	209	103	92	21	52	181	3	2	9	4.18	8.23	2.36	.95	40.1	1.32
Ted Lilly	32	32	0	0	13	10	.565	0	0	189 1/3	175	97	88	26	54	164	7	3	8	4.18	7.80	2.57	1.24	36.1	1.21
Josh Beckett	32	32	0	0	18	9	.667	0	0	206 1/3	189	100	97	23	64	162	7	0	7	4.23	7.07	2.79	1.00	40.4	1.23
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Curt Schilling	30	30	1	0	12	9	.571	0	1	191	226	93	91	26	34	158	4	0	0	4.29	7.45	1.60	1.23	32.3	1.36
Jarrod Washburn	31	31	1	0	10	12	.455	0	1	186 1/3	199	98	89	19	62	102	8	1	2	4.30	4.93	2.99	.92	24.4	1.40
Noah Lowry	32	32	2	0	12	11	.522	0	1	198 2/3	193	105	96	18	85	112	7	0	4	4.35	5.07	3.85	.82	26.5	1.40
Tom Glavine	32	32	0	0	10	10	.500	0	0	192	210	104	93	21	64	104	5	0	2	4.36	4.88	3.00	.98	23.4	1.43
Livan Hernandez	34	34	1	0	13	10	.565	0	0	217	241	110	106	25	86	118	3	1	1	4.40	4.89	3.57	1.04	27.3	1.51
Matt Morris	33	33	4	0	12	12	.500	0	0	214 2/3	226	117	105	19	64	116	11	3	1	4.40	4.86	2.68	.80	25.9	1.35
Randy Johnson	26	26	1	0	13	7	.650	0	0	165 1/3	149	87	81	19	38	166	10	1	2	4.41	9.04	2.07	1.03	31.3	1.13
Bronson Arroyo	35	35	2	0	7	16	.304	0	1	227	234	125	112	29	76	166	9	0	6	4.44	6.58	3.01	1.15	25.1	1.37
James Shields	31	31	2	0	8	10	.444	0	0	203 1/3	201	104	101	34	47	166	8	0	12	4.47	7.35	2.08	1.50	25.3	1.22
Claudio Vargas	31	29	0	1	12	7	.632	1	0	162 1/3	178	91	81	27	58	132	6	0	8	4.49	7.32	3.22	1.50	25.4	1.45
Barry Zito	33	33	0	0	14	15	.483	0	0	204 1/3	210	110	102	26	93	123	7	1	2	4.49	5.42	4.10	1.15	26.5	1.48
Miguel Batista	35	33	2	0	12	9	.571	0	1	205 2/3	219	112	103	16	83	116	8	3	11	4.51	5.08	3.63	.70	23.4	1.47
Nate Robertson	29	29	1	0	10	16	.385	0	0	181	203	96	91	27	58	105	2	1	7	4.52	5.22	2.88	1.34	20.0	1.44
Jon Lieber	30	28	3	1	9	12	.429	0	2	180 2/3	212	101	91	23	37	112	5	1	4	4.53	5.58	1.84	1.15	19.5	1.38
Chris Capuano	31	31	2	0	8	13	.381	0	1	183 2/3	197	104	93	26	52	133	9	0	8	4.56	6.52	2.55	1.27	20.1	1.36
Tim Hudson	35	35	0	0	13	11	.542	0	0	216 2/3	230	117	110	22	67	126	9	0	7	4.57	5.23	2.78	.91	23.9	1.37
Cliff Lee	28	28	2	0	12	10	.545	0	0	166 2/3	187	100	85	25	53	103	8	0	4	4.59	5.56	2.86	1.35	20.6	1.44
Doug Davis	33	33	1	0	12	14	.462	0	1	199 1/3	219	112	102	18	98	154	5	1	5	4.61	6.95	4.42	.81	25.1	1.59
Jamie Moyer	32	32	1	0	13	13	.500	0	0	202 1/3	210	109	104	35	54	106	7	0	2	4.63	4.71	2.40	1.56	20.8	1.30
Kyle Lohse	38	27	1	5	6	15	.286	0	1	180 2/3	199	99	93	21	45	123	3	1	5	4.63	6.13	2.24	1.05	15.6	1.35
Player	Games	GS	CG	GF	W	L	WPct	Sv	Sho	IP	H	R	ER	HR	BB	K	HBP	BK	WP	ERA	K9	BB9	HR9	Cy Young Pts	WHIP
Dave Bush	33	31	1	0	12	11	.522	0	1	197 2/3	209	108	102	22	31	148	18	0	3	4.64	6.74	1.41	1.00	23.6	1.21
Carlos Silva	34	34	2	0	13	15	.464	0	1	197	241	108	102	26	41	79	7	1	4	4.66	3.61	1.87	1.19	17.4	1.43
Zach Duke	34	34	1	0	8	14	.364	0	0	204 2/3	271	120	107	17	50	87	7	2	5	4.71	3.83	2.20	.75	12.0	1.57
Javier Vazquez	33	32	1	0	6	13	.316	0	0	204 1/3	194	113	107	29	57	195	9	0	10	4.71	8.59	2.51	1.28	20.7	1.23
Woody Williams	33	33	0	0	12	14	.462	0	0	196 1/3	227	115	103	33	54	93	10	2	4	4.72	4.26	2.48	1.51	16.5	1.43
Ervin Santana	33	33	0	0	13	12	.520	0	0	203	197	113	107	30	74	147	7	0	9	4.74	6.52	3.28	1.33	22.2	1.33
Paul Maholm	30	30	1	0	9	14	.391	0	1	181 1/3	196	106	97	22	63	113	9	1	4	4.81	5.61	3.13	1.09	14.0	1.43
Steve Trachsel	32	32	1	0	15	10	.600	0	0	176 2/3	183	98	96	24	90	73	3	3	5	4.89	3.72	4.58	1.22	14.6	1.55
Daniel Cabrera	30	30	3	0	11	14	.440	0	1	187	170	108	102	20	98	168	13	1	14	4.91	8.09	4.72	.96	19.3	1.43
Freddy Garcia	29	29	0	0	9	10	.474	0	0	177 2/3	200	104	97	27	43	128	10	0	6	4.91	6.48	2.18	1.37	13.6	1.37
Aaron Cook	33	33	1	0	8	13	.381	0	0	215 1/3	245	126	118	19	63	79	8	0	2	4.93	3.30	2.63	.79	5.6	1.43
Jose Contreras	32	32	2	0	10	17	.370	0	2	194	216	125	107	17	62	122	14	0	9	4.96	5.66	2.88	.79	12.2	1.43
Jason Marquis	33	33	1	0	10	15	.400	0	1	186 1/3	198	117	104	28	71	105	14	1	1	5.02	5.07	3.43	1.35	9.7	1.44
Paul Byrd	29	29	1	0	10	7	.588	0	0	166	249	117	94	27	21	82	4	0	2	5.10	4.45	1.14	1.46	7.2	1.63
Mark Buehrle	31	31	2	0	8	13	.381	0	1	192 1/3	223	113	110	38	38	115	6	1	1	5.15	5.38	1.78	1.78	5.7	1.36
Vicente Padilla	33	33	0	0	12	14	.462	0	0	194	229	127	114	24	68	130	13	2	2	5.29	6.03	3.15	1.11	8.0	1.53
Josh Fogg	30	29	1	0	9	10	.474	0	1	165 1/3	199	107	99	25	54	99	8	0	3	5.39	5.39	2.94	1.36	2.6	1.53
Kevin Millwood	30	30	1	0	12	15	.444	0	0	174 2/3	203	117	109	27	57	134	7	0	3	5.62	6.90	2.94	1.39	3.7	1.49
Ramon Ortiz	34	29	0	4	9	15	.375	0	0	178 1/3	217	119	113	31	49	87	16	2	3	5.70	4.39	2.47	1.56	-6.1	1.49

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database