Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
January 15, 2006
Paise for Tracy

Jim Tracy gets rave reviews from the Pirates attending the team's mini-camp. The new manager runs things very differently than Lloyd McClendon and the players like it. Here's Zach Duke:

"(This staff is) making sure that the personal relationships are established," Duke said on a special edition of "The Tim Benz Show." "When I came to the Pirates last year, it kind of felt like I didn't want to step on any toes or ruffle any feathers. Here, it's an open door policy and it really feels that way.

"When it came to (the previous) coaching staff, I didn't feel like I could come to them with whatever I had on my mind. It was all business. It seems that I can come to (this staff) with some more personal stuff this time."

In the interview, Duke described the motivation methods of McClendon and Williams as "a tear-down process."

"They were going to bark at you this way and if you didn't do it right they were going to yell at you," Duke explained.

Neither Tracy nor any of his coaches yelled at their players during this mini-camp. Such professionalism, amongst other things, did not go unnoticed by Duke and his teammates.

Ryan Vogelsong had this to say:

"It was great," pitcher Ryan Vogelsong said of mini-camp. "It was more structured than in the past. There was more detail. The workouts were definitely a little more intense than normal.

"Before, we would get the instructions, but it was more like we were just going through the movements. At this camp, we were getting the instructions and going through the drills, but things were crisp.

"I almost felt like it was two weeks into spring training, not mini-camp."

And John Grabow:

"Not to rag too much on the last manager, but in the past, if something was wrong, you didn't necessarily find out about it right away. With these guys, you hear about it immediately. It's like they instantly detect something that's wrong and let you know how to go about fixing it.

"Plus, they listen to you, too. That seems like one of the strengths of this manager and these coaches -- listening to the players and getting to know what guys can do. It's not, 'This is the way it's going to be,' like it was in the past. As a player, it seems like you're going to get a chance to work through your problems with the coaches. That kind of communication and working environment starts with our manager."

We'll see if this leads to better results on the field.


Posted by David Pinto at 11:36 AM | Management | TrackBack (0)
Comments

The upshot of this article, to my eyes, is that McClendon really, really sucked as a manager. Every good manager of employees anywhere - MLB, Burger King, whatever - should know the phrase "praise in public, punish in private". This is basic knowledge of how to win people's respect. Lloyd didn't have it.

Posted by: John Pontoon at January 15, 2006 12:12 PM

"praise in public, punish in private"

- Tracy certainly does that with the guys he likes. The guys he doesn't like, well ...

And don't get me wrong - sometimes he doesn't like exactly the right guys. But the guy's no saint.

Posted by: Jon at January 15, 2006 01:28 PM

Well, even though he never played Choi (for example), to my knowledge he never was recorded questioning Choi's heart or anything.

Anyhow, I wasn't really trying To say that Tracy's great. Just pointing out that McClendon sucked.

Posted by: John Pontoon at January 15, 2006 04:30 PM

i think it is tough to do your best for a boss you can't talk to or trust

and if you have questions or need help and you can't feel comfortable doing that, well, you and your team ain't going nowhere

i think every manager got pets and dogs. even bobby cox...

Posted by: lisa gray at January 15, 2006 06:39 PM

Just to provide some perspective - here's an excerpt from Ron Cook's Post-Gazette column of Oct. 24, 2000:

"It has been a long time since a manager or coach made such a terrific first impression in this town. Maybe not everyone who had a chance to talk to [McClendon] at Three Rivers Stadium yesterday felt like putting on a uniform and going outside for some batting practice, but a lot did. I haven't felt that way since Johnny Majors took over at Pitt in 1973."

Looks like Tracy is getting the same gushing press coverage every new manager gets - let's see if his reviews are any better than McClendon's 3 or 4 years down the road.

Posted by: Mark B. at January 17, 2006 06:01 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?