Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
March 13, 2007
Pitcher's Luck

Speaking to a reporter this afternoon about the Probabilistic Model of Range (PMR), I realized I never published the chart of how pitchers were helped or hurt by their defense in 2006. So without further ado:

Probabilistic Model of Range, Fielders Behind Pitchers, 2006. Smoothed Visit Model with Distance for Fly Balls
Pitcher Team In Play Actual Outs Predicted Outs DER Predicted DER Difference
Kris Benson Bal 595 425 402.81 0.714 0.677 0.03730
Chris Young SD 468 357 339.63 0.763 0.726 0.03712
Ervin R Santana LAA 603 435 412.64 0.721 0.684 0.03708
Roy Halladay Tor 686 491 466.71 0.716 0.680 0.03540
Kevin Millwood Tex 670 458 434.82 0.684 0.649 0.03460
Joel Pineiro Sea 569 378 361.55 0.664 0.635 0.02891
Kenny Rogers Det 656 472 454.00 0.720 0.692 0.02743
Chris Carpenter StL 638 455 437.61 0.713 0.686 0.02726
David T Bush Mil 621 440 423.21 0.709 0.681 0.02704
Jeff Suppan StL 634 435 420.48 0.686 0.663 0.02290
Carlos Zambrano ChC 563 409 396.36 0.726 0.704 0.02244
Johan Santana Min 603 433 419.91 0.718 0.696 0.02171
Tim Wakefield Bos 440 320 310.49 0.727 0.706 0.02162
Chris Capuano Mil 677 461 446.73 0.681 0.660 0.02108
Woody Williams SD 489 350 339.78 0.716 0.695 0.02089
Kirk Saarloos Oak 421 287 278.99 0.682 0.663 0.01902
Noah Lowry SF 521 370 360.15 0.710 0.691 0.01890
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 758 526 511.78 0.694 0.675 0.01875
John Smoltz Atl 662 457 444.95 0.690 0.672 0.01820
Bronson Arroyo Cin 707 509 496.17 0.720 0.702 0.01815
Mike Mussina NYY 570 395 384.84 0.693 0.675 0.01783
Steve Trachsel NYM 552 389 379.44 0.705 0.687 0.01733
Greg Maddux ChC 454 311 303.18 0.685 0.668 0.01722
Matt Morris SF 687 481 469.65 0.700 0.684 0.01652
Brandon Webb Ari 701 483 472.33 0.689 0.674 0.01522
Nate Robertson Det 640 448 438.33 0.700 0.685 0.01512
Jose Contreras CWS 614 433 424.27 0.705 0.691 0.01421
Carlos Silva Min 664 446 436.62 0.672 0.658 0.01413
Ricky Nolasco Fla 443 298 291.93 0.673 0.659 0.01371
Josh Johnson Fla 440 311 305.16 0.707 0.694 0.01328
Josh Beckett Bos 590 429 421.42 0.727 0.714 0.01284
Roy Oswalt Hou 668 459 450.87 0.687 0.675 0.01217
Randy Johnson NYY 590 416 409.33 0.705 0.694 0.01131
Erik Bedard Bal 583 394 387.98 0.676 0.665 0.01033
Jon Garland CWS 715 486 479.00 0.680 0.670 0.00979
Josh Fogg Col 581 394 388.42 0.678 0.669 0.00960
Freddy Garcia CWS 695 494 487.36 0.711 0.701 0.00955
Gil Meche Sea 539 372 366.94 0.690 0.681 0.00939
Jaret Wright NYY 467 313 308.80 0.670 0.661 0.00899
Felix A Hernandez Sea 551 371 366.17 0.673 0.665 0.00877
Eric Milton Cin 495 354 349.80 0.715 0.707 0.00848
Justin B Verlander Det 564 394 389.49 0.699 0.691 0.00800
Mark Buehrle CWS 688 471 465.66 0.685 0.677 0.00776
Jason Jennings Col 655 456 451.33 0.696 0.689 0.00713
Dan Haren Oak 668 466 461.60 0.698 0.691 0.00658
Jamie Moyer Sea 531 370 366.51 0.697 0.690 0.00656
Jason Schmidt SF 607 432 428.09 0.712 0.705 0.00643
Jarrod Washburn Sea 619 437 433.23 0.706 0.700 0.00609
Jeff W Francis Col 626 445 441.42 0.711 0.705 0.00572
Aaron Cook Col 744 507 503.15 0.681 0.676 0.00517
Clay A Hensley SD 571 402 399.10 0.704 0.699 0.00509
Casey Fossum TB 413 284 281.93 0.688 0.683 0.00502
Tim Hudson Atl 705 482 479.36 0.684 0.680 0.00375
Tom Glavine NYM 621 431 429.08 0.694 0.691 0.00310
Matt Cain SF 528 383 381.46 0.725 0.722 0.00291
Derek Lowe LAD 716 492 490.39 0.687 0.685 0.00225
Curt Schilling Bos 592 399 397.74 0.674 0.672 0.00212
Vicente Padilla Tex 608 415 414.25 0.683 0.681 0.00123
John Lackey LAA 635 433 432.39 0.682 0.681 0.00096
Rodrigo Lopez Bal 616 407 407.54 0.661 0.662 -0.00087
Brad Radke Min 549 371 371.63 0.676 0.677 -0.00114
John V Koronka Tex 424 294 294.76 0.693 0.695 -0.00178
Brad Penny LAD 583 386 387.05 0.662 0.664 -0.00180
Ted Lilly Tor 524 362 363.16 0.691 0.693 -0.00221
Doug Davis Mil 619 421 422.39 0.680 0.682 -0.00225
Jason Marquis StL 648 456 457.72 0.704 0.706 -0.00266
Jake Westbrook Cle 720 479 480.93 0.665 0.668 -0.00268
Jamey Wright SF 507 354 355.81 0.698 0.702 -0.00357
Scott M Olsen Fla 490 348 349.80 0.710 0.714 -0.00367
Andy Pettitte Hou 652 430 433.13 0.660 0.664 -0.00480
Mark Redman KC 573 385 387.79 0.672 0.677 -0.00488
Miguel Batista Ari 692 467 470.53 0.675 0.680 -0.00510
Brian Moehler Fla 436 283 285.38 0.649 0.655 -0.00545
Jon Lieber Phi 557 378 381.60 0.679 0.685 -0.00647
Paul G Maholm Pit 559 371 375.05 0.664 0.671 -0.00724
Paul Byrd Cle 647 426 430.91 0.658 0.666 -0.00760
Tony Armas Jr. Was 500 343 346.80 0.686 0.694 -0.00760
Esteban Loaiza Oak 520 351 355.50 0.675 0.684 -0.00866
Byung-Hyun Kim Col 473 306 310.22 0.647 0.656 -0.00893
Jake Peavy SD 542 372 377.82 0.686 0.697 -0.01074
Wandy E Rodriguez Hou 427 281 285.85 0.658 0.669 -0.01135
Jeremy Bonderman Det 615 413 420.29 0.672 0.683 -0.01186
Cliff Lee Cle 658 455 463.03 0.691 0.704 -0.01220
Chan Ho Park SD 436 302 307.47 0.693 0.705 -0.01254
C.C. Sabathia Cle 562 383 390.88 0.681 0.696 -0.01402
Barry Zito Oak 655 464 473.26 0.708 0.723 -0.01414
Javier Vazquez CWS 594 399 407.80 0.672 0.687 -0.01481
Claudio Vargas Ari 538 365 373.65 0.678 0.695 -0.01607
Zach Duke Pit 726 480 491.99 0.661 0.678 -0.01651
Ian D Snell Pit 539 362 371.02 0.672 0.688 -0.01673
Sean C Marshall ChC 400 280 287.55 0.700 0.719 -0.01888
Kelvim Escobar LAA 570 383 394.00 0.672 0.691 -0.01930
Brett Myers Phi 549 378 388.95 0.689 0.708 -0.01994
Ramon Ortiz Was 654 442 457.19 0.676 0.699 -0.02323
Dontrelle Willis Fla 690 466 482.36 0.675 0.699 -0.02372
Joe M Blanton Oak 668 439 456.28 0.657 0.683 -0.02586
Ryan Madson Phi 441 278 291.21 0.630 0.660 -0.02994
Livan Hernandez Was 496 332 346.94 0.669 0.699 -0.03012
Aaron Harang Cin 684 454 476.58 0.664 0.697 -0.03301

Looking at the Hardball Times, Benson has a much better ERA than FIP, as does Chris Young. Hernandez is negative for Washington, as is Harang for Cincinnati. So it looks like the arrows are pointing in the right direction.

In discussing this, another question arose. Which pitchers give their fielders the easiest balls to field? We can answer that by sorting on Predicted DER. At the top of the list is Young, Zito, Cain, Sean Marshall and Scott Olsen. At the bottom, the worst was Joel Pineiro, followed by Millwood, Moehler, B. Kim and Carlos Silva. Now you need to be careful with those number, since home field has a say in this (more balls turn into outs in PETCO). I'm going to try to work on an adjustment for that. However, not that Young also led this category in 2005 in a completely different home park and league.


Comments

Great stuff, David. Thanks for posting it.

Posted by: Phil at March 13, 2007 11:30 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?