Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
R.A. Dickey 93013 1.7500031 1/32888 29213022.306.032.59.5712.81.18
A.J. Burnett 1010105 3.6250071 2/3552019 618721102.399.042.26.7529.01.02
Ramon Ortiz 84043 01.0000034 321110 37242002.656.351.85.7912.41.15
Jarrod Washburn 99003 5.3750060 1/3572218 914387002.695.672.091.3419.01.18
Roy Halladay 26267015 6.71403187 1/31626657 22311339022.746.391.491.0665.01.03
Jeff Niemann 66003 01.0000036 351111 313283012.757.003.25.7512.81.33
Oliver Perez 65004 1.8000035 231111 413283032.837.203.341.0313.31.03
Jeremy Hellickson 75003 1.7500036 2/3291313 517243023.195.894.171.2310.71.25
Dan Haren 1111206 1.8570172 2/3702626 715664003.228.171.86.8722.91.17
David Wells 77003 3.5000046 2/3471817 55264113.285.01.96.9611.91.11
Scott Kazmir 1716007 6.5380097 834336 1046914033.348.444.27.9328.61.33
Felix Hernandez 1212306 5.5450186 853433 935730043.457.643.66.9423.31.40
Jake Arrieta 77003 1.7500044 371917 216382003.487.773.27.4111.81.20
C.J. Wilson 225141 3.2502053 1/3472321 327498013.548.274.56.5111.61.39
Scott Downs 453094 4.5001053 1/3572521 419458013.547.593.21.6814.21.43
Dave Bush 76112 1.6670135 1/3341614 49304013.577.642.291.02 8.71.22
Steve Trachsel 66002 3.4000040 321816 619230013.605.174.281.35 8.31.27
Tim Hudson 66001 2.3330041 301717 413262003.735.712.85.88 7.11.05
Jake Westbrook 88002 5.2860047 2/3462621 820260003.974.913.781.51 7.41.38
Francisco Liriano 87001 4.2000040 1/3422218 221393104.028.704.69.45 7.11.56
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
David Price 1615006 3.6670098 1/3854744 1144763044.036.964.031.0118.81.31
Gil Meche 1212003 3.5000071 1/3673332 824501024.046.313.031.0111.71.28
Pedro Martinez 1212003 4.4290077 2/3703535 923786014.069.042.671.0414.61.20
Jon Garland 99005 3.6250057 2/3612826 822290004.064.533.431.2510.71.44
Brandon Morrow 1610004 2.6670064 553329 628763054.0810.693.94.8414.61.30
Jon Lester 1717108 3.7270199 2/31014646 10381089024.159.753.43.9022.61.39
Justin Verlander 1212004 4.5000069 743832 1031623034.178.094.041.3012.71.52
Erik Bedard 1212004 5.4440066 643431 424614014.238.323.27.5512.11.33
Wade Davis 86002 3.4000033 2/3321816 419281014.287.495.081.07 5.61.51
J.P. Howell 224053 4.4290043 1/3352421 322353024.367.274.57.62 7.21.32
Joel Pineiro 169151 6.1430072 783535 1023483044.386.002.881.25 6.81.40
Johan Santana 1311015 4.5560073 1/3733636 1024641124.427.852.951.2312.11.32
Cliff Lee 1212106 4.6000075 1/3804137 1022572024.426.812.631.1912.41.35
Matt Garza 1211011 4.2000066 1/3693833 1124482114.486.513.261.49 6.01.40
Kevin Millwood 1212003 4.4290074 814037 1434600154.507.304.141.70 9.01.55
Scott Baker 66002 3.4000032 321616 312271004.507.593.38.84 4.71.38
Nick Blackburn 77002 1.6670033 2/3432017 414190004.545.083.741.07 3.71.69
James Shields 2323105 13.27800146 1/31548074 24451184044.557.262.771.4816.01.36
Brian Matusz 99003 5.3750048 2/3532925 819291014.625.363.511.48 5.21.48
Brian Burres 127012 2.5000046 2/3492424 712302034.635.792.311.35 4.31.31
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Victor Zambrano 1311004 5.4440068 563635 955576154.637.547.281.19 8.71.63
Mark Mulder 66103 2.6000042 1/3432222 516312024.686.593.401.06 5.31.39
John Lackey 2222008 8.50000138 1467872 155911513154.707.503.85.9816.51.49
Curt Schilling 1715026 6.50000101 1055453 2320710004.726.331.782.0510.61.24
Jered Weaver 1010005 2.7140056 1/3493430 1324531004.798.473.832.08 8.51.30
Tim Wakefield 3227248 12.40000172 1/314510292 278411010084.805.744.391.4113.21.33
Jose Contreras 98002 6.2500049 2/3543227 513343014.896.162.36.91 3.21.35
Brett Cecil 99004 3.5710052 2/3593029 727353034.965.984.611.20 4.81.63
Ricky Romero 1010103 4.4290061 573734 931544125.027.974.571.33 4.91.44
Daniel Cabrera 1717106 6.5000096 1/3995754 953519035.044.764.95.84 5.31.58
Joaquin Benoit 244041 3.2501040 1/3362523 922440035.139.824.912.01 2.61.44
Jeremy Guthrie 1715024 9.3080094 1/3965554 17306410035.156.112.861.62 3.61.34
Edwin Jackson 1713022 7.2220073 1/3794442 937451045.155.524.541.10 1.21.58
Brian Tallet 294072 1.6670059 623534 832383015.195.804.881.22 1.31.59
Mark Hendrickson 2711144 5.4441182 2/31045348 1124442035.234.792.611.20 1.71.55
John Parrish 271050 2.0000032 2/3352419 419164055.234.415.231.10-1.11.65
Bronson Arroyo 97000 1.0000047 1/3573128 811246005.324.562.091.52-1.91.44
Cory Lidle 55002 1.6670030 1/3331818 78201015.345.932.372.08 1.21.35
Sidney Ponson 1212204 7.3640182 1/3955349 1222423035.364.592.401.31 0.41.42
Josh Beckett 27270014 7.66700166 1/317710499 266115111075.368.173.301.4113.31.43
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Freddy Garcia 77001 3.2500043 2/3422926 611251005.365.152.271.24-0.71.21
Aaron Sele 87011 2.3330033 1/3382120 422131015.403.515.941.08-1.01.80
Miguel Batista 1950112 3.4006043 582626 617181015.443.773.561.26-0.71.74
Casey Fossum 178024 4.5000057 1/3614135 1124394115.496.123.771.73 1.61.48
Jason Johnson 66001 4.2000036 482422 616203025.505.004.001.50-1.01.78
Daisuke Matsuzaka 1010003 3.5000058 2/3543836 635497025.527.525.37.92 1.21.52
Rodrigo Lopez 2420129 8.52900128 2/31508479 28451014145.537.063.151.96 4.41.52
Rich Harden 119012 3.4000052 593232 731535035.549.175.371.21 1.31.73
Dustin McGowan 128012 2.5000048 1/3403030 329405145.597.455.40.56 0.21.43
Doug Waechter 109011 4.2000048 1/3563430 1019230025.594.283.541.86-2.51.55
Gustavo Chacin 108012 6.2500048 1/3533130 724344005.596.334.471.30-0.41.59
Josh Towers 118012 7.2220056 1/3663735 914303005.594.792.241.44-1.81.42
Jeremy Bonderman 1413103 9.2500083 1/3935852 1436552165.625.943.891.51-1.81.55
Nate Robertson 98102 5.2860052 1/3683333 517332025.685.682.92.86-1.51.62
Joe Kennedy 134042 3.4000034 1/3402422 513233105.776.033.411.31-0.51.54
Jesse Litsch 97001 5.1670037 1/3453024 612253025.796.032.891.45-1.81.53
Kris Benson 85012 1.6670031 372220 717143025.814.064.942.03-1.11.74
Scott Schoeneweis 322031 1.5001041 2/3472827 521294025.836.264.541.08-2.31.63
Clay Buchholz 88002 4.3330044 2/3583229 1120241025.844.844.032.22-2.31.75
Ervin Santana 1414005 6.4550082 1/3945954 2235679055.907.323.832.40-1.11.57
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Gavin Floyd 76002 2.5000040 2/3442727 1011341025.987.522.432.21-1.31.35
Paul Byrd 88002 5.2860043 1/3583429 117191006.023.951.452.28-3.41.50
Kelvim Escobar 1210025 3.6251053 1/3633836 727522046.088.784.561.18 0.91.69
Barry Zito 1111002 7.2220060 2/3704741 1534492006.087.275.042.23-3.81.71
Ted Lilly 1313002 7.2220068 724746 1334562116.097.414.501.72-4.41.56
Tom Glavine 66003 2.6000032 1/3462323 515122006.403.344.181.39-2.61.89
Zack Greinke 118002 4.3330044 2/3513432 723271036.455.444.631.41-5.01.66
Brett Anderson 55000 4.0000030 1/3432622 69222006.536.532.671.78-4.61.71
Jason Vargas 76000 3.0000033 382824 69200106.555.452.451.64-5.51.42
Andy Sonnanstine 168062 3.4000056 644741 1513320016.595.142.092.41-7.81.38
Bruce Chen 1714112 6.2500075 1036255 2325521016.606.243.002.76-10.31.71
Shaun Marcum 1210001 5.1670049 593636 1024382016.616.984.411.84-6.71.69
Jamie Moyer 99002 1.6670050 2/3624038 1416320016.755.682.842.49-7.51.54
Jason Hammel 137031 3.2500040 513130 1017273016.756.083.832.25-6.31.70
Gio Gonzalez 66001 5.1670032 302424 322332016.759.286.19.84-3.71.62
Mark Buehrle 1010001 7.1250054 804441 814282006.834.672.331.33-10.21.74
John Danks 66002 3.4000031 2/3412625 916250007.117.114.552.56-4.71.80
Fausto Carmona 118011 5.1670044 613835 922204007.164.094.501.84-10.01.89
Jae Seo 66001 3.2500031 2/3472727 59122007.673.412.561.42-9.01.77
Derek Lowe 1010004 4.5000048 2/3775243 725203017.953.704.621.29-12.72.10
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Derek Holland 76000 5.0000034 483635 1021201019.265.295.562.65-16.02.03
Carlos Silva 76001 4.2000031 583732 85140039.294.061.452.32-14.12.03
Bartolo Colon 88002 4.3330038 2/3614741 1615310009.547.223.493.72-16.61.97

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database