Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons
Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
You may also specify just home or just road games.
Default dates are first and last games in the database.
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
R.A. Dickey
9 3 0 1 3
1 .750 0 0 31 1/3 28 8 8
2 9 21 3 0 2 2.30 6.03 2.59 .57 12.8 1.18
A.J. Burnett
10 10 1 0 5
3 .625 0 0 71 2/3 55 20 19
6 18 72 1 1 0 2.39 9.04 2.26 .75 29.0 1.02
Ramon Ortiz
8 4 0 4 3
0 1.000 0 0 34 32 11 10
3 7 24 2 0 0 2.65 6.35 1.85 .79 12.4 1.15
Jarrod Washburn
9 9 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 60 1/3 57 22 18
9 14 38 7 0 0 2.69 5.67 2.09 1.34 19.0 1.18
Roy Halladay
26 26 7 0 15
6 .714 0 3 187 1/3 162 66 57
22 31 133 9 0 2 2.74 6.39 1.49 1.06 65.0 1.03
Jeff Niemann
6 6 0 0 3
0 1.000 0 0 36 35 11 11
3 13 28 3 0 1 2.75 7.00 3.25 .75 12.8 1.33
Oliver Perez
6 5 0 0 4
1 .800 0 0 35 23 11 11
4 13 28 3 0 3 2.83 7.20 3.34 1.03 13.3 1.03
Jeremy Hellickson
7 5 0 0 3
1 .750 0 0 36 2/3 29 13 13
5 17 24 3 0 2 3.19 5.89 4.17 1.23 10.7 1.25
Dan Haren
11 11 2 0 6
1 .857 0 1 72 2/3 70 26 26
7 15 66 4 0 0 3.22 8.17 1.86 .87 22.9 1.17
David Wells
7 7 0 0 3
3 .500 0 0 46 2/3 47 18 17
5 5 26 4 1 1 3.28 5.01 .96 .96 11.9 1.11
Scott Kazmir
17 16 0 0 7
6 .538 0 0 97 83 43 36
10 46 91 4 0 3 3.34 8.44 4.27 .93 28.6 1.33
Felix Hernandez
12 12 3 0 6
5 .545 0 1 86 85 34 33
9 35 73 0 0 4 3.45 7.64 3.66 .94 23.3 1.40
Jake Arrieta
7 7 0 0 3
1 .750 0 0 44 37 19 17
2 16 38 2 0 0 3.48 7.77 3.27 .41 11.8 1.20
C.J. Wilson
22 5 1 4 1
3 .250 2 0 53 1/3 47 23 21
3 27 49 8 0 1 3.54 8.27 4.56 .51 11.6 1.39
Scott Downs
45 3 0 9 4
4 .500 1 0 53 1/3 57 25 21
4 19 45 8 0 1 3.54 7.59 3.21 .68 14.2 1.43
Dave Bush
7 6 1 1 2
1 .667 0 1 35 1/3 34 16 14
4 9 30 4 0 1 3.57 7.64 2.29 1.02 8.7 1.22
Steve Trachsel
6 6 0 0 2
3 .400 0 0 40 32 18 16
6 19 23 0 0 1 3.60 5.17 4.28 1.35 8.3 1.27
Tim Hudson
6 6 0 0 1
2 .333 0 0 41 30 17 17
4 13 26 2 0 0 3.73 5.71 2.85 .88 7.1 1.05
Jake Westbrook
8 8 0 0 2
5 .286 0 0 47 2/3 46 26 21
8 20 26 0 0 0 3.97 4.91 3.78 1.51 7.4 1.38
Francisco Liriano
8 7 0 0 1
4 .200 0 0 40 1/3 42 22 18
2 21 39 3 1 0 4.02 8.70 4.69 .45 7.1 1.56
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
David Price
16 15 0 0 6
3 .667 0 0 98 1/3 85 47 44
11 44 76 3 0 4 4.03 6.96 4.03 1.01 18.8 1.31
Gil Meche
12 12 0 0 3
3 .500 0 0 71 1/3 67 33 32
8 24 50 1 0 2 4.04 6.31 3.03 1.01 11.7 1.28
Pedro Martinez
12 12 0 0 3
4 .429 0 0 77 2/3 70 35 35
9 23 78 6 0 1 4.06 9.04 2.67 1.04 14.6 1.20
Jon Garland
9 9 0 0 5
3 .625 0 0 57 2/3 61 28 26
8 22 29 0 0 0 4.06 4.53 3.43 1.25 10.7 1.44
Brandon Morrow
16 10 0 0 4
2 .667 0 0 64 55 33 29
6 28 76 3 0 5 4.08 10.69 3.94 .84 14.6 1.30
Jon Lester
17 17 1 0 8
3 .727 0 1 99 2/3 101 46 46
10 38 108 9 0 2 4.15 9.75 3.43 .90 22.6 1.39
Justin Verlander
12 12 0 0 4
4 .500 0 0 69 74 38 32
10 31 62 3 0 3 4.17 8.09 4.04 1.30 12.7 1.52
Erik Bedard
12 12 0 0 4
5 .444 0 0 66 64 34 31
4 24 61 4 0 1 4.23 8.32 3.27 .55 12.1 1.33
Wade Davis
8 6 0 0 2
3 .400 0 0 33 2/3 32 18 16
4 19 28 1 0 1 4.28 7.49 5.08 1.07 5.6 1.51
J.P. Howell
22 4 0 5 3
4 .429 0 0 43 1/3 35 24 21
3 22 35 3 0 2 4.36 7.27 4.57 .62 7.2 1.32
Joel Pineiro
16 9 1 5 1
6 .143 0 0 72 78 35 35
10 23 48 3 0 4 4.38 6.00 2.88 1.25 6.8 1.40
Johan Santana
13 11 0 1 5
4 .556 0 0 73 1/3 73 36 36
10 24 64 1 1 2 4.42 7.85 2.95 1.23 12.1 1.32
Cliff Lee
12 12 1 0 6
4 .600 0 0 75 1/3 80 41 37
10 22 57 2 0 2 4.42 6.81 2.63 1.19 12.4 1.35
Matt Garza
12 11 0 1 1
4 .200 0 0 66 1/3 69 38 33
11 24 48 2 1 1 4.48 6.51 3.26 1.49 6.0 1.40
Kevin Millwood
12 12 0 0 3
4 .429 0 0 74 81 40 37
14 34 60 0 1 5 4.50 7.30 4.14 1.70 9.0 1.55
Scott Baker
6 6 0 0 2
3 .400 0 0 32 32 16 16
3 12 27 1 0 0 4.50 7.59 3.38 .84 4.7 1.38
Nick Blackburn
7 7 0 0 2
1 .667 0 0 33 2/3 43 20 17
4 14 19 0 0 0 4.54 5.08 3.74 1.07 3.7 1.69
James Shields
23 23 1 0 5
13 .278 0 0 146 1/3 154 80 74
24 45 118 4 0 4 4.55 7.26 2.77 1.48 16.0 1.36
Brian Matusz
9 9 0 0 3
5 .375 0 0 48 2/3 53 29 25
8 19 29 1 0 1 4.62 5.36 3.51 1.48 5.2 1.48
Brian Burres
12 7 0 1 2
2 .500 0 0 46 2/3 49 24 24
7 12 30 2 0 3 4.63 5.79 2.31 1.35 4.3 1.31
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Victor Zambrano
13 11 0 0 4
5 .444 0 0 68 56 36 35
9 55 57 6 1 5 4.63 7.54 7.28 1.19 8.7 1.63
Mark Mulder
6 6 1 0 3
2 .600 0 0 42 1/3 43 22 22
5 16 31 2 0 2 4.68 6.59 3.40 1.06 5.3 1.39
John Lackey
22 22 0 0 8
8 .500 0 0 138 146 78 72
15 59 115 13 1 5 4.70 7.50 3.85 .98 16.5 1.49
Curt Schilling
17 15 0 2 6
6 .500 0 0 101 105 54 53
23 20 71 0 0 0 4.72 6.33 1.78 2.05 10.6 1.24
Jered Weaver
10 10 0 0 5
2 .714 0 0 56 1/3 49 34 30
13 24 53 1 0 0 4.79 8.47 3.83 2.08 8.5 1.30
Tim Wakefield
32 27 2 4 8
12 .400 0 0 172 1/3 145 102 92
27 84 110 10 0 8 4.80 5.74 4.39 1.41 13.2 1.33
Jose Contreras
9 8 0 0 2
6 .250 0 0 49 2/3 54 32 27
5 13 34 3 0 1 4.89 6.16 2.36 .91 3.2 1.35
Brett Cecil
9 9 0 0 4
3 .571 0 0 52 2/3 59 30 29
7 27 35 3 0 3 4.96 5.98 4.61 1.20 4.8 1.63
Ricky Romero
10 10 1 0 3
4 .429 0 0 61 57 37 34
9 31 54 4 1 2 5.02 7.97 4.57 1.33 4.9 1.44
Daniel Cabrera
17 17 1 0 6
6 .500 0 0 96 1/3 99 57 54
9 53 51 9 0 3 5.04 4.76 4.95 .84 5.3 1.58
Joaquin Benoit
24 4 0 4 1
3 .250 1 0 40 1/3 36 25 23
9 22 44 0 0 3 5.13 9.82 4.91 2.01 2.6 1.44
Jeremy Guthrie
17 15 0 2 4
9 .308 0 0 94 1/3 96 55 54
17 30 64 10 0 3 5.15 6.11 2.86 1.62 3.6 1.34
Edwin Jackson
17 13 0 2 2
7 .222 0 0 73 1/3 79 44 42
9 37 45 1 0 4 5.15 5.52 4.54 1.10 1.2 1.58
Brian Tallet
29 4 0 7 2
1 .667 0 0 59 62 35 34
8 32 38 3 0 1 5.19 5.80 4.88 1.22 1.3 1.59
Mark Hendrickson
27 11 1 4 4
5 .444 1 1 82 2/3 104 53 48
11 24 44 2 0 3 5.23 4.79 2.61 1.20 1.7 1.55
John Parrish
27 1 0 5 0
2 .000 0 0 32 2/3 35 24 19
4 19 16 4 0 5 5.23 4.41 5.23 1.10 -1.1 1.65
Bronson Arroyo
9 7 0 0 0
1 .000 0 0 47 1/3 57 31 28
8 11 24 6 0 0 5.32 4.56 2.09 1.52 -1.9 1.44
Cory Lidle
5 5 0 0 2
1 .667 0 0 30 1/3 33 18 18
7 8 20 1 0 1 5.34 5.93 2.37 2.08 1.2 1.35
Sidney Ponson
12 12 2 0 4
7 .364 0 1 82 1/3 95 53 49
12 22 42 3 0 3 5.36 4.59 2.40 1.31 0.4 1.42
Josh Beckett
27 27 0 0 14
7 .667 0 0 166 1/3 177 104 99
26 61 151 11 0 7 5.36 8.17 3.30 1.41 13.3 1.43
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Freddy Garcia
7 7 0 0 1
3 .250 0 0 43 2/3 42 29 26
6 11 25 1 0 0 5.36 5.15 2.27 1.24 -0.7 1.21
Aaron Sele
8 7 0 1 1
2 .333 0 0 33 1/3 38 21 20
4 22 13 1 0 1 5.40 3.51 5.94 1.08 -1.0 1.80
Miguel Batista
19 5 0 11 2
3 .400 6 0 43 58 26 26
6 17 18 1 0 1 5.44 3.77 3.56 1.26 -0.7 1.74
Casey Fossum
17 8 0 2 4
4 .500 0 0 57 1/3 61 41 35
11 24 39 4 1 1 5.49 6.12 3.77 1.73 1.6 1.48
Jason Johnson
6 6 0 0 1
4 .200 0 0 36 48 24 22
6 16 20 3 0 2 5.50 5.00 4.00 1.50 -1.0 1.78
Daisuke Matsuzaka
10 10 0 0 3
3 .500 0 0 58 2/3 54 38 36
6 35 49 7 0 2 5.52 7.52 5.37 .92 1.2 1.52
Rodrigo Lopez
24 20 1 2 9
8 .529 0 0 128 2/3 150 84 79
28 45 101 4 1 4 5.53 7.06 3.15 1.96 4.4 1.52
Rich Harden
11 9 0 1 2
3 .400 0 0 52 59 32 32
7 31 53 5 0 3 5.54 9.17 5.37 1.21 1.3 1.73
Dustin McGowan
12 8 0 1 2
2 .500 0 0 48 1/3 40 30 30
3 29 40 5 1 4 5.59 7.45 5.40 .56 0.2 1.43
Doug Waechter
10 9 0 1 1
4 .200 0 0 48 1/3 56 34 30
10 19 23 0 0 2 5.59 4.28 3.54 1.86 -2.5 1.55
Gustavo Chacin
10 8 0 1 2
6 .250 0 0 48 1/3 53 31 30
7 24 34 4 0 0 5.59 6.33 4.47 1.30 -0.4 1.59
Josh Towers
11 8 0 1 2
7 .222 0 0 56 1/3 66 37 35
9 14 30 3 0 0 5.59 4.79 2.24 1.44 -1.8 1.42
Jeremy Bonderman
14 13 1 0 3
9 .250 0 0 83 1/3 93 58 52
14 36 55 2 1 6 5.62 5.94 3.89 1.51 -1.8 1.55
Nate Robertson
9 8 1 0 2
5 .286 0 0 52 1/3 68 33 33
5 17 33 2 0 2 5.68 5.68 2.92 .86 -1.5 1.62
Joe Kennedy
13 4 0 4 2
3 .400 0 0 34 1/3 40 24 22
5 13 23 3 1 0 5.77 6.03 3.41 1.31 -0.5 1.54
Jesse Litsch
9 7 0 0 1
5 .167 0 0 37 1/3 45 30 24
6 12 25 3 0 2 5.79 6.03 2.89 1.45 -1.8 1.53
Kris Benson
8 5 0 1 2
1 .667 0 0 31 37 22 20
7 17 14 3 0 2 5.81 4.06 4.94 2.03 -1.1 1.74
Scott Schoeneweis
32 2 0 3 1
1 .500 1 0 41 2/3 47 28 27
5 21 29 4 0 2 5.83 6.26 4.54 1.08 -2.3 1.63
Clay Buchholz
8 8 0 0 2
4 .333 0 0 44 2/3 58 32 29
11 20 24 1 0 2 5.84 4.84 4.03 2.22 -2.3 1.75
Ervin Santana
14 14 0 0 5
6 .455 0 0 82 1/3 94 59 54
22 35 67 9 0 5 5.90 7.32 3.83 2.40 -1.1 1.57
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Gavin Floyd
7 6 0 0 2
2 .500 0 0 40 2/3 44 27 27
10 11 34 1 0 2 5.98 7.52 2.43 2.21 -1.3 1.35
Paul Byrd
8 8 0 0 2
5 .286 0 0 43 1/3 58 34 29
11 7 19 1 0 0 6.02 3.95 1.45 2.28 -3.4 1.50
Kelvim Escobar
12 10 0 2 5
3 .625 1 0 53 1/3 63 38 36
7 27 52 2 0 4 6.08 8.78 4.56 1.18 0.9 1.69
Barry Zito
11 11 0 0 2
7 .222 0 0 60 2/3 70 47 41
15 34 49 2 0 0 6.08 7.27 5.04 2.23 -3.8 1.71
Ted Lilly
13 13 0 0 2
7 .222 0 0 68 72 47 46
13 34 56 2 1 1 6.09 7.41 4.50 1.72 -4.4 1.56
Tom Glavine
6 6 0 0 3
2 .600 0 0 32 1/3 46 23 23
5 15 12 2 0 0 6.40 3.34 4.18 1.39 -2.6 1.89
Zack Greinke
11 8 0 0 2
4 .333 0 0 44 2/3 51 34 32
7 23 27 1 0 3 6.45 5.44 4.63 1.41 -5.0 1.66
Brett Anderson
5 5 0 0 0
4 .000 0 0 30 1/3 43 26 22
6 9 22 2 0 0 6.53 6.53 2.67 1.78 -4.6 1.71
Jason Vargas
7 6 0 0 0
3 .000 0 0 33 38 28 24
6 9 20 0 1 0 6.55 5.45 2.45 1.64 -5.5 1.42
Andy Sonnanstine
16 8 0 6 2
3 .400 0 0 56 64 47 41
15 13 32 0 0 1 6.59 5.14 2.09 2.41 -7.8 1.38
Bruce Chen
17 14 1 1 2
6 .250 0 0 75 103 62 55
23 25 52 1 0 1 6.60 6.24 3.00 2.76 -10.3 1.71
Shaun Marcum
12 10 0 0 1
5 .167 0 0 49 59 36 36
10 24 38 2 0 1 6.61 6.98 4.41 1.84 -6.7 1.69
Jamie Moyer
9 9 0 0 2
1 .667 0 0 50 2/3 62 40 38
14 16 32 0 0 1 6.75 5.68 2.84 2.49 -7.5 1.54
Jason Hammel
13 7 0 3 1
3 .250 0 0 40 51 31 30
10 17 27 3 0 1 6.75 6.08 3.83 2.25 -6.3 1.70
Gio Gonzalez
6 6 0 0 1
5 .167 0 0 32 30 24 24
3 22 33 2 0 1 6.75 9.28 6.19 .84 -3.7 1.62
Mark Buehrle
10 10 0 0 1
7 .125 0 0 54 80 44 41
8 14 28 2 0 0 6.83 4.67 2.33 1.33 -10.2 1.74
John Danks
6 6 0 0 2
3 .400 0 0 31 2/3 41 26 25
9 16 25 0 0 0 7.11 7.11 4.55 2.56 -4.7 1.80
Fausto Carmona
11 8 0 1 1
5 .167 0 0 44 61 38 35
9 22 20 4 0 0 7.16 4.09 4.50 1.84 -10.0 1.89
Jae Seo
6 6 0 0 1
3 .250 0 0 31 2/3 47 27 27
5 9 12 2 0 0 7.67 3.41 2.56 1.42 -9.0 1.77
Derek Lowe
10 10 0 0 4
4 .500 0 0 48 2/3 77 52 43
7 25 20 3 0 1 7.95 3.70 4.62 1.29 -12.7 2.10
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Derek Holland
7 6 0 0 0
5 .000 0 0 34 48 36 35
10 21 20 1 0 1 9.26 5.29 5.56 2.65 -16.0 2.03
Carlos Silva
7 6 0 0 1
4 .200 0 0 31 58 37 32
8 5 14 0 0 3 9.29 4.06 1.45 2.32 -14.1 2.03
Bartolo Colon
8 8 0 0 2
4 .333 0 0 38 2/3 61 47 41
16 15 31 0 0 0 9.54 7.22 3.49 3.72 -16.6 1.97
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions .
Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database