Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Pitcher Comparisons

Select start and end dates, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

You may also specify just home or just road games.

Default dates are first and last games in the database.

Start Date:
End Date:
All Games:
Home Games:
Road Games:
Playing For:
Playing Versus:
At Park:
Sort by:
Descending
Ascending
Minimum Innings Pitched:
Minimum Decisions:
Minimum Games Played:
Minimum Games Started:
Minimum Complete Games:
Minimum Games Finished:
Minimum Wins:
Minimum Losses:
Minimum Saves:
Minimum Shutouts:
Minimum Hits:
Minimum Runs:
Minimum ER:
Minimum Home Runs:
Minimum Walks:
Minimum Strikeouts:
Minimum Hit by Pitch:
Minimum Balks:
Minimum Wild Pitches:
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Zack Greinke 18185010 5.66702127 1/31163830 4211291042.129.121.48.2856.61.08
Dan Haren 1717208 5.61500121 853129 12151192032.168.851.12.8951.4.83
Tim Lincecum 1717309 2.81802121 973430 4301413062.2310.492.23.3053.61.05
Chris Carpenter 1212106 3.6670077 2/3532120 311582002.326.721.27.3530.6.82
Matt Cain 17173010 2.83300115 1/3953331 1146931072.427.263.59.8646.01.22
Randy Wells 1111004 3.5710069 612019 514493102.486.391.83.6524.41.09
Erik Bedard 1212005 2.7140069 2/3562220 623734022.589.432.97.7827.11.13
Edwin Jackson 1717106 4.60000114 2/3903933 933932012.597.302.59.7139.61.07
Felix Hernandez 1717108 3.72701116 2/31034034 83411451112.628.792.62.6243.71.17
Roy Halladay 16163010 2.83301116 1093836 1017982022.797.601.32.7841.81.09
Josh Johnson 1818207 2.77800121 1/31024038 7331022072.827.572.45.5239.91.11
Jair Jurrjens 1818006 7.46200108 1/3964135 741752222.916.233.41.5832.71.26
Nick Blackburn 1717307 4.63600116 1/31204638 1028511012.943.952.17.7732.31.27
R.A. Dickey 2610101 1.5000052 561717 519354032.946.063.29.8713.51.44
Javier Vazquez 1818106 7.46200119 1024239 10231362032.9510.291.74.7640.11.05
Yovani Gallardo 1717108 6.57100109 2/3803736 13511204032.959.854.191.0738.81.19
Wandy Rodriguez 1818108 6.57101112 2/31044437 12401062112.968.473.20.9637.91.28
Ricky Romero 1212007 3.7000079 732626 1027663132.967.523.081.1427.11.27
J.A. Happ 219145 01.0000180 662727 1130573023.046.413.381.2423.71.20
Jarrod Washburn 1616105 6.45501105 1/3903936 1126693013.085.902.22.9428.61.10
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Adam Wainwright 1818009 5.64300122 1/31144742 12451101073.098.093.31.8839.21.30
Dallas Braden 1717006 7.46200106 1/31064137 728671013.135.672.37.5928.91.26
Doug Davis 1818004 8.33300112 1054539 1152841053.136.754.18.8829.41.40
Mark Buehrle 1717009 2.81800114 2/31044340 1425653123.145.101.961.1032.81.12
Chad Billingsley 1818009 4.69200120 1/3944642 8511155053.148.603.81.6038.71.20
Jered Weaver 1717309 3.75001114 1/3954240 1234952023.157.482.68.9435.71.13
Clayton Kershaw 1717006 5.5450093 2/3663434 554951233.279.135.19.4828.31.28
Zach Duke 1717208 7.53301118 1154543 1229593013.284.502.21.9229.91.22
Johan Santana 1717009 7.56200109 1/3984940 15361072013.298.812.961.2334.41.23
Ted Lilly 1717008 6.57100111 1044441 1723970223.327.861.861.3832.21.14
Kevin Millwood 1818208 6.57100124 1185046 1542747053.345.373.051.0931.41.29
James Shields 1818006 6.50000122 2/31305246 1425881113.386.461.831.0330.11.26
Joel Pineiro 1616206 9.40002106 1/31135040 312434013.393.641.02.2523.51.18
John Lannan 1717106 5.54500107 1064741 1238486033.454.043.201.0123.31.35
Cliff Lee 1818104 8.33301120 1384646 831852063.456.382.33.6026.51.41
Johnny Cueto 1717008 5.61500104 1/3894640 1435795023.456.813.021.2128.11.19
Carlos Zambrano 1515004 4.5000096 854037 741756033.477.033.84.6622.51.31
Josh Outman 1412014 1.8000067 1/3533026 925530013.487.083.341.2017.01.16
Randy Wolf 1818003 3.50000108 1/3944542 1531822043.496.812.581.2523.41.15
Justin Verlander 1818209 4.69201115 1/31035146 10351413353.5911.002.73.7834.81.20
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Brad Bergesen 1515105 3.6250097 2/3934239 1023504023.594.612.12.9219.81.19
Jason Marquis 17172011 5.68801117 1/31145247 938541143.614.142.91.6928.11.30
Josh Beckett 17171010 3.76901112 1015245 10351033103.628.282.81.8031.31.21
Max Scherzer 1717005 6.4550096 1/3914739 939974103.649.063.64.8423.91.35
Scott Richmond 1613116 5.5450085 1/3723735 1530710043.697.493.161.5820.81.20
CC Sabathia 1818208 5.61501121 2/31015350 1135896043.706.582.59.8127.71.12
Matt Garza 1717006 6.50000109 1/3884645 1444954013.707.823.621.1525.21.21
Aaron Cook 1717108 3.72701103 1084643 1331521013.764.542.711.1421.71.35
John Danks 1616007 6.5380095 2/3864240 1132854003.768.003.011.0323.31.23
A.J. Burnett 1717008 4.66700107 1/3954845 145310170133.778.474.441.1726.81.38
Roy Oswalt 1818205 4.55600113 1/31104848 1431894043.817.072.461.1122.61.24
Jason Vargas 1311013 3.5000063 2/3672927 1019410003.825.802.691.4111.91.35
Ubaldo Jimenez 1717106 8.42900109 2/31014847 545936243.867.633.69.4123.11.33
Brian Bannister 1515006 6.5000090 2/3894839 828553143.875.462.78.7917.81.29
Aaron Harang 1818205 8.38501111 1285348 1626953033.897.702.111.3022.01.39
Scott Feldman 1714007 2.7780089 2/3764039 1130454233.914.523.011.1017.31.18
Jake Peavy 1313106 6.5000081 2/3693836 728921123.9710.143.09.7720.01.19
Kyle Lohse 1010104 4.5000156 1/3532825 616393123.996.232.56.9611.11.22
Joba Chamberlain 1616004 2.6670084 2/3884738 1141749114.047.874.361.1715.71.52
Koji Uehara 1212002 4.3330066 2/3713330 712480004.056.481.62.9410.11.25
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Justin Masterson 256033 2.6000064 1/3643029 522586024.068.113.08.7012.01.34
Jason Hammel 1714105 4.5560086 1/31004739 921591024.076.152.19.9415.11.40
Ryan Dempster 1717005 5.50000105 2/31015348 1344894054.097.583.751.1118.71.37
Phil Hughes 187023 2.6000050 1/3442423 718475114.118.403.221.25 9.91.23
Russ Ortiz 199033 4.4290070 703532 637543014.116.944.76.7711.41.53
Sean Marshall 278143 6.3330059 552927 821391014.125.953.201.22 9.41.29
Jeff Niemann 1615117 4.6360182 2/3834238 835465054.145.013.81.8714.91.43
Rick Porcello 1616008 6.5710087 964540 1331471134.144.863.211.3416.21.46
Gil Meche 1818104 8.33301104 1/31075448 946812074.146.993.97.7816.31.47
Jon Lester 1717207 6.53800106 1085249 13331232044.1610.442.801.1023.31.33
Mike Hampton 1414005 5.5000080 774037 831521004.165.853.49.9013.21.35
Bartolo Colon 1111003 6.3330055 1/3633926 1220360014.235.863.251.95 8.31.50
Kenshin Kawakami 1616005 6.4550088 2/3844842 1036685064.266.903.651.0214.11.35
Hiroki Kuroda 99003 5.3750052 2/3482725 511380044.276.491.88.85 8.11.12
Tim Wakefield 17172011 3.78600108 2/31135252 837619034.315.053.06.6619.41.38
Gavin Floyd 1717106 6.50000108 1025652 841852054.337.083.42.6716.51.32
Glen Perkins 1212004 4.5000074 803636 714351124.384.261.70.85 8.51.27
Andrew Miller 1412003 4.4290071 1/3703935 531551064.426.943.91.63 9.21.42
Barry Zito 1717105 8.38500101 2/3955050 1144797224.436.993.90.9713.71.37
Chris Volstad 1818106 8.42901107 1/31015753 1730772064.446.462.521.4314.41.22
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Joe Saunders 1717108 5.61501107 1/31065653 2037615124.445.113.101.6814.81.33
Sean West 99003 3.5000050 1/3442725 724282024.475.014.291.25 6.01.35
Seth McClung 312053 2.6000050 1/3492525 929321024.475.725.191.61 6.41.55
Micah Owings 1615016 8.4290090 1/3944945 1344565014.485.584.381.3011.81.53
Kevin Correia 1717005 7.4170098 1/3935149 1133792004.487.233.021.0113.11.28
Garrett Olson 168023 2.6000056 502928 1218323004.505.142.891.93 6.21.21
Mike Pelfrey 1616006 4.6000091 2/31055246 634473514.524.613.34.5910.51.52
Jordan Zimmermann 1414003 3.5000079 2/3844240 825783004.528.812.82.9010.61.37
John Maine 1111005 4.5560061 2/3513331 734422034.526.134.961.02 9.01.38
Andy Pettitte 1717008 4.66700103 1/31145852 1442693014.536.013.661.2214.61.51
Vicente Padilla 1515007 4.6360089 1/3964745 739497244.534.943.93.7111.61.51
Jose Contreras 1212004 7.3640073 1/3704137 822551024.546.752.70.98 9.21.25
Derek Lowe 1818007 7.50000106 2/31175854 536563134.564.723.04.4211.91.43
Livan Hernandez 1616105 4.5560096 2/31105049 1234511004.564.753.171.12 9.41.49
Paul Maholm 1818006 4.60000109 2/31255956 536664184.605.422.95.4111.41.47
Mark Hendrickson 247074 4.5000056 1/3673729 921391004.636.233.361.44 7.11.56
Ross Ohlendorf 1717007 7.50000101 1035352 1426557014.634.902.321.2511.01.28
Brett Myers 1010004 3.5710063 2/3663333 1720464014.666.502.832.40 7.41.35
Trevor Cahill 1818005 8.3850098 1/31005851 1841473024.674.303.751.65 7.91.43
Brad Penny 1616006 3.6670088 2/31045246 1028614024.676.192.841.0210.41.49
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Joe Blanton 1616005 4.5560096 1055050 1832852014.697.973.001.6911.51.43
Jeff Suppan 1818005 6.4550099 2/31175752 1343537044.704.793.881.17 8.11.61
Cole Hamels 1616105 5.5000192 1104948 1218791014.707.731.761.1710.91.39
Clayton Richard 2311133 2.6000072 814238 930553244.756.883.751.12 6.51.54
Braden Looper 1717007 4.6360096 1055751 1830573024.785.342.811.69 9.71.41
Jon Garland 1717004 8.33300101 1/31175954 1039392024.803.463.46.89 4.61.54
Randy Johnson 1717008 6.5710091 2/3905149 1831801154.817.853.041.7712.81.32
Jeff Karstens 2110063 4.4290072 1/3754039 1029292004.853.613.611.24 3.11.44
Brett Anderson 1515105 7.4170183 1/3925545 1324613104.866.592.591.40 7.81.39
Kevin Slowey 16160010 3.7690090 2/31135049 1515755034.867.441.491.4913.81.41
Matt Palmer 1611127 1.8750074 714240 734424054.865.114.14.85 8.21.42
Craig Stammen 99001 4.2000051 2/3533128 511252044.884.351.92.87 1.31.24
Brandon McCarthy 1111105 2.7140164 663635 1126442004.926.193.661.55 6.41.44
Brad Thompson 167082 5.2860053 583129 714194124.923.232.381.19 1.41.36
Brian Tallet 2117025 6.45500103 2/3986057 1251783014.956.774.431.04 7.61.44
Chad Gaudin 1514004 7.3640082 1/3724846 644855145.039.294.81.66 7.71.41
Armando Galarraga 1717005 7.4170093 1015452 1741623005.036.003.971.65 5.71.53
Jorge de la Rosa 1717006 7.4620095 2/3925754 945984055.089.224.23.85 9.61.43
Luke Hochevar 99104 3.5710051 1/3473129 719214025.083.683.331.23 2.81.29
John Lackey 1111003 4.4290066 794138 818555055.187.502.451.09 3.51.47
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Chris Young 1414004 6.4000076 704744 1240502015.215.924.741.42 3.01.45
Shairon Martis 1515105 3.6250085 2/3835250 1139344035.253.574.101.16 1.21.42
Jonathan Sanchez 1613022 8.2000069 2/3724441 746684075.308.785.94.90 2.61.69
Scott Baker 1616006 7.4620095 965756 1720781035.317.391.891.61 5.31.22
Jeremy Guthrie 1818106 8.42900101 1106660 2034625005.355.523.031.78 2.71.43
Rich Harden 1313005 5.5000069 714541 1532772025.3510.044.171.96 6.21.49
Ian Snell 1515102 8.2000080 2/3875048 744521035.365.804.91.78-0.51.62
Carl Pavano 1717107 7.5000199 1206459 1120713035.366.451.821.00 4.61.41
Ricky Nolasco 1515106 6.5000084 2/3965651 1020821025.428.722.131.06 5.51.37
Josh Geer 1513001 3.2500084 925551 1917432005.464.611.822.04-3.71.30
Francisco Liriano 1717004 8.3330096 2/3996059 1344884055.498.194.101.21 2.11.48
Todd Wellemeyer 1818007 7.50000100 1256462 1345643015.585.764.051.17 1.41.70
Brian Moehler 1414105 5.5000073 1/3864946 1423493035.656.012.821.72 0.61.49
Dave Bush 1514003 4.4290081 835351 18265910015.676.562.892.00-1.61.35
Jamie Moyer 1616007 6.5380089 2/31085757 1924517105.725.122.411.91-0.11.47
Chris Jakubauskas 218115 6.4550064 1/3634341 820301045.744.202.801.12-0.81.29
Kyle Davies 1414103 7.3000079 2/3815551 1441544045.766.104.631.58-2.81.53
Jeremy Sowers 1110012 7.2220057 2/3653837 725301005.774.683.901.09-3.21.56
Chan Ho Park 247043 2.6000056 643736 525464025.797.394.02.80-0.41.59
Bronson Arroyo 1717108 8.50000103 1217467 2141545015.854.723.581.83-2.11.57
PlayerGamesGSCGGFW L WPctSvShoIPHRERHRBBKHBPBKWP ERAK9BB9HR9Cy Young Pts WHIP
Derek Holland 177003 5.3750057 1/3714138 1117440325.976.912.671.73-1.91.53
Scott Olsen 1010002 4.3330056 2/3744138 923410026.046.513.651.43-3.61.71
David Huff 1010004 3.5710052 633635 816301006.065.192.771.38-2.01.52
Matt Harrison 1111204 5.4440163 1/3814343 923342006.114.833.271.28-3.91.64
Ross Detwiler 1010100 5.0000052 693837 322331026.405.713.81.52-7.71.75
Andy Sonnanstine 1515006 7.4620081 2/31036160 1522502036.615.512.421.65-8.21.53
Felipe Paulino 1310002 5.2860052 2/3704339 1018483046.668.203.081.71-5.91.67
Scott Kazmir 1212004 5.4440062 785349 1133502097.117.264.791.60-9.01.79
Fausto Carmona 1212002 6.2500060 2/3695550 941363047.425.346.081.34-14.11.81
Manny Parra 1313003 8.2730064 2/3835754 941551047.527.655.711.25-13.21.92

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database