Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons
Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
You may also specify just home or just road games.
Default dates are first and last games in the database.
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Johan Santana
99 99 4 0 48
26 .649 0 2 670 565 239 217
80 157 667 12 4 20 2.91 8.96 2.11 1.07 232.7 1.08
CC Sabathia
95 95 19 0 46
28 .622 0 8 670 2/3 635 260 230
56 137 614 22 2 6 3.09 8.24 1.84 .75 212.7 1.15
Brandon Webb
99 99 12 0 55
25 .688 0 7 684 617 271 237
40 183 542 21 2 16 3.12 7.13 2.41 .53 214.2 1.17
Jake Peavy
92 92 3 0 39
31 .557 0 0 594 1/3 498 214 207
53 185 618 17 0 13 3.13 9.36 2.80 .80 191.0 1.15
Roy Halladay
96 95 19 0 51
23 .689 0 3 682 1/3 654 269 245
52 120 472 20 0 11 3.23 6.23 1.58 .69 194.4 1.13
Roy Oswalt
97 95 6 1 45
25 .643 0 2 635 1/3 638 244 229
54 142 482 23 2 3 3.24 6.83 2.01 .76 181.9 1.23
John Smoltz
73 72 3 0 33
19 .635 0 1 465 2/3 442 179 169
43 110 444 13 0 15 3.27 8.58 2.13 .83 141.2 1.19
John Lackey
89 89 8 0 44
24 .647 0 4 602 1/3 571 246 219
56 162 498 30 1 29 3.27 7.44 2.42 .84 176.0 1.22
Chad Billingsley
94 67 2 7 34
19 .642 0 1 429 2/3 400 174 161
36 200 394 14 0 20 3.37 8.25 4.19 .75 127.2 1.40
Scott Kazmir
84 84 1 0 35
24 .593 0 1 498 2/3 445 207 187
52 209 560 13 0 21 3.38 10.11 3.77 .94 153.3 1.31
Adam Wainwright
112 51 2 10 26
16 .619 3 0 403 391 168 154
31 121 297 15 0 11 3.44 6.63 2.70 .69 103.2 1.27
Cole Hamels
83 83 4 0 38
22 .633 0 2 536 465 224 205
71 143 511 7 0 10 3.44 8.58 2.40 1.19 152.1 1.13
Ben Sheets
71 71 7 0 31
20 .608 0 3 443 1/3 419 179 170
42 93 379 4 0 14 3.45 7.69 1.89 .85 120.6 1.15
Chris Young
78 78 1 0 26
19 .578 0 0 448 2/3 331 183 173
51 189 419 14 6 15 3.47 8.40 3.79 1.02 119.2 1.16
Dan Haren
100 100 3 0 45
30 .600 0 1 654 2/3 634 282 254
74 139 565 19 0 30 3.49 7.77 1.91 1.02 174.8 1.18
Erik Bedard
76 76 1 0 34
20 .630 0 1 459 1/3 407 196 179
44 163 464 14 0 12 3.51 9.09 3.19 .86 131.1 1.24
Derek Lowe
101 99 5 1 42
33 .560 0 0 625 1/3 607 281 250
48 159 415 7 3 8 3.60 5.97 2.29 .69 146.2 1.22
Jered Weaver
76 76 0 0 35
19 .648 0 0 455 436 195 184
52 132 364 11 0 9 3.64 7.20 2.61 1.03 114.9 1.25
Carlos Zambrano
96 96 2 0 48
26 .649 0 1 614 1/3 518 271 253
60 284 515 29 1 16 3.71 7.54 4.16 .88 153.7 1.31
Chien-Ming Wang
79 78 4 1 46
15 .754 1 1 512 1/3 522 220 213
25 146 234 13 2 15 3.74 4.11 2.56 .44 112.6 1.30
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Matt Cain
97 96 3 1 28
41 .406 0 2 601 1/3 528 270 258
50 253 522 18 4 28 3.86 7.81 3.79 .75 122.9 1.30
Tim Hudson
92 91 4 0 40
29 .580 0 3 584 2/3 581 269 251
46 172 358 19 3 15 3.86 5.51 2.65 .71 117.1 1.29
Cliff Lee
83 79 6 1 41
21 .661 0 2 514 1/3 541 250 224
57 125 357 20 0 12 3.92 6.25 2.19 1.00 109.9 1.29
John Maine
73 72 2 1 31
23 .574 0 2 421 359 200 184
54 175 373 11 0 15 3.93 7.97 3.74 1.15 94.8 1.27
Felix Hernandez
91 91 5 0 35
32 .522 0 2 576 589 273 252
60 190 512 17 2 26 3.94 8.00 2.97 .94 122.2 1.35
James Shields
83 83 5 0 31
24 .564 0 2 546 2/3 543 259 242
69 113 440 27 0 23 3.98 7.24 1.86 1.14 106.3 1.20
A.J. Burnett
80 79 5 1 38
26 .594 0 1 514 2/3 473 248 228
56 189 514 29 3 22 3.99 8.99 3.31 .98 118.7 1.29
Mike Mussina
92 91 1 0 44
26 .629 0 0 538 2/3 579 263 239
53 99 404 17 0 8 3.99 6.75 1.65 .89 114.7 1.26
Aaron Harang
98 96 9 0 37
33 .529 0 4 638 1/3 643 303 284
87 155 579 18 2 20 4.00 8.16 2.19 1.23 130.1 1.25
Bronson Arroyo
102 102 5 0 38
37 .507 0 1 644 1/3 660 317 287
87 193 498 24 0 16 4.01 6.96 2.70 1.22 123.0 1.32
Justin Verlander
94 94 3 0 45
32 .584 0 2 583 2/3 558 283 263
59 211 462 39 6 28 4.06 7.12 3.25 .91 120.0 1.32
Gil Meche
98 98 2 0 32
32 .500 0 0 601 594 298 271
65 214 484 11 2 12 4.06 7.25 3.20 .97 109.9 1.34
Ted Lilly
99 99 0 0 46
30 .605 0 0 587 1/3 545 284 267
88 199 514 14 8 18 4.09 7.88 3.05 1.35 124.1 1.27
Josh Beckett
89 89 2 0 48
27 .640 0 0 573 2/3 546 272 261
71 147 518 21 1 18 4.09 8.13 2.31 1.11 125.6 1.21
Aaron Cook
89 89 4 0 33
31 .516 0 1 590 656 296 269
45 147 249 17 0 8 4.10 3.80 2.24 .69 83.9 1.36
Fausto Carmona
91 60 3 12 28
25 .528 0 2 409 1/3 408 200 187
32 161 252 26 3 16 4.11 5.54 3.54 .70 70.9 1.39
Brad Penny
86 83 0 1 38
22 .633 0 0 491 2/3 517 237 227
41 169 334 17 1 13 4.16 6.11 3.09 .75 90.2 1.40
Mark Buehrle
94 94 5 0 36
33 .522 0 1 609 2/3 678 312 282
79 140 344 16 1 4 4.16 5.08 2.07 1.17 93.2 1.34
Brett Myers
111 63 3 37 27
26 .509 21 1 452 1/3 442 223 211
67 153 432 10 0 10 4.20 8.60 3.04 1.33 85.4 1.32
Greg Maddux
100 100 1 0 36
38 .486 0 0 596 642 305 279
54 92 317 12 2 7 4.21 4.79 1.39 .82 86.7 1.23
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Andy Pettitte
105 102 2 1 43
36 .544 0 1 633 2/3 709 332 300
62 194 477 10 2 11 4.26 6.77 2.76 .88 107.5 1.43
Javier Vazquez
96 95 4 0 38
34 .528 0 0 619 1/3 605 312 295
75 164 589 28 0 14 4.29 8.56 2.38 1.09 111.6 1.24
Tom Glavine
79 79 1 0 30
19 .612 0 1 461 2/3 488 236 222
56 163 257 11 0 3 4.33 5.01 3.18 1.09 64.5 1.41
Ervin Santana
91 89 2 1 38
28 .576 0 1 559 1/3 538 289 269
68 174 467 26 3 22 4.33 7.51 2.80 1.09 95.4 1.27
Braden Looper
132 62 1 28 33
29 .532 0 1 440 1/3 468 227 213
49 115 230 17 4 3 4.35 4.70 2.35 1.00 63.2 1.32
Jamie Moyer
98 98 3 0 40
33 .548 0 1 601 643 312 292
83 178 363 21 1 8 4.37 5.44 2.67 1.24 84.8 1.37
Jeff Francis
90 90 2 0 34
30 .531 0 2 558 585 288 273
64 181 376 23 1 1 4.40 6.06 2.92 1.03 77.6 1.37
Randy Johnson
71 71 3 0 31
23 .574 0 0 430 2/3 421 237 213
58 114 407 19 3 5 4.45 8.51 2.38 1.21 74.0 1.24
Paul Maholm
89 89 3 0 27
33 .450 0 1 554 605 293 274
62 187 359 27 2 10 4.45 5.83 3.04 1.01 65.9 1.43
Jeremy Bonderman
74 74 0 0 28
21 .571 0 0 459 2/3 482 248 228
50 148 391 10 2 16 4.46 7.66 2.90 .98 68.9 1.37
Oliver Perez
83 83 1 0 28
30 .483 0 1 474 439 273 236
65 244 444 24 2 20 4.48 8.43 4.63 1.23 73.4 1.44
Joe Blanton
98 97 4 0 38
34 .528 0 2 616 687 323 307
54 163 356 13 1 8 4.49 5.20 2.38 .79 74.6 1.38
Barry Zito
99 98 0 0 37
39 .487 0 0 589 2/3 573 316 294
66 280 396 21 2 12 4.49 6.04 4.27 1.01 77.4 1.45
Doug Davis
92 92 1 0 30
31 .492 0 1 538 570 291 269
53 256 412 14 1 20 4.50 6.89 4.28 .89 71.2 1.54
Jon Garland
96 95 4 0 42
28 .600 0 2 611 1/3 692 337 306
68 156 298 18 0 8 4.50 4.39 2.30 1.00 71.5 1.39
Tim Wakefield
82 82 2 0 33
34 .493 0 0 499 472 269 251
66 174 308 24 0 28 4.53 5.56 3.14 1.19 62.3 1.29
Jarrod Washburn
91 89 2 1 23
43 .348 1 1 534 1/3 573 292 270
67 172 304 22 1 7 4.55 5.12 2.90 1.13 50.6 1.39
Dave Bush
96 91 3 2 33
31 .516 0 2 573 1/3 576 310 292
82 126 406 39 1 11 4.58 6.37 1.98 1.29 68.3 1.22
Jeff Suppan
96 96 1 0 34
29 .540 0 0 569 1/3 649 322 290
68 203 303 23 1 18 4.58 4.79 3.21 1.07 59.0 1.50
Kyle Lohse
100 83 2 6 28
28 .500 0 1 513 1/3 561 277 262
53 149 335 21 1 11 4.59 5.87 2.61 .93 56.2 1.38
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Ian Snell
94 94 1 0 29
35 .453 0 0 553 1/3 607 304 283
68 230 476 12 1 28 4.60 7.74 3.74 1.11 70.3 1.51
Kenny Rogers
75 74 0 1 29
25 .537 0 0 440 2/3 472 251 228
53 158 217 19 1 10 4.66 4.43 3.23 1.08 43.0 1.43
Paul Byrd
91 91 4 0 36
29 .554 0 2 546 1/3 664 319 283
84 99 254 19 0 7 4.66 4.18 1.63 1.38 51.6 1.40
Scott Olsen
95 95 0 0 30
35 .462 0 0 548 570 328 284
80 227 406 10 0 21 4.66 6.67 3.73 1.31 60.6 1.45
Wandy Rodriguez
84 78 1 1 26
29 .473 0 1 443 2/3 458 260 230
53 167 374 16 2 11 4.67 7.59 3.39 1.08 55.2 1.41
Dontrelle Willis
76 75 4 0 22
29 .431 0 1 447 1/3 489 259 236
53 202 319 33 3 20 4.75 6.42 4.06 1.07 41.6 1.54
Jose Contreras
82 80 4 2 30
32 .484 0 3 506 556 299 271
53 152 317 28 0 25 4.82 5.64 2.70 .94 43.7 1.40
Nate Robertson
93 89 1 1 29
36 .446 0 0 550 1/3 616 312 295
77 188 361 13 1 16 4.82 5.90 3.07 1.26 45.3 1.46
Miguel Batista
111 85 3 9 31
33 .484 1 1 514 1/3 575 306 277
55 248 316 20 3 34 4.85 5.53 4.34 .96 42.8 1.60
Zach Duke
84 83 3 0 18
37 .327 0 2 500 2/3 639 300 271
50 140 243 17 4 10 4.87 4.37 2.52 .90 21.6 1.56
Kevin Millwood
92 92 5 0 35
35 .500 0 0 543 1/3 644 321 296
59 167 393 18 1 12 4.90 6.51 2.77 .98 50.0 1.49
Mark Hendrickson
105 59 1 7 17
31 .354 0 1 420 462 249 229
49 138 272 10 1 14 4.91 5.83 2.96 1.05 25.2 1.43
Vicente Padilla
84 84 1 0 34
28 .548 0 1 485 1/3 533 295 266
63 183 346 41 5 18 4.93 6.42 3.39 1.17 45.3 1.48
Jason Marquis
94 93 1 0 36
34 .514 0 1 546 573 328 306
71 216 292 36 2 12 5.04 4.81 3.56 1.17 32.2 1.45
Matt Morris
70 70 5 0 20
30 .400 0 0 428 2/3 499 277 247
46 131 228 25 3 7 5.19 4.79 2.75 .97 10.1 1.47
Livan Hernandez
97 97 3 0 36
35 .507 0 0 593 1/3 738 365 344
87 198 282 12 3 7 5.22 4.28 3.00 1.32 16.9 1.58
Daniel Cabrera
90 90 5 0 26
38 .406 0 1 532 1/3 536 324 309
60 302 418 38 5 39 5.22 7.07 5.11 1.01 25.0 1.57
Odalis Perez
87 75 0 6 21
30 .412 0 0 419 2/3 521 266 246
54 135 259 15 4 13 5.28 5.55 2.90 1.16 10.7 1.56
Carlos Silva
97 92 3 2 28
44 .389 0 1 535 2/3 688 343 323
78 100 228 15 1 6 5.43 3.83 1.68 1.31 -4.4 1.47
Joel Pineiro
107 60 1 22 21
25 .457 2 0 405 496 258 246
58 123 221 14 1 8 5.47 4.91 2.73 1.29 -0.4 1.53
Player Games GS CG GF W L WPct Sv Sho IP H R ER HR BB K HBP BK WP ERA K9 BB9 HR9 Cy Young Pts WHIP
Josh Fogg
83 74 1 3 23
25 .479 0 1 416 497 283 262
64 146 232 25 0 7 5.67 5.02 3.16 1.38 -7.8 1.55
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions .
Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database