Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Jake Peavy 34340019 6.76000223 1/31696763 13682406042.549.672.74.5291.71.06
Brandon Webb 34344018 10.64303236 1/32099179 12721945033.017.392.74.4676.61.19
John Lackey 33332019 9.67902224 2198775 185217912193.017.192.09.7273.91.21
Brad Penny 33330016 4.80000208 1997570 9731355063.035.843.16.3963.51.31
Fausto Carmona 32322019 8.70401215 1997873 166113711153.065.732.55.6767.21.21
Dan Haren 34340015 9.62500222 2/32149176 245519230103.077.762.22.9769.51.21
John Smoltz 32320014 8.63600205 2/31967871 18471974083.118.622.06.7965.51.18
Chris Young 3030009 8.52900173 1186660 10721677473.128.693.75.5252.21.10
Erik Bedard 28281013 5.72201182 1416664 19572215033.1610.932.82.9462.11.09
Roy Oswalt 33321014 7.66700212 2218075 14601547113.186.542.55.5960.41.33
CC Sabathia 34344019 7.73101241 2389486 20372098013.217.801.38.7574.41.14
Josh Beckett 30301020 7.74100200 2/31897673 17401945033.278.701.79.7666.71.14
Johan Santana 33331015 13.53601219 1838881 33522354173.339.662.141.3667.01.07
Tim Hudson 34341016 10.61501224 1/32218783 10531328253.335.302.13.4058.41.22
Cole Hamels 28282015 5.75000183 1/31637269 25431773053.398.692.111.2355.41.12
Kelvim Escobar 30303018 7.72001195 2/31827974 11661603093.407.363.04.5157.81.27
Scott Kazmir 34340013 9.59100206 2/31969180 188923970103.4810.413.88.7860.21.38
Oliver Perez 29290015 10.60000177 1539070 22791747063.568.854.021.1250.91.31
Mark Buehrle 30303010 9.52601201 2088681 22451155013.635.152.01.9941.01.26
Matt Cain 3232107 16.30400200 1738481 147916350123.657.333.56.6342.31.26
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Justin Verlander 32321018 6.75001201 2/31818882 2067183192173.668.172.99.8955.11.23
Gil Meche 3434109 13.40900216 2189888 22621563033.676.502.58.9244.61.30
Jeremy Guthrie 3226037 5.58300175 1/31657872 23471234183.706.312.411.1835.01.21
Adam Wainwright 32321014 12.53800202 2129383 13701369063.706.063.12.5845.61.40
Chien-Ming Wang 30301019 7.73100199 1/31998482 9591048193.704.702.66.4147.11.29
Roy Halladay 31317016 7.69601225 1/323210193 15481393043.715.551.92.6049.61.24
Aaron Harang 34342016 6.72701231 2/321310096 285221881123.738.472.021.0957.61.14
Javier Vazquez 32322015 8.65200216 2/31979590 29502137053.748.852.081.2054.61.14
A.J. Burnett 25252010 8.55600165 2/31317469 236617612053.759.563.591.2541.41.19
Ian Snell 3232109 12.42900208 2099487 226817780123.767.662.94.9543.71.33
Ted Lilly 34340015 8.65200207 1819188 28551743073.837.572.391.2247.91.14
James Shields 31311012 8.60000215 2029892 283618410093.857.701.511.1745.91.11
Brian Bannister 27271012 9.57100165 1567671 1544776043.874.202.40.8231.21.21
Curt Schilling 2424109 8.52901151 1656865 21231012003.876.021.371.2529.61.25
Tom Gorzelanny 32321014 10.58301201 2/32149087 186813511153.886.023.03.8041.31.40
Derek Lowe 33323012 14.46200199 1/319410086 20591471133.886.642.66.9040.41.27
John Maine 32321015 10.60001191 1689083 23751805023.918.483.531.0845.51.27
Jered Weaver 28280013 7.65000161 1787770 17451152043.916.432.52.9535.01.39
Rich Hill 32320011 8.57900195 1708985 276318312113.928.452.911.2541.81.19
Noah Lowry 26261014 8.63600156 1557668 1287875053.925.025.02.6932.71.55
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Felix Hernandez 30301014 7.66701190 1/32098883 20531653173.927.802.51.9542.71.38
Joe Blanton 34343014 10.58301230 240106101 16401404133.955.481.57.6342.01.22
Carlos Zambrano 34341018 13.58100216 1/318710095 2310117714033.957.364.20.9648.91.33
Andy Pettitte 36340015 9.62500215 1/323810697 16691411034.055.892.88.6739.81.43
Dustin McGowan 27272012 10.54501169 2/31468077 146114420134.087.643.24.7434.21.22
Aaron Cook 2525208 7.53300166 1788776 1544616004.123.312.39.8121.11.34
Shaun Marcum 38250612 6.66710159 1497673 27491225014.136.912.771.5330.71.25
Greg Maddux 34341014 11.56000198 2219291 14251046054.144.731.14.6432.41.24
Carlos Silva 33332013 14.48101202 2299994 2036894144.193.971.60.8928.91.31
Jeff Francis 34341017 9.65401215 1/3234103101 25631657114.226.902.631.0440.21.38
Bronson Arroyo 3434109 15.37500210 2/323210999 286315613044.236.662.691.2030.91.40
Jon Garland 32322010 13.43501208 1/321911498 1957984014.234.232.46.8226.01.32
Chuck James 30300011 10.52400161 1/31647776 32581161114.246.473.241.7927.31.38
Doug Davis 33330013 12.52000192 2/321110091 219514451104.256.734.44.9832.71.59
Miguel Batista 33320016 11.59300193 20910192 188513382154.296.203.96.8433.81.52
Micah Owings 2927208 8.50001152 2/31468173 205010614054.306.252.951.1821.91.28
Jarrod Washburn 32321010 15.40001193 2/320110293 23671148124.325.303.111.0725.21.38
Jake Westbrook 2525006 9.40000152 1597873 1355936034.325.513.26.7718.31.41
Daisuke Matsuzaka 32321015 12.55600204 2/3191100100 258020113054.408.843.521.1037.41.32
Chad Gaudin 34341011 13.45800199 1/320510898 211001548134.426.954.52.9528.11.53
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Tom Glavine 34341013 8.61901200 1/321910299 2364894024.454.002.881.0323.11.41
Barry Zito 34330011 13.45800196 2/318210599 24831314054.535.993.801.1023.41.35
Wandy Rodriguez 3131109 13.40901182 2/317910293 22621585034.587.783.051.0823.11.32
Paul Byrd 31312015 8.65202192 1/323910798 2728886054.594.121.311.2622.01.39
Jason Marquis 34331012 9.57101191 2/319011198 227610913034.605.123.571.0320.71.39
Jeff Suppan 34341012 12.50000206 2/3243113106 186811411074.624.962.96.7820.71.50
Kyle Lohse 3432209 12.42901192 2/320710999 225712212034.625.702.661.0318.51.37
Matt Chico 3131007 9.43800167 1839686 2674945074.635.073.991.4013.91.54
Nate Robertson 3030009 13.40900177 2/31999894 22631193154.766.033.191.1115.71.47
Tim Wakefield 31310017 12.58600189 191104100 226411040104.765.243.051.0522.51.35
Matt Morris 32323010 11.47600198 2/3240123108 18611029044.894.622.76.8211.51.52
Steve Trachsel 2929107 11.38900158 1768986 1976562374.903.194.331.08 5.61.59
Livan Hernandez 33331011 11.50000204 1/3247116112 3479906234.933.963.481.5010.21.60
Braden Looper 31300012 12.50000175 18310096 2251874304.944.472.621.1312.21.34
Josh Fogg 30290010 9.52600165 2/31949991 23599413034.945.113.211.2511.21.53
Jeremy Bonderman 28280011 9.55000174 1/319310597 234814541125.017.492.481.1915.71.38
Jamie Moyer 33331014 12.53800199 1/3222118111 30661335025.016.012.981.3516.01.44
Paul Maholm 29292010 15.40001177 2/320411099 22491056055.025.322.481.1110.31.42
Boof Bonser 3130008 12.40000173 19910898 27651365135.107.083.381.4010.11.53
Chris Capuano 2925005 12.29400150 1709385 205413280105.107.923.241.20 8.21.49
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Dave Bush 33310212 10.54500186 1/3217110106 274413411035.126.472.131.3012.61.40
Mike Mussina 28270011 10.52400152 1889087 1435914015.155.392.07.83 9.11.47
Kevin Millwood 31310010 14.41700172 2/321311199 19671238045.166.413.49.99 9.61.62
Dontrelle Willis 35350010 15.40000205 1/3241131118 298714614195.176.403.811.27 9.31.60
Woody Williams 3331008 15.34800188 216114110 355310112215.274.842.541.68 2.11.43
Matt Belisle 3030108 9.47100177 2/3212111105 26431257165.326.332.181.32 4.31.44
David Wells 2929009 9.50000157 1/32019795 2242823015.434.692.401.26 0.91.54
Daniel Cabrera 3434109 18.33300204 1/3207133126 2510816615275.557.314.761.10 1.81.54
Jose Contreras 32302210 17.37002189 232134117 216211315035.575.382.951.00-1.21.56
Kip Wells 3426047 17.29200162 2/3186116103 19781229185.706.754.321.05-2.51.62
Edwin Jackson 3231105 15.25001161 195116103 19881284175.767.164.921.06-4.71.76
Ervin Santana 2826017 14.33300150 17410396 26581268075.767.563.481.56-1.41.55
Scott Olsen 33330010 15.40000176 2/3226134114 29851331085.816.784.331.48-2.41.76
Adam Eaton 30300010 10.50000161 2/3192117113 30719711066.295.403.951.67-12.51.63

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database