Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Johan Santana 99994048 26.64902670 565239217 80157667124202.918.962.111.07232.71.08
CC Sabathia 959519046 28.62208670 2/3635260230 5613761422263.098.241.84.75212.71.15
Brandon Webb 999912055 25.68807684 617271237 40183542212163.127.132.41.53214.21.17
Jake Peavy 92923039 31.55700594 1/3498214207 53185618170133.139.362.80.80191.01.15
Roy Halladay 969519051 23.68903682 1/3654269245 52120472200113.236.231.58.69194.41.13
Roy Oswalt 97956145 25.64302635 1/3638244229 5414248223233.246.832.01.76181.91.23
John Smoltz 73723033 19.63501465 2/3442179169 43110444130153.278.582.13.83141.21.19
John Lackey 89898044 24.64704602 1/3571246219 56162498301293.277.442.42.84176.01.22
Chad Billingsley 94672734 19.64201429 2/3400174161 36200394140203.378.254.19.75127.21.40
Scott Kazmir 84841035 24.59301498 2/3445207187 52209560130213.3810.113.77.94153.31.31
Adam Wainwright 1125121026 16.61930403 391168154 31121297150113.446.632.70.69103.21.27
Cole Hamels 83834038 22.63302536 465224205 7114351170103.448.582.401.19152.11.13
Ben Sheets 71717031 20.60803443 1/3419179170 429337940143.457.691.89.85120.61.15
Chris Young 78781026 19.57800448 2/3331183173 51189419146153.478.403.791.02119.21.16
Dan Haren 1001003045 30.60001654 2/3634282254 74139565190303.497.771.911.02174.81.18
Erik Bedard 76761034 20.63001459 1/3407196179 44163464140123.519.093.19.86131.11.24
Derek Lowe 101995142 33.56000625 1/3607281250 481594157383.605.972.29.69146.21.22
Jered Weaver 76760035 19.64800455 436195184 5213236411093.647.202.611.03114.91.25
Carlos Zambrano 96962048 26.64901614 1/3518271253 60284515291163.717.544.16.88153.71.31
Chien-Ming Wang 79784146 15.75411512 1/3522220213 25146234132153.744.112.56.44112.61.30
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Matt Cain 97963128 41.40602601 1/3528270258 50253522184283.867.813.79.75122.91.30
Tim Hudson 92914040 29.58003584 2/3581269251 46172358193153.865.512.65.71117.11.29
Cliff Lee 83796141 21.66102514 1/3541250224 57125357200123.926.252.191.00109.91.29
John Maine 73722131 23.57402421 359200184 54175373110153.937.973.741.1594.81.27
Felix Hernandez 91915035 32.52202576 589273252 60190512172263.948.002.97.94122.21.35
James Shields 83835031 24.56402546 2/3543259242 69113440270233.987.241.861.14106.31.20
A.J. Burnett 80795138 26.59401514 2/3473248228 56189514293223.998.993.31.98118.71.29
Mike Mussina 92911044 26.62900538 2/3579263239 539940417083.996.751.65.89114.71.26
Aaron Harang 98969037 33.52904638 1/3643303284 87155579182204.008.162.191.23130.11.25
Bronson Arroyo 1021025038 37.50701644 1/3660317287 87193498240164.016.962.701.22123.01.32
Justin Verlander 94943045 32.58402583 2/3558283263 59211462396284.067.123.25.91120.01.32
Gil Meche 98982032 32.50000601 594298271 65214484112124.067.253.20.97109.91.34
Ted Lilly 99990046 30.60500587 1/3545284267 88199514148184.097.883.051.35124.11.27
Josh Beckett 89892048 27.64000573 2/3546272261 71147518211184.098.132.311.11125.61.21
Aaron Cook 89894033 31.51601590 656296269 4514724917084.103.802.24.6983.91.36
Fausto Carmona 916031228 25.52802409 1/3408200187 32161252263164.115.543.54.7070.91.39
Brad Penny 86830138 22.63300491 2/3517237227 41169334171134.166.113.09.7590.21.40
Mark Buehrle 94945036 33.52201609 2/3678312282 7914034416144.165.082.071.1793.21.34
Brett Myers 1116333727 26.509211452 1/3442223211 67153432100104.208.603.041.3385.41.32
Greg Maddux 1001001036 38.48600596 642305279 549231712274.214.791.39.8286.71.23
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Andy Pettitte 1051022143 36.54401633 2/3709332300 62194477102114.266.772.76.88107.51.43
Javier Vazquez 96954038 34.52800619 1/3605312295 75164589280144.298.562.381.09111.61.24
Tom Glavine 79791030 19.61201461 2/3488236222 5616325711034.335.013.181.0964.51.41
Ervin Santana 91892138 28.57601559 1/3538289269 68174467263224.337.512.801.0995.41.27
Braden Looper 1326212833 29.53201440 1/3468227213 4911523017434.354.702.351.0063.21.32
Jamie Moyer 98983040 33.54801601 643312292 8317836321184.375.442.671.2484.81.37
Jeff Francis 90902034 30.53102558 585288273 6418137623114.406.062.921.0377.61.37
Randy Johnson 71713031 23.57400430 2/3421237213 5811440719354.458.512.381.2174.01.24
Paul Maholm 89893027 33.45001554 605293274 62187359272104.455.833.041.0165.91.43
Jeremy Bonderman 74740028 21.57100459 2/3482248228 50148391102164.467.662.90.9868.91.37
Oliver Perez 83831028 30.48301474 439273236 65244444242204.488.434.631.2373.41.44
Joe Blanton 98974038 34.52802616 687323307 5416335613184.495.202.38.7974.61.38
Barry Zito 99980037 39.48700589 2/3573316294 66280396212124.496.044.271.0177.41.45
Doug Davis 92921030 31.49201538 570291269 53256412141204.506.894.28.8971.21.54
Jon Garland 96954042 28.60002611 1/3692337306 6815629818084.504.392.301.0071.51.39
Tim Wakefield 82822033 34.49300499 472269251 66174308240284.535.563.141.1962.31.29
Jarrod Washburn 91892123 43.34811534 1/3573292270 6717230422174.555.122.901.1350.61.39
Dave Bush 96913233 31.51602573 1/3576310292 82126406391114.586.371.981.2968.31.22
Jeff Suppan 96961034 29.54000569 1/3649322290 68203303231184.584.793.211.0759.01.50
Kyle Lohse 100832628 28.50001513 1/3561277262 53149335211114.595.872.61.9356.21.38
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Ian Snell 94941029 35.45300553 1/3607304283 68230476121284.607.743.741.1170.31.51
Kenny Rogers 75740129 25.53700440 2/3472251228 53158217191104.664.433.231.0843.01.43
Paul Byrd 91914036 29.55402546 1/3664319283 849925419074.664.181.631.3851.61.40
Scott Olsen 95950030 35.46200548 570328284 80227406100214.666.673.731.3160.61.45
Wandy Rodriguez 84781126 29.47301443 2/3458260230 53167374162114.677.593.391.0855.21.41
Dontrelle Willis 76754022 29.43101447 1/3489259236 53202319333204.756.424.061.0741.61.54
Jose Contreras 82804230 32.48403506 556299271 53152317280254.825.642.70.9443.71.40
Nate Robertson 93891129 36.44600550 1/3616312295 77188361131164.825.903.071.2645.31.46
Miguel Batista 111853931 33.48411514 1/3575306277 55248316203344.855.534.34.9642.81.60
Zach Duke 84833018 37.32702500 2/3639300271 50140243174104.874.372.52.9021.61.56
Kevin Millwood 92925035 35.50000543 1/3644321296 59167393181124.906.512.77.9850.01.49
Mark Hendrickson 105591717 31.35401420 462249229 49138272101144.915.832.961.0525.21.43
Vicente Padilla 84841034 28.54801485 1/3533295266 63183346415184.936.423.391.1745.31.48
Jason Marquis 94931036 34.51401546 573328306 71216292362125.044.813.561.1732.21.45
Matt Morris 70705020 30.40000428 2/3499277247 4613122825375.194.792.75.9710.11.47
Livan Hernandez 97973036 35.50700593 1/3738365344 8719828212375.224.283.001.3216.91.58
Daniel Cabrera 90905026 38.40601532 1/3536324309 60302418385395.227.075.111.0125.01.57
Odalis Perez 87750621 30.41200419 2/3521266246 54135259154135.285.552.901.1610.71.56
Carlos Silva 97923228 44.38901535 2/3688343323 7810022815165.433.831.681.31-4.41.47
Joel Pineiro 1076012221 25.45720405 496258246 5812322114185.474.912.731.29-0.41.53
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Josh Fogg 83741323 25.47901416 497283262 6414623225075.675.023.161.38-7.81.55

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database