Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons
Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
You may also specify just home or just road games.
Default dates are first and last games in the database.
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Jake Peavy
34 34 0 0 19
6 .760 0 0 223 1/3 169 67 63
13 68 240 6 0 4 2.54 9.67 2.74 .52 91.7 1.06
Brandon Webb
34 34 4 0 18
10 .643 0 3 236 1/3 209 91 79
12 72 194 5 0 3 3.01 7.39 2.74 .46 76.6 1.19
John Lackey
33 33 2 0 19
9 .679 0 2 224 219 87 75
18 52 179 12 1 9 3.01 7.19 2.09 .72 73.9 1.21
Brad Penny
33 33 0 0 16
4 .800 0 0 208 199 75 70
9 73 135 5 0 6 3.03 5.84 3.16 .39 63.5 1.31
Fausto Carmona
32 32 2 0 19
8 .704 0 1 215 199 78 73
16 61 137 11 1 5 3.06 5.73 2.55 .67 67.2 1.21
Dan Haren
34 34 0 0 15
9 .625 0 0 222 2/3 214 91 76
24 55 192 3 0 10 3.07 7.76 2.22 .97 69.5 1.21
John Smoltz
32 32 0 0 14
8 .636 0 0 205 2/3 196 78 71
18 47 197 4 0 8 3.11 8.62 2.06 .79 65.5 1.18
Chris Young
30 30 0 0 9
8 .529 0 0 173 118 66 60
10 72 167 7 4 7 3.12 8.69 3.75 .52 52.2 1.10
Erik Bedard
28 28 1 0 13
5 .722 0 1 182 141 66 64
19 57 221 5 0 3 3.16 10.93 2.82 .94 62.1 1.09
Roy Oswalt
33 32 1 0 14
7 .667 0 0 212 221 80 75
14 60 154 7 1 1 3.18 6.54 2.55 .59 60.4 1.33
CC Sabathia
34 34 4 0 19
7 .731 0 1 241 238 94 86
20 37 209 8 0 1 3.21 7.80 1.38 .75 74.4 1.14
Josh Beckett
30 30 1 0 20
7 .741 0 0 200 2/3 189 76 73
17 40 194 5 0 3 3.27 8.70 1.79 .76 66.7 1.14
Johan Santana
33 33 1 0 15
13 .536 0 1 219 183 88 81
33 52 235 4 1 7 3.33 9.66 2.14 1.36 67.0 1.07
Tim Hudson
34 34 1 0 16
10 .615 0 1 224 1/3 221 87 83
10 53 132 8 2 5 3.33 5.30 2.13 .40 58.4 1.22
Cole Hamels
28 28 2 0 15
5 .750 0 0 183 1/3 163 72 69
25 43 177 3 0 5 3.39 8.69 2.11 1.23 55.4 1.12
Kelvim Escobar
30 30 3 0 18
7 .720 0 1 195 2/3 182 79 74
11 66 160 3 0 9 3.40 7.36 3.04 .51 57.8 1.27
Scott Kazmir
34 34 0 0 13
9 .591 0 0 206 2/3 196 91 80
18 89 239 7 0 10 3.48 10.41 3.88 .78 60.2 1.38
Oliver Perez
29 29 0 0 15
10 .600 0 0 177 153 90 70
22 79 174 7 0 6 3.56 8.85 4.02 1.12 50.9 1.31
Mark Buehrle
30 30 3 0 10
9 .526 0 1 201 208 86 81
22 45 115 5 0 1 3.63 5.15 2.01 .99 41.0 1.26
Matt Cain
32 32 1 0 7
16 .304 0 0 200 173 84 81
14 79 163 5 0 12 3.65 7.33 3.56 .63 42.3 1.26
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Justin Verlander
32 32 1 0 18
6 .750 0 1 201 2/3 181 88 82
20 67 183 19 2 17 3.66 8.17 2.99 .89 55.1 1.23
Gil Meche
34 34 1 0 9
13 .409 0 0 216 218 98 88
22 62 156 3 0 3 3.67 6.50 2.58 .92 44.6 1.30
Jeremy Guthrie
32 26 0 3 7
5 .583 0 0 175 1/3 165 78 72
23 47 123 4 1 8 3.70 6.31 2.41 1.18 35.0 1.21
Adam Wainwright
32 32 1 0 14
12 .538 0 0 202 212 93 83
13 70 136 9 0 6 3.70 6.06 3.12 .58 45.6 1.40
Chien-Ming Wang
30 30 1 0 19
7 .731 0 0 199 1/3 199 84 82
9 59 104 8 1 9 3.70 4.70 2.66 .41 47.1 1.29
Roy Halladay
31 31 7 0 16
7 .696 0 1 225 1/3 232 101 93
15 48 139 3 0 4 3.71 5.55 1.92 .60 49.6 1.24
Aaron Harang
34 34 2 0 16
6 .727 0 1 231 2/3 213 100 96
28 52 218 8 1 12 3.73 8.47 2.02 1.09 57.6 1.14
Javier Vazquez
32 32 2 0 15
8 .652 0 0 216 2/3 197 95 90
29 50 213 7 0 5 3.74 8.85 2.08 1.20 54.6 1.14
A.J. Burnett
25 25 2 0 10
8 .556 0 0 165 2/3 131 74 69
23 66 176 12 0 5 3.75 9.56 3.59 1.25 41.4 1.19
Ian Snell
32 32 1 0 9
12 .429 0 0 208 209 94 87
22 68 177 8 0 12 3.76 7.66 2.94 .95 43.7 1.33
Ted Lilly
34 34 0 0 15
8 .652 0 0 207 181 91 88
28 55 174 3 0 7 3.83 7.57 2.39 1.22 47.9 1.14
James Shields
31 31 1 0 12
8 .600 0 0 215 202 98 92
28 36 184 10 0 9 3.85 7.70 1.51 1.17 45.9 1.11
Brian Bannister
27 27 1 0 12
9 .571 0 0 165 156 76 71
15 44 77 6 0 4 3.87 4.20 2.40 .82 31.2 1.21
Curt Schilling
24 24 1 0 9
8 .529 0 1 151 165 68 65
21 23 101 2 0 0 3.87 6.02 1.37 1.25 29.6 1.25
Tom Gorzelanny
32 32 1 0 14
10 .583 0 1 201 2/3 214 90 87
18 68 135 11 1 5 3.88 6.02 3.03 .80 41.3 1.40
Derek Lowe
33 32 3 0 12
14 .462 0 0 199 1/3 194 100 86
20 59 147 1 1 3 3.88 6.64 2.66 .90 40.4 1.27
John Maine
32 32 1 0 15
10 .600 0 1 191 168 90 83
23 75 180 5 0 2 3.91 8.48 3.53 1.08 45.5 1.27
Jered Weaver
28 28 0 0 13
7 .650 0 0 161 178 77 70
17 45 115 2 0 4 3.91 6.43 2.52 .95 35.0 1.39
Rich Hill
32 32 0 0 11
8 .579 0 0 195 170 89 85
27 63 183 12 1 1 3.92 8.45 2.91 1.25 41.8 1.19
Noah Lowry
26 26 1 0 14
8 .636 0 0 156 155 76 68
12 87 87 5 0 5 3.92 5.02 5.02 .69 32.7 1.55
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Felix Hernandez
30 30 1 0 14
7 .667 0 1 190 1/3 209 88 83
20 53 165 3 1 7 3.92 7.80 2.51 .95 42.7 1.38
Joe Blanton
34 34 3 0 14
10 .583 0 1 230 240 106 101
16 40 140 4 1 3 3.95 5.48 1.57 .63 42.0 1.22
Carlos Zambrano
34 34 1 0 18
13 .581 0 0 216 1/3 187 100 95
23 101 177 14 0 3 3.95 7.36 4.20 .96 48.9 1.33
Andy Pettitte
36 34 0 0 15
9 .625 0 0 215 1/3 238 106 97
16 69 141 1 0 3 4.05 5.89 2.88 .67 39.8 1.43
Dustin McGowan
27 27 2 0 12
10 .545 0 1 169 2/3 146 80 77
14 61 144 2 0 13 4.08 7.64 3.24 .74 34.2 1.22
Aaron Cook
25 25 2 0 8
7 .533 0 0 166 178 87 76
15 44 61 6 0 0 4.12 3.31 2.39 .81 21.1 1.34
Shaun Marcum
38 25 0 6 12
6 .667 1 0 159 149 76 73
27 49 122 5 0 1 4.13 6.91 2.77 1.53 30.7 1.25
Greg Maddux
34 34 1 0 14
11 .560 0 0 198 221 92 91
14 25 104 6 0 5 4.14 4.73 1.14 .64 32.4 1.24
Carlos Silva
33 33 2 0 13
14 .481 0 1 202 229 99 94
20 36 89 4 1 4 4.19 3.97 1.60 .89 28.9 1.31
Jeff Francis
34 34 1 0 17
9 .654 0 1 215 1/3 234 103 101
25 63 165 7 1 1 4.22 6.90 2.63 1.04 40.2 1.38
Bronson Arroyo
34 34 1 0 9
15 .375 0 0 210 2/3 232 109 99
28 63 156 13 0 4 4.23 6.66 2.69 1.20 30.9 1.40
Jon Garland
32 32 2 0 10
13 .435 0 1 208 1/3 219 114 98
19 57 98 4 0 1 4.23 4.23 2.46 .82 26.0 1.32
Chuck James
30 30 0 0 11
10 .524 0 0 161 1/3 164 77 76
32 58 116 1 1 1 4.24 6.47 3.24 1.79 27.3 1.38
Doug Davis
33 33 0 0 13
12 .520 0 0 192 2/3 211 100 91
21 95 144 5 1 10 4.25 6.73 4.44 .98 32.7 1.59
Miguel Batista
33 32 0 0 16
11 .593 0 0 193 209 101 92
18 85 133 8 2 15 4.29 6.20 3.96 .84 33.8 1.52
Micah Owings
29 27 2 0 8
8 .500 0 1 152 2/3 146 81 73
20 50 106 14 0 5 4.30 6.25 2.95 1.18 21.9 1.28
Jarrod Washburn
32 32 1 0 10
15 .400 0 1 193 2/3 201 102 93
23 67 114 8 1 2 4.32 5.30 3.11 1.07 25.2 1.38
Jake Westbrook
25 25 0 0 6
9 .400 0 0 152 159 78 73
13 55 93 6 0 3 4.32 5.51 3.26 .77 18.3 1.41
Daisuke Matsuzaka
32 32 1 0 15
12 .556 0 0 204 2/3 191 100 100
25 80 201 13 0 5 4.40 8.84 3.52 1.10 37.4 1.32
Chad Gaudin
34 34 1 0 11
13 .458 0 0 199 1/3 205 108 98
21 100 154 8 1 3 4.42 6.95 4.52 .95 28.1 1.53
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Tom Glavine
34 34 1 0 13
8 .619 0 1 200 1/3 219 102 99
23 64 89 4 0 2 4.45 4.00 2.88 1.03 23.1 1.41
Barry Zito
34 33 0 0 11
13 .458 0 0 196 2/3 182 105 99
24 83 131 4 0 5 4.53 5.99 3.80 1.10 23.4 1.35
Wandy Rodriguez
31 31 1 0 9
13 .409 0 1 182 2/3 179 102 93
22 62 158 5 0 3 4.58 7.78 3.05 1.08 23.1 1.32
Paul Byrd
31 31 2 0 15
8 .652 0 2 192 1/3 239 107 98
27 28 88 6 0 5 4.59 4.12 1.31 1.26 22.0 1.39
Jason Marquis
34 33 1 0 12
9 .571 0 1 191 2/3 190 111 98
22 76 109 13 0 3 4.60 5.12 3.57 1.03 20.7 1.39
Jeff Suppan
34 34 1 0 12
12 .500 0 0 206 2/3 243 113 106
18 68 114 11 0 7 4.62 4.96 2.96 .78 20.7 1.50
Kyle Lohse
34 32 2 0 9
12 .429 0 1 192 2/3 207 109 99
22 57 122 12 0 3 4.62 5.70 2.66 1.03 18.5 1.37
Matt Chico
31 31 0 0 7
9 .438 0 0 167 183 96 86
26 74 94 5 0 7 4.63 5.07 3.99 1.40 13.9 1.54
Nate Robertson
30 30 0 0 9
13 .409 0 0 177 2/3 199 98 94
22 63 119 3 1 5 4.76 6.03 3.19 1.11 15.7 1.47
Tim Wakefield
31 31 0 0 17
12 .586 0 0 189 191 104 100
22 64 110 4 0 10 4.76 5.24 3.05 1.05 22.5 1.35
Matt Morris
32 32 3 0 10
11 .476 0 0 198 2/3 240 123 108
18 61 102 9 0 4 4.89 4.62 2.76 .82 11.5 1.52
Steve Trachsel
29 29 1 0 7
11 .389 0 0 158 176 89 86
19 76 56 2 3 7 4.90 3.19 4.33 1.08 5.6 1.59
Livan Hernandez
33 33 1 0 11
11 .500 0 0 204 1/3 247 116 112
34 79 90 6 2 3 4.93 3.96 3.48 1.50 10.2 1.60
Braden Looper
31 30 0 0 12
12 .500 0 0 175 183 100 96
22 51 87 4 3 0 4.94 4.47 2.62 1.13 12.2 1.34
Josh Fogg
30 29 0 0 10
9 .526 0 0 165 2/3 194 99 91
23 59 94 13 0 3 4.94 5.11 3.21 1.25 11.2 1.53
Jeremy Bonderman
28 28 0 0 11
9 .550 0 0 174 1/3 193 105 97
23 48 145 4 1 12 5.01 7.49 2.48 1.19 15.7 1.38
Jamie Moyer
33 33 1 0 14
12 .538 0 0 199 1/3 222 118 111
30 66 133 5 0 2 5.01 6.01 2.98 1.35 16.0 1.44
Paul Maholm
29 29 2 0 10
15 .400 0 1 177 2/3 204 110 99
22 49 105 6 0 5 5.02 5.32 2.48 1.11 10.3 1.42
Boof Bonser
31 30 0 0 8
12 .400 0 0 173 199 108 98
27 65 136 5 1 3 5.10 7.08 3.38 1.40 10.1 1.53
Chris Capuano
29 25 0 0 5
12 .294 0 0 150 170 93 85
20 54 132 8 0 10 5.10 7.92 3.24 1.20 8.2 1.49
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Dave Bush
33 31 0 2 12
10 .545 0 0 186 1/3 217 110 106
27 44 134 11 0 3 5.12 6.47 2.13 1.30 12.6 1.40
Mike Mussina
28 27 0 0 11
10 .524 0 0 152 188 90 87
14 35 91 4 0 1 5.15 5.39 2.07 .83 9.1 1.47
Kevin Millwood
31 31 0 0 10
14 .417 0 0 172 2/3 213 111 99
19 67 123 8 0 4 5.16 6.41 3.49 .99 9.6 1.62
Dontrelle Willis
35 35 0 0 10
15 .400 0 0 205 1/3 241 131 118
29 87 146 14 1 9 5.17 6.40 3.81 1.27 9.3 1.60
Woody Williams
33 31 0 0 8
15 .348 0 0 188 216 114 110
35 53 101 12 2 1 5.27 4.84 2.54 1.68 2.1 1.43
Matt Belisle
30 30 1 0 8
9 .471 0 0 177 2/3 212 111 105
26 43 125 7 1 6 5.32 6.33 2.18 1.32 4.3 1.44
David Wells
29 29 0 0 9
9 .500 0 0 157 1/3 201 97 95
22 42 82 3 0 1 5.43 4.69 2.40 1.26 0.9 1.54
Daniel Cabrera
34 34 1 0 9
18 .333 0 0 204 1/3 207 133 126
25 108 166 15 2 7 5.55 7.31 4.76 1.10 1.8 1.54
Jose Contreras
32 30 2 2 10
17 .370 0 2 189 232 134 117
21 62 113 15 0 3 5.57 5.38 2.95 1.00 -1.2 1.56
Kip Wells
34 26 0 4 7
17 .292 0 0 162 2/3 186 116 103
19 78 122 9 1 8 5.70 6.75 4.32 1.05 -2.5 1.62
Edwin Jackson
32 31 1 0 5
15 .250 0 1 161 195 116 103
19 88 128 4 1 7 5.76 7.16 4.92 1.06 -4.7 1.76
Ervin Santana
28 26 0 1 7
14 .333 0 0 150 174 103 96
26 58 126 8 0 7 5.76 7.56 3.48 1.56 -1.4 1.55
Scott Olsen
33 33 0 0 10
15 .400 0 0 176 2/3 226 134 114
29 85 133 1 0 8 5.81 6.78 4.33 1.48 -2.4 1.76
Adam Eaton
30 30 0 0 10
10 .500 0 0 161 2/3 192 117 113
30 71 97 11 0 6 6.29 5.40 3.95 1.67 -12.5 1.63
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions .
Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database