Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
April 01, 2006
AL East Preview

Not to be boring, but you can guess how the AL East looks this year:

  1. New York Yankees
  2. Boston Red Sox
  3. Toronto Blue Jays
  4. Baltimore Orioles
  5. Tampa Bay Devil Rays

The biggest positive for the Devil Rays going into 2006 is their middle infield. Cantu and Lugo combined for 42 win shares in 2005. And even though Lugo is past his peak, the Rays have B.J. Upton waiting in the wings.

Cantu is the typical Rays prospect. His strength in putting up a good batting average is offset by his overall weakness in getting on base. The hope is as these players mature, they do a better job getting on, as Carl Crawford did last year. Rocco Baldelli gets a chance to make that improvement this year as he returns from an injury. The Rays centerfielders were so bad last year that anything from Rocco is bound to be better.

I don't understand why they continue to go with Travis Lee at first. They need to find a hulk with power who can take advantage of that ballpark. It's an easy way to improve the offense of the club. Still I like the fact it's a mostly young club that has room for improvement.

Kamir and McClung are two pitcher who have half the game figured out. They strike out a lot of hitters, but they walk way too many. They need to control that. When McClung came to the majors, his home runs per nine went way up. If he gets that under control, his walks won't hurt as much.

The bullpen is a mess. Shinji Mori's season ended before it got started with an injury. Chad Orvella looks to be the go to guy in the bullpen, and if he can come close to his minor league strikeout and walk numbers, he should be a good one.

The Rays are an up and coming team, but this won't be the year they make a big move. The most interesting thing to watch this year is how the new management team handles the team.

The Orioles played two season last year, one in which they were the best team in the east, another in which they were the worst. They let Sosa and Palmeiro go, but the team is not on a youth movement. They simply moved around players, brought in batters like Millar and Hernandez, and are going to give at bats to people like Jeff Conine. I really don't see the offense getting much better.

However, there's a lot of potential in the starting pitching, Leo Mazzone to develop it. In terms of 2005 win shares, the staff is comparable to the Yankees, but with a much higher upside. Look first pitch strikes on the low outside corner in April. If you see that, you know Leo got through to the staff. But without the pitching improving significantly, I really don't see the Orioles making a move this season.

The Blue Jays were very active in the off-season, spending a heap of money on two pitchers, A.J. Burnett and B.J. Ryan. They also traded defense for offense, landing Troy Glaus for Orland Hudson. Yes, they're improved. Yes, they were unlucky last year, and that has a way of evening things out. I just don't see them winning the division.

The offense just isn't that good. The aggregate of the batters isn't that different than the Devil Rays. What they have is the best pitching in the division, but not that much better than the Red Sox. And the Red Sox are a mile ahead of them offensively. Toronto should be over .500, but they need to play New York and Boston very well and win the close games, unlike 2005. That's the only way they'll be in contention for the title.

The best news for Boston this spring is that Curt Schilling appears to be healthy. A full season of a good Schilling keeps Boston even with Toronto on the mound. And although they appeared to be trading offense for defense this winter, I'm not sure they succeeded. Yes, shortstop is going to stop many more balls than last year, but I'm not convinced that third, second and center are any better. They might even be worse.

The offense with Manny and Ortiz in the middle is very good, but still far behind the Yankees. I'm not sure that the pitching can make up the difference, so my pick of Boston for second.

The Yankees offense looks every bit as good as the 1998 team. Even if all the over 30 players fell off 10% from last year, no other division rival would be close. About the only things that's going to keep New York from leading the league in runs are season ending injuries to A-Rod and Sheffield.

The pitching is another matter. The front end is old, the back end is injured. However, they don't need to be great to win. This team reminds me of the 1992-93 Blue Jays. Take a couple of old pitchers, score 6 or 7 runs a game for them and Morris and Stewart kept you in the game. With the level of offense, they'll survive the pitching.


Posted by David Pinto at 09:25 PM | Predictions | TrackBack (0)
Comments

Orvella was optioned to the minors, making the pen even worse in TB.

Posted by: Adam B. at April 1, 2006 09:50 PM

i just dont have a good feeling about boston (and im not even a yankee fan)... i think the best move they made over the winter was getting milly mo because him and trot make a really solid platoon. Their entire infield is brand new andi dont think youkliss has proven himself yet and their. lowell is doing terrible so far in spring training and loretta is a complete mystery. Alex Gonzalez is no Jeter. Beckett (and burnett) will see their numbers worsen but nothing like pavano.

The thing that i dont like about toronto is their middle infield. things could get really ugly there. i think vernon wells will have a solid year now that he has more protection. overbay has always been waiting for a breakout season and in this lineup it could be this year.

they have two dominating pitchers who are also big injury risks. if both of them go down (burnett is already down) then things could get ugly fast.

Posted by: tony flynn at April 2, 2006 12:06 AM

First, I would say Youkilis has done about all he can to prove himself ready. In 287 ML ab's he hit .265 with a .376 OBP and .787 OPS. In AAA last year he hit .322 with a .444 OBP and 8 homers in just 152 AB's. Those are pretty solid numbers. As for Lowell, I haven't seen him play, but even though the power seems to be still missing this spring, he has hit for decent average and is still taking his walks. Loretta has a career OBP of .365 and average of .301...the only low number from last year was his average and power, and his thumb is fine now. I'm also convinced that Crisp is going to have a monster year. This isn't science talking, just call it a hunch/prayer.

As for the pitching, theoretically the Sox should have one of the better pens in the AL. This is assuming Tavarez, Riske, and Saenz all do close to what Boston expects them to do. I would say that as long as 2 of 3 don't dissappoint too much, Boston should be in good shape. Meanwhile, out of Schilling, Beckett, and Foulke, 2 of the 3 need to perform at a high level. Papelbon can probably fill in if something happens to one of them, and the Sox have 4-5 relievers in the minors that are pretty close to ML ready, but still need decent seasons out of them.

I would say that the Red Sox have about as many question marks as the Yankees, especially in terms of pitching. In fact I think the Sox staff starts out significantly stronger then the Yanks, with far more room for error. Does anyone really think Wang, Chacon, and Small will repeat their 06 performances? Is Mussina going to keep sliding like he has the last 2 years? Is RJ RJ? Will Farnsworth combust under the pressure of NY? (He is known as a hothead) Can Rivera's arm keep doing what it's been doing? Will Damon/Giambi/Sheffield/Posada stay healthy? I'd say the odds of the Sox staff staying healthy and productive are at least as good as, and probably better, then the odds of the Yanks staff staying healthy and as strong as they were last year. One other note, I'm fairly convinced that Pavano and Wright aren't going to return to any sort of high level of productivity. Wright has a shot, but how long has it been since Pavano pitched well against somebody? One potential X-Factor, though, is Dotel. He could end up becoming a HUGE signing for the Yanks.

Posted by: josh at April 2, 2006 01:01 AM

My analysis (using OPS+ for offense, ERA+ for pitching, and ZR for defense) says that the Red Sox will win the AL East. Yankees have the better offense by 4 points of OPS+. The Red Sox have the better pitching by 4 points of ERA+. The Red Sox have the better defense by .009 ZR. The Sox also have the better farm system with 4 of BA's top 100 vs. 2 for the Yankees

Yankees vs. Red Sox comparison

Posted by: Jason at April 3, 2006 12:46 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?