Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
October 16, 2006
Opinions Change

I remember when these signings weren't thought of so warmly:

The Tigers' pitching is excellent, but the position players have distinguished themselves with clutch hitting and resilience. One of Dombrowski's investments was Magglio Ordonez, who left the Chicago White Sox for a five-year, $75 million contract in Detroit. Ordonez had two home runs in the decisive Game 4 of the Tigers' sweep of Oakland on Saturday night, including a game-ending three-run homer.

He was worth every cent.

Catcher Ivan Rodriguez was overpaid with $40 million over four years, but his handling of the pitching staff, especially the younger pitchers, has been flawless.

No one has complained about the money.

When Ordonez played just 82 games in 2005, fans complained about the money. Why would Dombrowski spend so much on an oft-injured player? When Ivan's weight and offensive production dropped in 2005, people complained about the money. Both those deals took a while to pay dividends.


Posted by David Pinto at 08:26 AM | Management | TrackBack (0)
Comments

I remember thinking that maybe it was a bit too much to spend, but it did help to show the Tiger fans and other players that they were serious about improving after their awful 2003. Unlike some other teams who sign free agents in order to appear competitive -- I'm looking at you Pittsburgh -- the Tigers went the rest of the way with it, continuing to develop quality minor leaguers, scan the waiver wire and add useful free agent parts. I was mostly upset about the Magglio signing solely because no one knew how his knee would hold up, but the Tigers took a huge gamble and came out successful because of it.

Posted by: Marc Normandin at October 16, 2006 08:43 AM

i thought the Pudge signing was brilliant, but the Magglio signing was moronic. i've never understood why pudge is undervalued, as if hof catchers fall off trees.

Posted by: Tim at October 16, 2006 09:44 AM

I remember lots of negative reaction to both signings -- especially Magglio, who was perceived as a huge risk because of his injury history. The conventional wisdom was that the best free agents didn't even consider Detroit, forcing the Tigers to overpay for free-agent question marks. Both signings have turned out to be positives, but they were not perceived as such at the time.

By the way, what did Dombrowski see in Pudge Rodriguez that nobody else saw? As he left the Rangers, Pudge was seen as a selfish player and a defensive liability (good thrower, but poor at calling a game and working with pitchers), likely entering the decline phase of his career because he had caught a lot of games. In the 2002 offseason, he attracted very little interest on the free-agent market.

Dombrowski brought him in to the Marlins for their 2003 championship, and then brought him to Detroit. Both teams had extremely successful young pitching staffs. Rodriguez has to get some credit for both accomplishments. At the very least, the teams were unaffected by his perceived shortcomings as a handler of pitchers.

Posted by: johnw at October 16, 2006 09:54 AM

$15M per year for Ordonez is still too much, but when you are the pre-2006 Tigers you really have to over pay to get decent players. If the Tigers had not offered $15M per year for Ordonez they would not have gotten a $10M per year right fielder who could clinch a league championship with a walk-off, three-run home run.

Posted by: Doug Purdie at October 16, 2006 01:21 PM

I wanted to go back and see my reaction back in March when I wrote the Tigers team preview, and it sort of echoes the above sentiments from my first comment:

"Was Ordonez overpaid? Yes. Was the contract too long? Yes. Was taking a risk on a player with injury problems a bad move? No. Ordonez is capable of hitting, although not at the levels of yesteryear, and he certainly presents an injury problem with his knee condition. He can provide above average production though, and his signing helped to show the Tigers front office was serious about putting a productive team on the field. I don't usually agree with that sort of move, but bringing the fan base back should be high on the list of things to do after your team almost sets the all-time single season loss record, and the Ordonez moves, as well as the ones that preceeded it, certainly seem to have succeeded in doing that."

Posted by: Marc Normandin at October 17, 2006 08:25 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?